1 20 1 https://omeka.lib.jmu.edu/erp/files/original/Rockingham_County_Criminal_Court_Criminal_Cases/ccr001_006_154-commonwealth-v-pink-barbour.pdf 64f830799f31dd0cc38c98a155365195 PDF Text Text w.. '· .... ,'?. .tt-:li_,,.....,...... "ftrx, :f~ 1 tJ".n!, )'iA ..:r••1~3 ,., " , otnbl .. ts ,.._, ., L- r,~c " •• "'~''Yl'I ., et ' 0 J'.Nl_j; ~ ' ~10 n - tl.e Bc.t\l:lr, . • WUB • t 'tl ] r.t '1£-1 ., ~c C •• b u. ., • tl a 11 te, ,. •• r •t; ->I~:. ' " ...~ 0 '1"'11. _ th• J'• • tl": 1. 1 .... •rt~ nee ,., ,,, t' "c ied V BC.Get J'. .. t, .• • L-,.1 ,., "' • ~ '1 ,. t ~,i A-- - ·- <.. t1' ,-....,..,.t ritnese, ". - " •d. ' -a.y. ,,,..; ' ar.d C t. ,,,1; ...... • ..., • to anrt. t Lee A .. ...1 ., e 1 t -,.e L'ic:.ien -wid~, • <1' r •• 1. ., - nt h"r, .. r••• • 12.JK-.; ~i!:'.B~-..- ar.d , e I l'" ! •• i L • •t .. ' ataolo t•·-t.w thto·~. ~ -t , .!.!' ,. -• •• 1;,arb1.,..r went r •- ...i:rne.rt to • t· Jl 0 • t t 1rti l::t, 1t!'".".'I ~io.c. e t'11'le ott1.c.•, + '"' 1 I i t"• "'t t ke4 ' ,d t t "tr.~d ·v~m .,,--41 1 ,. .,..l"~·r 'f"TI ll-:-.. ,•1 8't>C' t t'· li ~l to n ,._. "'t' Jot r t t .. • ~ ' .,., • to I": , k no·t; 1;_,-.· OU!' t t~• '\'.'...,i"'S. e.r.d E"' l'-,.. ,..,....., 61 u to .J. ,. e, 1'1 1,1 s e i ..• t.. ·•· " ,._a:,,ln. ~-1~etr 8, l11, r11:0<1, r, ::i '.p"'""'t • 0 ~ t n te1 I ,. r, T' ' •• ;)~ up• 6~ C""" ,..,_ tf'~"I"n d t'JO:' , l!l8.~ ign-:-•ttl"'I \ h.1 ' n ; t:-iess .... 1! he mi t e •:1 C ·Jl!--f!~r!f'! t' - t a man. l at.er St.re,. at t""'"" ••• cm:J.<t net. r:o ''ltn t. 01 11. him 'l'T',..!'! •'8 t~, • ~1 • ~-• t: z:.art 1~ tt . ~-' r• J..,e ,ms 4• n:, t·.•• ;-r:r't. I ~ " .,. .;a.!!.~$ tint "t ~12 M ,. ..."',..n ne• nf' t.te stJ-11'1•, at• Yl)<n 6 ~ t •e • n.e:- le }roted 8 i~ ' �7 • • �• ••r------------------------------~--~-~--~---~-~---~ Loft • • ... ,.,. ..... --e,..,. • ornor I rs t .,..~- t 1 • ' t Witr.'!, --- 9 U.t • r '== • 8 • • """ C ~t..r. )I' - -- • s• -- •> •• s n 1•, a • • t .~- • •1 into re • • T • ,.._,,___ ,r • ., ':U.81 " .. ~ n ~ ,m i •'9 ti .ox • C, .. • t t e e C M"'th i l'J8 l'l • • ta • • ' 11 Y, •!' . ~ \ •• • , t n<I t·". .... e 4 • • • -u-.~• tea. • 0~ ~ • hJ":·t• • • l'lim: "? n • • • e ' • • 1 t •• • • a • hf'llt,' d.on't 'I • IX .ad ••:'I to • • •. • ••• a ...0 1n'1 '118 pl'I ,.."\ • R l. • • ,, irtJ<t; tt, ,n ~- t id.c • •• • ' •• h•t ,· • r • ir.teTV:<l t" l 1• • ,.. 3n1 t".· r. el •""l- ~ t . 11~t ,.., • ...ul •• ... ~·-•·t, t t'"• " .., le n t .·- • t • H ·•"tit - ' ,.. • • ~ •1ng · , •• n· ••• - •••• - • • • • ~ n.1 �,. • • • • • • ' �•• 'l • , ..... , e t14.? 9~::=nnr, Qo.t ,,. l .lt"'led., - 't !."'& " .... .t • A • ,, ,,. ,..~, nm t.ha1. tt was I")··,.,l ,. th .. .,_,. J, } o "r.ioer ~ ~ •• • 111.m,- •• r.r. - n 1 #\o... r, ~- --, L~~ - • • ~- • ;/:~.ti.::•. r.---..• "' L- "" tlie ts f'Ol.'..OTI ..l l • A •.l'"'r ete1-t,,,. •'",..,1:-'J'l1 t Ot ~?' a. •• Qir ... • " 1 tatol i:'")i.11 'fj_ ... i ,,_ a n?ise .. t. • ...,a t t.• ,. r. 8 .. - t 'lre -,--t c· ...•: Cl' ·~' ., 1,. .,,,,1..---t - i tow ~1 ·-, ' 1 nk l:ll'lb '>lD' • ~ot,. • 1~ t!'te t, f,f ~ator :1. .,.,.__.,4(. ...... l n ' B:1',0'1 .. ~ 1 sr- t .-,..1,ton·~ .. l""'le~ ;,,j .~ "r Ell to -tau. ., h• St"l- ... t -, e• r I'd ~ ll l• ' ..., "" 1., t .,-· '1' t 0 "'iv.. nt .., t " C " r '"ne :1, ta• ,.. ..~, • ' l, 0 ,n . • i 0115 . t,., <lrl I nr:, all .. • ""' n'X-:r'!. •wei ..-~ r..-: htt}"' .. ti,,; dOi" "~ Ci pat ~ ~'1· .. ,_....., (l~(\ . ...~·.u•e 7--r-r tl. ln abrn l ,111.....~." '. . 'I" • ~ t· • • t i?'"""'f\; t.uyeJ t .. -~.... ... , 7 • -~, tp ' , ... /~&Mo, • .. .,... . Jl)"'"" t 01);!' .• ... ..,, • ~ ~, ...,,........'-'••-; to t~.e •01> o" , ♦ ~L 0~ 1 ~ ,. ,i~ .. t.":':"ll41 t. ~ ~Old • ~le ...,._ - .,, •n • ••• • inti, o- 'rl!'T)l'/ ?t 1 1 • ~,'-'tr •• a a 1 t!"'""I"'1.t X ~7.~t I --, I'."" 1 t•1" Wjt.~• ...!'\, and ••l 1 >, .:)'.t ' ... ~ r- a,•-t 1.. l mv.t,t: .. ~· .,_,,, ~ tw.,o/ ~ ~ ~ ·- ~·~. • •r 1r.g •nt.• t ' ~ • t""1a till 0:, t?.... 'W"l.·· t~ 0 ~. ' rt .... ...,. t 0 .,.,. t tl-e •, ,.i.--.11\, ~ Jt r:.:.t1~ C!"~S • l r I •._,'t rt'. the a ot I t. ..... ::t t.i.e ~1. f'-n,-."""'! !l • t •n. to ,t ail-,; n th" • ~ '""!..,.. ~ " i • t '.,. • 'ld t �,, 1 • • • • • • • • • • • �•• l • . -- ., ~ t • L ';'lt .. -- il. ~ r~• ~ ,,..• t li.', t·• • .. -.c l1d I t r t!'-,.. •• >OC-k•tn, ..... • • • ' •• .l:tY<"ti •• nt • --.. • " . l. • ,, ~,tu , ,..r..,.r o-n1 • .e t!"-i w:1r-· or ,., ....... " • l I\ t,Ena ,,.• t Ealr t'r ! j,)1'' .. t ,.. t • .II!. J, ,. • ·:,t 1my,,t.t-~+--11'"➔ •rf r-1,~ ~ • 1 ♦ .- • • • • t T' er. " Q_• tn- t, ~ p l • ~- .,,.,... • • - br"I0."""1en tt1W •• -- • •1t t:' ,....... ' ... :ri •• - e • t o" t.he t>· nt· '1 • •• or -· .~ -- ~ ~::t,hO,:-.. ~ D 8 • "" M ;:- 3 t - t....i.. ,en , ··e·t '?•~·o!'rt ,r t - ...., I ed. ""t Side n 't)• ~ '• " •• ~ •• e T !"!~ • t= .... • 1"! ,. ?: • 1Btcl • rr 8.JYl .....s:.""11 ,. t ll3d L'l• "' ~s•ek, u;-, :,a • ""IS _-· ... !l'. < __,, -· ' •• t~ Le~ ~- -,a; ,. ~ ed ttr.esi, 11.1,180, e1 t I.e~ nt" t.?1.• .•- - "st. BO • a h ,1a t.,.r, I\Hl he&i ·1 ""e, "). t ,, ' 1e .St.lb ,.....L!' ,,,.' 1,,t.•mt ,,. to n•-' • Is M: •n• .,, • ., ,:r •• Loo, " " 1 •• ' and " "" .,. • ·e J:llc. 1 ;;,:,u t~e ·,f".1-..•'"u• i i"'ro t"''! ,. a-t:,' it!> tl-.~ "1 • n'1<\ t • " "!.'."".at ••::ut a'Xl ti, t ,m ll'nter Str,.et. " -r '"' " ""' t ~ B :!dJ-1 t,j C • p £ • • ,, t .. """nt.eh1t1, et ~"le, d"'"Jlll'!<I ' I } • r .. ....• ~• .. • V rt,.i·•-1~ ... ,,1 l o-~t l • n• <t - 'P ;. ' "' t t f'o.tr C"':et �.. j· • • ' • • • • • • ,· J �,, .c.:• re •rt - "'"• ,,. 1t M • - £..~o4i. ,. ,t.011,,.., "-1 n • • ft ~- .r... '!! r ~· • r t, • -. -4 - • 1 lf11,1 ti:.:, ...O!; ~ • '"lls • t. P, ·• ...,. ....,,,~ .. ,. • Ar • ' t I~., • ~~ ,. .. L,~ 0 ~ .. e.nd • :t, • ,_ u•. • ~ . '" t ... r. • ' -• ,. .. ·e • ... -4.... '"-:-I'd, ,. • e •; - • .,.,dia ~ ,;r b • etroet. li'l'" t r• t: or.1i-•• - "~,. as ):'• • IF. 1 <I 't r. •t ,·r..,,. r•1_ ,.,, ,A i"•, e • • 11<1th .. 1= !( • C • tr. 8 "I '.II ,~ d ,r ' • I ., • • -" ~ t • • • !'I! 1.r"'i. • ' " mrt• •• h t t -,- ') J '.J • (_ -~. , --r•a BDr, , ..,,.. .. i --to _£'~• ·• ,1 :,• ' I\ l n' • " - r-t ~u:~ • " \Y - ........~ 41;._ ••• • • a t•. •I,. ' ...... _... ~1" t • 'lots, t • 7'........ • !l ..1 :,, ....,..t :.-::i~ ,. ftl);J .,.k,.... • .. }•I" • -• 1""%1.ll'l<I :.1 "' e:u: ' .,. • �• • • • • • • • • �•• 6 . ' ♦ t ' c.,. . t;. • .a ~- 1,. • .. . .u .-J,. ........... ~ ,.. - ......, ' ., -,,un •• • " t11', wl: "- ••• •• - tho• ' ~- t .e ~ t "'·" • • .;. - l ,. cl •t,t:,,i .... I (! n, T, !fa r -' ... - •r..... • BM 8't tson~ ... .,... l - en r .a., • ♦ ~h• "' r • "'QX1.t~t~d. ' ' ""' . ., - .., .. d."' ' .,. ""n1~ ,, ~,( • d.t;; t ,; i !.n,. -io f a a•• ~ -' -~-· It nt.ntie, ,. ' •• t t•, ' i1t ~h f 1~ t: ;.t • ~ re tt.• ,, • """ • • ' .,,..-t_r.,~ - -- . le~;~•~ ., r •• 1. t ,. ✓ 1 C ... i+ ~·• ,.."'• ~ 11 a.- t:e ~ • ,..,. 1 ~ ~f'l1 • ♦ ~•a • l' e th C C 1"0 • W".J1 .. • •• •U', ,..n • l!' ~ -w&-}~:1,. l lit ' . t;;. .... ,... & Pt('lt • 'he rww UU!'hr,, -,. • • I ,.·~ C t,,,... o.,..•'lt-r l!lt'"! t.· • \' ,et~" '' f'(')..,, ~ ' '>rth , ;,\ - Ln wllt,; r,r,e/ • t 0,.J l<\ ... f'+:"t t "Ii\ t t~n t. ,. • " -· ¾. .) r • ....• ' i• n - • ~..J.., f ! ' - t 1f' ~t • s d'>i er. ■ 11 , at t r llt 1!.11 st t • t 8 1 ,e d,,..n e l!'J c:-. t. e V l ,,,. C.W"' r4JO~ ... ..~ -"'1,. O WU it.'! "Uli', ..... t ..... ,,.. t., .f!,,.. Ht.lL ,t. .. ...,.• - ""1.n. -• ...... ,,.. s....,. " • ~ <! �•• ... ... • • • ' �• .. • - ., - - or-t-.-1,., t. e'"' ..,~ (W"!1 •r~""l t]',• ... ~r !.r. C':"~t :i.,~.-Lt;wi-":;_ ~. ,.•• - - .. ,.. locl:• tl:e n.rp ............,. ,...---. :11.. ,A.A..-, • : lntn ~l .. --••n?14.;;.•. " ~ -·•• ,. ' ~ • l t. .. ....,.i -.. t~- II x: - •• ~ iO l·e ,I-~ 51~- =~ ..... - f') ,..,.., td. t Pti •· ir,J;.., "'l':N, ~ oc,u·•.t R"' • ,~ •:1:• .... l O<> •u_'1 '"t • t:·"!'i:.t. t ' r, I, -- ~ • • l re·· v r t:r ....,,, ti • - I At."' th .. 8 ,, " " " J. H. ..., trri~a l'-•"'"'"~ l, .... " e·... r1 th~ ~... •; ,-( r. t, a 01 ' J "' 1:,.·t'I!* ~ ( JI-:'"'-ic """'• t .;,., • • l- t 1 8 ~'t t "' 1_J"I♦ t") T1 i'1t te 3 " O' I 1~ 0 -n.--:- - • 1.l t..nd tz•d,~•• ►• n •th t )" e~·, ul tn Ll!"IT:. •11>!44114---1\1\>•',~',..,.-"", '.'-' .,.,,.,..~.,,,.,. -.,c~,.,,. .., ti-fl..~••• ..,.+ 'L, ., 'l"I ti ..... il t_ cf<.. ,L41 , . 1de J J• ,,ro . " (l "';.- •• t llan:,,a:i ". t t -. . - r. 11 ..., ,, 4.,. . 1·.._.,, L t}tO • • • Lee ',a I " ti """ t]', tit'iet..;- t 8 ••• i I ,.,.,.,.. ., U, te." • ft"l'('!i ~..,,.i,,,,.~ &!JI. )]le 88 lll:.r;t ; .. -c; -~ 1'1""'"1't'" n 't t, ~ ·- '" I 1,..,.,v "" .. t.l", -,.,t_:(, ........ ,I; ..... ~· 1-~,. • ,!'(t ,., ri E c. .., �•• • , ; • • • • • • • • • • �• ,, • • • - l - - • r.. nly m \"f Bur t ' 1~t~o~uc-~ • ~ • • to (i /:• t • by th~ rt: .... . 1 t e i .I.,. ~· T &':tt:zz t • ' • r "H\4-- 86,T' &_ t. ,-,. 1' 15 I: .... . ,. r 1 1 o • oc~ O t • IC ,,..., .,. -;r)r.e, t I et ...,.,.._t 1 ...bc:,•r wh"' ,... ~ .. ,.., ,...,Ut£ 1 ot •. ~ • • 11 •. '7!·:- OW•d ,..,f'! r it~r.t ru:1-ti <) • ~- ,1i;,j2 IC!; • I ....... 'T !' 1C~V'•l . a.'14 "'-'- -it""".G • ~1"> ~ •11 111~1 e ,., 'ld c1r • ;!lat ~ • , l,+.C",_ . ., • "'1 ""\ n .. llo ~I _fQ.tu•t"r l"' e..;_ •~ t,~ 1 ,. - ~ ln.S.a.;;ite \0 u:oo- ,.,. .,.. t'?-o, am �" • . •• • • • • • �.. • ., ' • - - 9 - - • rt e .' ' TJ11, A ltr:.ess, "''r. et: rt1 r11 • t•• t • nm fl\lcc• r...-1.on; t ll r;ie d ,tum '..n. p1• • ~~ 1• •• < r: s tn:,d1r,r '1• t e tu.,, l"'JC1r,....,, ..... T" 1"fln t.hn:. -· • •• rl!--.!Ii:; n c• hl""I, ~ ,.. •t t ti. ..,,. i t • • " ~,.!-.e lJ•,.•t ... ,. l'l\1 LO~t r ...... et .- 0 ,. i, , t~ 1• .,. ,,,t • !"!...~. i;'h".,.t "l1 'td I.<"r s 1- " L~ r........ w 8 ---• p~1 ◄ ~,.l •1"~'"'" ,•r.rr, t'.1-te !V'"•r:~.., r. "C!i.!\l ~ J .. d ~ ld r,r lla~b(, r Mlrt ~ -. ta,,.,., f. r- t.,..,,•1-i•d:- .,. "I"'!'!. . ~ Lr 11, ....-:.. t. •m 1~t ~ C • nd ntn-tr1 , .."• - -~-- L • l'<! l n .,... ~ • ,..lY _.....,. 11...--{~>,;,1 ,' 1tr"r,r r rrtl!',.'I t-"la ~o :,... ' • .,. I Jt:. it:-i,,sa ... ni"-11 ~ed n~ t~e wnr '..? w:.i:- a.11 t'" 7",av• ~~ ... 4!'t,&1.11r.. &r. wi'tne ~i'"' ·--< ,:, ........, t t - - 'l':I. -,.'-,, -·')¢' D'"><l 1'r t~ A.Jf14 ...... '\ ~ b,:•a. ••• .,. A Jrn ~n "nt!rl~t1on, t;. ...r1~•1"'.. t. Ba'r.,,o; r. ~11J•t,'t!arbo :r #:t:1 bt1 .. ' j t; .. ,i 1,,1_,~ -o b'.Jt .,..,•• ~ T~ ' n,. ,.,a .,,1.. , -. • • , 4J'l1 W9!,:¥j\f'l \1 -·· • ~t <triit1g,land e •• 1o ~ )(,..,,. .,_- �" • • • �•• • t • tlorir", ,, ., • A!11 ..,. t ti - a'"' ,n......~ Sa,,..,.."'._.. •~t• 1 ... 11::<1 c.a••~1. ' • • II •r,..,1,.,-~.,,,_ r C - - • ' t 'I' t C .., J ' t1 , ... . - •n Rf'+ .. •• t ....ct- t t rt-.n b r ,.,. Q limes R:J.l.t:'! t~ .rt 1 " .. ., : at ~ ·1•T- .. ,. • )iy an '.'l: t-0~,:,1,t.t-,; ._ +<·~ I , •rt~, am. t1'11"' lfr:"'!-~ft A! ht. t 1tr.~BB .-...'! O ec:.l 'i'! .. tv .ed Ja11: • :, ,. • ,,..- «c •=••••-t.-o'- ,: 4 LJ!bOt 0 u • tr Ot r:, ... T. t c'lnh~ ., 11 " c ".a:he~sv • .. r 00. ,:. p ....... tat.rd, • " :I I .. �•· • • • • • • • • ' �' • - or 'oeer. a:v -'It ;-• f't t <tr .n.~ n ---tl C>t.l• .,. ·,' 51 ·- ' Hr. • t,~,.~r ~ch - l.l ~ , al ~ 'b• •• -· ..~••=••~ ~ lt ....~ • • i '1"' • r •r t ~ < . i! rb Tl'" ! ,., \ .. e .t , b:10-..:... .. ,J._ r~t tell': t '11u e • • .r.i1y. t t r,: 4,t tho I • b. r' • ..,_ .,. ~ 6 t , '.:>, ~ t '11·11 k~ - wit .,.• '3e.1 -- ·1\:.~ • • 1 -., t --':!"'J "'-la r_ l ' --~ 'Th· -•-,g,...-. t 1 ~-1 r w ....t:, 1, ,._ W"'llt tn., 11! a •l"I ·- .... " t f!: • u ,, ~""':l?'t,-, 1"' '!!t , ,,. -~ rru Jl. ,., it 'r,): •• ._,-,1 •h fi • = ;/J!I ti 4/--+ ,< - t t :flI - ." : ., - • t<t n:-• th•11": u t r' ............ t ... ' ' - t "'" he e.-oq, hic.•,r.rn W.( U-11.ii g, ,, l l ' •i.ty • " ca ~'li..:''·•r ,.-. i. t b l I"" • th"!'~- ... ~h cL"'"3rt~ £1"- ~l "• T t • •• ' ~ l~!>fl ~ " t in ,,; ...,,_ I aln""P-." T}"-.a.t witn,. 1,1 • i.- • .._ •' '71 ~ .......t.;.L":,W r-·• 0 , 1 1O l • - �••• ' • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • �•• •• • • - - 1""'- - ~~:.1. ,.t• m. t,. 1,1 1-. · ,.._ .. --~ .. MF '~rtac:ri~,-.. ~':> [: ,.. .... .,t -,- . 'Jnl!O, ,,: t r ~ C '"Te 1 •• ... . ♦ • .,,.. ,. . r a.r,_r-: ... b a-. r.c1 r. • ths " e '" . •• ve ;\ t r E •• --tt ••• • . \. 't t. les "' l n t 11.rr ':a-b,. ,.. a ,,r 1'" ➔ d >' t. ,.,,,.. ~ $ • ,.. t r.e.se cf' t • ..... J • n. n t H(it'te,l;- •·· d,; • ...-rl ta er it •• •' the:-; ..,,ti,..,.., e IL ttri, ne t. - •• tro1n " u, id. t n• - ~ t • .. ,.,1 • 0 ti:~ -•t :,e4 .. " 1.~ f' t • ♦ - 'rr U'd "'l" a a " tu•rl\'1!.l • • -y of' l>• - t'. - t'l "" ~ 1 ..e. ,,,., = ,. 1n B ~ Jta,t ""...... JHly, ,1r~,n1<. f\ut - • • _,, .,,""' r t -· t t. ,.,J. l, Hll ..•·,.c, Pr•tt·- • J)l)T' ' te ,.~ "' t! ,t ~ ♦ J l ..=, - ""' y ~r. ,.. t • • • #' 4 tra1%! " • . ~in""• ...., • . • nt •r n:-:-1 8 n U:~ &tre t t'P"•f t ~1•1' t • • t• lf', .. hilc 1n i ...... ,. ,,."'"". • ~ ♦ - ,. ~ 1!!·'"~ t: • .,., "" :-.<~ Jul':, 1 r-r ,-"'1.....• , ba::- rlY.'ZI t.: :u. 1 ~ t·• ~~ r t ~ L ·- str"'e~. �I .. •• • • • • �•• 13 - - • • 1,t \. t , "'C!l" t; • t .._ . ,. ...... dJ" b ... ,..,... ., ' rt n ~ -e t..:!J> faJtair, kett, cxrert r "'n t,-, .. "'....... ' I ll dO n~ �' • .• . • • • • • �• •• \ • • t:1s pistol ~hAt h9 carried o~~ !.O '.CGn..~e.,r to~ heeV'y rain, 1, d •itll '1111 w:,en h~ 1e:r, Ooo~s llill o::- tne n1ght o't ;.ha Sd he spent the nieht er JU])•: to dr1va :.tat b~c-:-us, ,t ne-G!"Ile nt.:,;rcr•~11 ; 8-"11-1thr:t ee:-Jy en the rio:rn1ng 01' the ~t~, t.1 deOil1~d to eon.a to li.err1son:iure no cpport\lnltv 1tat f'or tl:et 1,0 rea•o~ ~c bnol, th,.. to Gooda li.tlJ. tc ohs,iga J-Lta cloth~s, t. b~p1 = •d ~o ha· the 11latol along 1 a..'11cam~ and it w"th hi, �.. i·• ' • , • • �" •• -lt:- • An<1th:11 b~i~· all t.he avid.ance, t)w Court J.nstr 1ct3d the 3"1·· as tollOW'II· for the Cotnl"'onwenlth ~n I b:, counsel ror tne dei''!ndunt, Jury the uron ( Here lnnert verdic~ l. '?hereuron unu.11c: the c1~-rend.,.nt, by counsel, en<" tlii! e-.•id9nc.o, and to r.rant a n ..•► t:rial ti o ~ourt overrule~ f'ellc;nn,; in o-.•er~,/4~ to grant the // 1 -:Y1i.'3r~nnc!l to t.h7 ct3r'mda~t; 1tuch n,c;ticn a,.J a=--torod t.:!l unid Mrl 1n r•ef'ustnt movorl tho Court. to 0 ,r\d ,•~J t,,.. ord,,,,,-; 'tiOll )&•• BS llfOX9' ef'e:::'!.~''J'('1 n n.e,, i.:rte.1,. t~e de-ft!'\ciant, t~.ts I ls b111 er exeeptlc:'13· I a. )j,._, ") (t tj'•: ( 1, J}I >IIt," ..3r! I r-~7V j..£7 t~r 'i ,,._~ t' !,.,,';, /~,,6 6 I .,,. ,;;,,,, '-,'Ji,..,,..._._ r • I' v /,._ L /, y~ 4 '"' ... ,... ....... ;,,,. II<>_, ~'fr r ✓~- .l_,._.f �• •• • ~ • • • • • , ·' • • ' ,, • • • • , -~I �.. • -.!C- Bil: e•,1danc9 or rxc~ptions ~o. .,ad b11 .1 .l::t'"od•.,o3d as "et ( Her~ illeo.rt lnstr,,ct1on• 3. O\lt in Bill ol' r,xceptions 4/ ~ ~ on bel!Alr or Coronon,.eoltl.'. Uu 00U!'; over?, o ...,.rj(..,, -....r '"1 of" "ni<1 jnstrum.1ons a:1t1 to ,y CJU:ts~J • ob.,eC:t,!d: r'1lO<l sa1q ol je ,tic:1e to za.111)C1Jt tho gtvtng J!o. 1, wrr~rsupon ,,, eoo, ont? of -:.~te:nand e:ro.:!t,"'i.1t .. ..J sn_t,• 1.'1.::-• ~•,1etto I'! an1 ef!:C\hof' ther:,: ......, ..:. I~'-"-~I:.,.. ;\,._I). ~A.,,./'> I.., <"•• '4•-4.. cc_ I 4-~ ff!ld tc t.?1~ ~~t.1.on o.....t:i~ --ou.rt. in so OVCI'T"'l ~ flaid 003oot.lo':13 a-:-l l. ~ " '-J , ~, .,_/ ....,.4._.-:..,.;,,.,,,. ~ ,.rr;nt[ 0 ,, snt,J ln9truotionq and e~ch o'f th""1, the dera:1/l"~t, by cou:,- °' n, 7 ~ ., ..- f Z '. <,,, f f f:1 L • -. ! • �·• ,.• •• • ,- • • , ....I �•' •• ' • Bill of' ~oaptJ~1s e11idenc~ ,iart be~n i>ttroduced fil'lil.l'-6£1...i..o Oourt to ti.VD tho ( 11:3:t"O neert. lnatr:Jctiona Tt. !M S. "" net o ,t 1n ill l' 1a pre,:•od to h" t.--·~~t !d V9 o ,,,rt ,,nich sal., io, 1 001.."':l- 1'Qllowj_ng in~~?'",,ctJcc.r.; oaker1 1or b~,1cief'endi ·,t tlr-L.'"lL cf' w?:1,ct. inst.ruct1J'lne on~ !.G, J, the cte,·cnc1nnt, oy hereof', Jl.1l'Y th" -,-r r.xeep,1 t:.: H =➔ • (:o.:Jteomr"alt.t, A•bt • t:.· 1.ts wt.eret:...,~'1 tl& Co".U't a:J~tP.in~ -he obj!'ction of' 'the 4.,.. -c. • ( 4.........__::r ~ ... ~...; "~,..-,...... 7J Co!!t.."!o:i.w3al lh n~ t.o ~ inetr ict.!0:11, a.""ld1.•ef'"uscd to crent t 1-r.1 -::- '"•:.Y at.:.om:J.y, ob_.ect·1~: of th.;m.i>.x11l1111•1zxn=11,ou 1!'.g tha objsetton ~ .~ f. a1" ,.,. ~"/ tt.• " To wltl.,•J, ,ction Cot.ll!lomreolth and ' h ... } . ..,.~.,,, inst~.101.1 ,n!'J..,_oren1r o-1' th~,e·l'~ dafe.nd.c.nt. ~t..;c,, rdfUetn,: to 1:rant Raid ,._,__....c. •.,, 1'1 r:,f"'Uning to ernnt. .,_,.rt,.. .... "',.t.'".io w:P C:n•"'• 101, t,-._1,,._ • t:!e hi.n 11.111 l'Jr IXC?pt- '\ey e"' J:u1 r, 1u11. • tli.:\F _ ti 0 .4.. 7r e-J-..l-~-..,. :, ,; " -<L7' I . '" ~· .,, :,,non or tnem, of" th•:? -rcc.ord in t• c cas-.,. ,..a.ch is oc, h,..,.I '1, t2-c,...-f,,,.·-•---' 19 1 P , z,.. .-., in Col!l•t in sustein- b·• c,.;..1:e;..;). ~X,......>')-:.ed: ~nr1 ... t':·:ct.ne~"'!"n var· I _,,;- of tho • 1 8 ,_ <><. <"~-,..~ p,-4...:..1/~ r,._&_.-.... - "7 I ,,: "-. CJ&. __ .) 4 ,4 ..... ,r ,_, <._.- xi: ~•.//Q~, J .:.j[;e. ~~, �• ••• •• •' -7 • J ... J • • �ORKNEY SPRINGS HOTEL {.....,,..C ....... /, / / "l 0 l'-C-- t! ...,_ /t~c........ , :) ' ~ h,v>T ~ y c</.&;_~ / 7__y,. /;J,PV,:Y>-.- (',,.,.._~ i. .. ◄• ::, o '"i1'-' ~,.-" • -. /"'-• ' / '- .t:_..,• ~ r l,,,__, 4"'\~ I,_.__ , J).. 1 ,,J.-,_->'.' • • · ,"' /,,,,..,h,,,,- '"7 L.._,,...,. ...._ I!· /J ,,...._ 4-,....,.,-; /_'. -1"~ .!"-~ - ~- Iv /,;,._e,,.:_?7p 7,_, ,-,....,-t • ••~ ..:;_-;;., , ,...,_~ ;:,./_,.,__• / ~ •-a....-;Z,<T/ /~-, ; • If ·-r t.. ~k ·/' r.,,.- r, ;{_r ..... <. ,,,. /J...Ls:.. T /;/~ ~ J.J~ :,----. 7;--•/ ~.,,,(, /,<,_-JI I q Ce, l&L,_1 I'-< I...,..~ 7;i... .1.........' ;~ 7 ,-,:f t..--..~ ;( ,,-l-.., ;{__ ,t ~ ~-/r ? z ~-/ j1 4 1,., ~.,/,.__ 7 -?)"~ 't-, - C L ,..._._-,( • ---<t~~ IC ... 1?/,_,. ,.. • -- -~ ;/,~ L • • t!"'...~' I I!, /,t.. ........ µ _. J /J..• ✓~ "I ~~~~---~ ��"'T ..... - ~·, ""·~-·•-•-'t-.. ' • ( ( /It~ ' • �'' .\ �I -'j,J? L fl-<- fl/1(,.fi ~~~:::--A- (?,ry,.~ �• �•• .. 1. , • ne <'cm- ..nstrn,..•e tt'lo 1u.ry 'tl'.q,t r,oeve:?" k.111~ e oe<f.,~ with tial1ct> a:orAt,-ou,ht 1a JiO"'!>otrl'\ted b~/ ,,oteon, -rllful, :-1,..e.t ~ol1l><!r'<tP, · cree; ly1n- ts ru!l~y tn wait., ~n<1 1-~ "d1t'lt"'1 &11 ott.e- :::ur,te,,- "'Ut'.lf!n o!' M11r".lcr. A tlW'4M· 1'/111oh or c;ny othAr tlnd. of" kilting l • ,.,~1~ n th" tn JCU.,..dertn i110 nr-~ond degree • • • No, 10,11oe ,-rorl'thousht an us"'.I. in the roroeotnr. I:.f?ana e.n,· :fo!'ltiOd oi, -n or 101ng =-1~cttef 11;:r.tti• ar.d de1>rr,v1ty or ho•.Tt tn e"ne:ral. a~.~ther in"trn~t1on P...riAt.n.e"r-.i �.. •• • ' • • I • • �~ JIO ..... rn • oh'll'gf! of' rnnrder, of UU.Uli'. --i,~n the tUJ. cl.ro11r18·11n•ne of pe • thro·•n fltion ne 1• m'tlini, _3 ia i,remmcrt from the !'act :rov""1 and 1a 1·1t1\~oor.ii>~ni.1 with the l>ur<ien of dlaprovlr,r 1""1100 1e uJl()n the P1ncue~d• (', 1'h& rourt 1e l'!'"•u:ned I,:· l • we,;.lth would. elevate uat wove woulrJ rn i.'11Jtl'11~\8 to '>e =<le!' the off'enoo tho ~hara<-tOTiat1.,:,1 U"O 'th,, ~U...""o/tha1. 1n th eve.,..,. un1f:lwt"U.1 hor.Ltolde •~ond 11.--:-ee, ~ t•,. Cor:'OOn- to rourde'" ln tho f11·ot <1<>1 ~A&, it r th!lt of'f'~nco, /,, -·-•...h-~ t?"e ot·f',.,.noe"-t"'e bUl'1.en ea• t.~OOt' te anrt 1f the on hie. "riunner �• • • ' • • • • • • • • • • �No. It. J ,.._ The court • wil'tul, deliberate, 1netruoie further and rom~d1tated the jury k1ll1nr: 1t that to oonatituie 1■ not n~oeea,u-y that the 1.n•.ention to r.111 ehOul.d e-:1nt t.n;, ~..ri1c"1a:r t tne ,,.ior to the aetual 1nten,1on tit::" killu,g. t't. ,-r ~illlne, or 51\Y ~il!le ~"'1.;;th o~ iu only necorearir ehuuld ~o"" •nto ox1etence ror the ttr~t • tL"'8 th~t ~t "uoll the 1"ovtous1r. daa lr, wec.l>QJ\ 1n the l>:i:.tv1oue oe8eeelon 1e prtl"'l of t.he nla:;er, t'aaie rtlf•tl, upon the 40cuaed ithout del1b~,.~te ny or u-,:iontJet"'t sl1&b1. .,rovoeatton, and ~,.•,l!leditlrted the n 'Of!oa1\y or p,.oving lt1U1M and tbro"n eirtl'lnu'it1118 <"b·ctl!tfttanceo, ' �•• • • • t • • • • • • • �.. • • I • tho jury believe r.iaJ.1o1oua but not ,rlll'lu., Jt1l1in/' fl-om the evid.,,,,.e 4el1ber"t" th"t and p~, n:"41tat,,,t, ts ll:\U'der 1n the B~<'Ond dP.gree. the .k1llinjr th"n Ruch w ft �' •• • • • • • �•• s • • 1£ the cn~ ltill jury b~lievr '1 the dect't~er'1 do the <leo~..sed " eertous or~enoe 1e murder. 1~om the in Mfloution Pe?"AOll'll hurt evtdftt\!'e that the p~ie- of e m->J.1c1oua 'l\ll'pose by ,·oundint htm the to �• • �•• • a. ~e oOUTt 1notruote 1• tile unli,.-tul 11ill11g 'b ,,~....., 1m lied, ot :,d,"O.,n ., uoon a -u<1<1enhe~t. t1Utuu aomb..t, the jury ~ that thout voluntary mlice, ma.nelaughtnr aotutl c,n '1"8'\~0n'lble p,-ovo~,tion, " or or In �• • • • • • • • �•• J cou.,.t tnntructa ~e witneaaos 1-e thet o: ta " quo~t lon exoluuively aboxe to dete:r~tne their the~ .,;e~!IMO nppnr~nt !ID<i h are - for tho jury; ~ of ftftd the le,w and 1~om all appellrlng and of tho 011 the t:rtaj. I'. k t- I and to 111ve ored1t /; ./ I' "- .\ 1, • right t~O app'U'ont oan1or their wol'thy ot ored.it, have tho w1tneea~R o~ the et'\l\1, 1ntell:Lg~nce, Rlll'roundJ.ng o lroumstan•es witnesseo th<> o~edib111ty •fl".'l'iliy 9"1.lHllOdl:. the jury manne,- of teet1.'v1!1.!!, fai:rness, othor :'r<>2 that ,,i" itnesr,e,.., teebtt'Y di•"r"Cly e~ s01a1t.e • u,~e:J L!lC ,e.v.14e.G'JII ,., their the jury " which aooo?'d- I �•• • • - - • • • • - • • • • •• • • �•• ,..... t1 ot. t , c--.... t ➔ t11•.-, -n.1r .... ln the t • Ill i: '!.- 11. .... 1· 6.hat ,. c--,,,,,,.. tt- i t~ ... 11 ••• •t ,. 1, 'nt"O '"• ' •.,' "'t' y ~'Tt!J 'J1' , .. I• -~ • • -• -~ us I or. j i~ ...,,11. ~-i,---::1. l':li! d... - -•o-•:"'at ~ d ,;r do ~ (l •' t• "Y (! ., £- .... ..... ..' .., ii. 1... "\:-Y, aT C ~ 0 "ind him gu1~' }' 0 • ......, f1 wh1cll .,... ~ " �' ,·• • • • �I •• / .3 • • •• t ""Y tl' t ff" .. 1 • er.r .. t •• �.. • �f J '!'he court ooneldering to hunt the jw7 n-,,. ,,at -::!'lloe ...14""9.l 0?' "";'U\j~t.:Ul"tl.l. tv eerioua b , 0t1· '4 o !Jerond the ev1dcn-,e they entert'ltn ~ 'UOh doubts .re!UlOMnle 10\l ~t tho o.,r11~nc~. evidenoe to loubt without lllllt te'!' o:r la>1, 1n ~ ,n•e not to !-• L.,.-r.1(,,,,-'.. .._ the ev1t:i.mtoe or ~ an arbitrary wo. 9~- 11111 truo te the ,1ui·y as the es"e, u:p doubt6, - nat t, i1UH, a to believe OTnly be bJILsod UJ)OD rt. mu.Rt no\. ..bt"i 1n • It :wst and. eubet nt1~ l in ordor to ,,·arrant nn 110,,uit 1. a doubt of II catort,,.l a:ra be rt ~,ot :r•~t or :raete neoooaary for the Jury to flnd. a verliet o:r ~onvletlon ~M not of l.mmato~i~l �••• •• ' •• • • ' • • • • • �•• • 1 ih1 f t Jl,,i"'1'l' ~r \4]·"".. ' 1 ·t:ruot t tw, o. •• e~ u t out 1.h6~ ,. th up In •r1ct a ..,....Uh~r\ 4 • 1 ·n t v• • '11· ra· ~1 " • ' I ~ l th " ' t • i"t ;en nt th t • c,.._v1et 'Y h 'UPH 1 C ,N cJ 'Q4 tog u- t l t t • t r •• .r • b th t • • y b· 1 lt ::u: n blc t :\. 01 n it • 0 ....lU 1Y "t 1, ., 1n it '' •Y r.1,00,,nt, • r' d ,. I aettt IJ" ,n L• It TO t. ...i -- 08 \I~. ) ,v .' . 0 , '"-~- ae 8~ Vr1. ....... ~3 \' • 3l!~ /u,, I 'I Oord.•n1 n ae ~. "1... V th -con , • t .' :. h " l • nJ , 1t • h I t t ~L ttt nt th t \ n t • vi thm tr ·ty tr pr hlilltl n .,. t 0 1• er. nt, ' .diet t r.n,v1ct 'r. t ed thr Ul" v .n t th t ,:: r ? • r. • &C :,u !.1"11'""Id gi t Ihm. th t, 11r. Jlll"Y " I> •:.d',ranr, r, -- ~ •• •t t ....':,. ""'9:ft•• 'lo. t>i l C 3 ,,.,, ar t t t.1 , ..... n 1~ ·h t J, tl'u1· a n:. 0 t:te: AO' pt ft:nault 1r,u •t.: th~ I h tru,11on 1 ;r,,:,n 0 .. t rn th ts tit JU-¥ h 1>t1 fll 1 rt. on tr-1\°"'L "1!.oo~r.t 0 • .. , C IliC\U 3 I 1n t I ru~tr 4 CO\P't 1 tr1 O,l t. th :1 •l' r r}". In 1- ' r. · 1'J •ti t e ' V' tltl Th tr , ..e-r 1R ur:,· U",y,rho t Q - th, 0 l. I • ~ ~- "· 74,G. t ? "'e �• • �• lt,ut.ruotton I ~·-: Th n Vii. 1".ntru t tllr-1 ·~" ,. of \l t:c ,L•· •..: I y l" t:f.. V "'t.~Y - nt 1 t~ " ,;ucll nr•ll n, 'll"'~d. 'l Jur•• Q • 1. , a t, ' ! 1, 1'11\ i-u.'!\y, ' t. r atro11 •• I r •i, c.,.~in • auttlclct 1n ..•• ry,· .... Who over.,· Mn t \ 1 n til .::uut Al~ b /OU l • ' 1 ea. or H•J'1 oi II \ r 0 t l hYP tl". <Jhf:r''M. al Ol VI 1Y an ,.~r!h U\ I• h.11 ♦ • 1.rnoe~ u !'l,(' v1rt1rn, ;:.n,' l thll r ~,• r ,u•,i)i, 'Ir' t tr,-· t \.0 of" J~: \ 7.11, t:.r 1 th •te Ila. IV. t • \I 1\ ♦ •ll • th lo~ •ti "',)' t I C.h oo 1r. - J Y'l\l no. Cir- �• • • �• •• • • I . G. 'ihtl I Cot.tr l 1 ..l ~ ~m;,,,v t. ff - .......,, ~y <o .. 'h 0 jur; 1'~oh IL~ .' - th, y oa ;,,t c~-t 1nt;- .... .., • o.:,r,·.-1.')i..t'I b, n 11t ~1•u,o• ! to t :ht.7· th•t t J!OO-'":'lt.' .. t t ,t on fL, ,uro;t au r -t ' r~ m·1 "-' "mi')L t 8 l:- lb en1.1-e oa:,pn.;,.t n , ~ l ~ ~ y th11.t • 1oy r, bu t.--uth rt.a. th of z l -f:~ T',~e nta-...... • 01' • ♦ rtir ')~ --r t /) i:'M~Btf!:nt. hYUot.he:-..11=: C'>fth .. be " 1• t .. al ,:u;oc it. ~l an ab1 ,u '\ 1' unon th, 0.C(""IU&~ t nc \, 'ur. lty; - i'J.:J: ~tw:, th ot C nL t • 11 th ..u ...:.. '1' ccr.v 11t!cn C"r.:- lln " •i, l 1:1 ,:.;or ch - c. Ort: r..1eat' Jiu·~· • " • .. "Th .t st t ,, " ""'"•! • ts In :.,..not.le:,, Mn. 7. '!'h~ ,..ff\t t 111 L""l:, ..t t r. r.v !,\)t, th - r \h " , .t bll.!"" .,,• • .r..; ' u ed. •_i.:;t:be ·nott 01 .. t:1, • • Tn ,.,. .!'r 1 .Ill_;,~1 X ·t lt: " r !! .....j u ..h t1JJ exnln1nn ao,1 o<11 Un :, nr.v ...1• imllt • ""'- 1 •• nny ,r 1 ,...;:1,.1,.,r. l ~ht an--u Ot'\ �.. . \ • • .- • �.. • .\ • • • ...... .., ' , �" • .•\ '• • , �Coc:,)0ff'ffl~l th ot Virgtnia, ,o,,l:1ngh!ll:l county, 'l'o-•1t: 10 tho nheri.!'t or MY one o~ h1o deput1ee ot 1,ny on~ nr the oonatableo • ,,herftaA H~~ or o~ ~ei<l. oounty, on tt,B 4th day ot .ruty, t1 kill rnalioe, 1910, in sa1d oounty, and tn.1Mor one Jpen. f ...'..,1t' Juet•c~ lllotr1t't d&alt s=n ~o •l> to 001lllll81ldyou t'o,,-tlnrith /J~= of P,$.d to a;;P,-l'hend t"e oaid _____ tn central KaK1ate•tal to M""e::- the eatd 00l!llll111nt, and ht'l t\1Tthfl'.!' An.1. you a=-e,-:o- ...o•.e-, fr.ij) , ¼Lz::'.k:::- and ~11.l' _ ".le or 60tie othe,- l~""ord-"'""to lu. tl'I an1 Of' ntn U. Lee; County, at Rerr!sonourg, in ea1d countv, o. Herrtni;, thR nru:i., ot the Co"'1110l1'll\fllthot at tl'>e a11-.e til'lb ·ouo1'1nt Md "la~" the 7 to testU'y Cl r,.,,.,,1._ :t ·o fuz,,-~ al! wltneas•• on 11~halt ma't.t'>- ot: tho •~ <1 ~O!'\jlli\Ul't.. / otv·'n Under ffll' hand and eoo.l this ~C; • re1on1ouely Md br1r,g him bororo or 't.ho c~r.m,on,,.,'llth • 1n d&Y /b,,,d...,-c- (2,_~ 'l'heAC 11re, th· ..,..,ro,.~, V1r,:1nla raid county, hae th!a on oath b11:!'ore r-..e, ooorco ~hat o:r county: &aid 1os,1e ooi,u>lnlnt Rn<t in('orm~t1on a JuBt1~e and to all l:.th day or July, 11110. w½-,:, -~ / ,,., ' j ~ P .J fll'JALl. �• • ) ( • • . · ti l 1J 1 s ~"!' ~~ ~ ~ ~ -;,; (" �you find It (ul'.1 n,, the 1,,:risoner not guilty r:o,..,,. Tf you !'ind the JJrinono!' gull t!• det?.'rt,a "" oh•rgol'\ hut gu11:y a1,<1 Anert~in 1'1e ,ion1t,,ntl.'u·y If f1:ret will of rourde,, but 1,y ~o llnd eaoertatn , 18.1'}•not lees l r you 1"1.ncltha O!'" ll'CCortn "C;-,"PP thAt 11 tl.i:e tn j~U O not less o~ hoth . e you be ~nnrtn".,...nt hall yf!are. of '!11t"er r.,,.-<1m-tn the 0"' ,0111nt.al""'· m.-...n°.l!l1lgh1.er "'11ch bP rr.urrtO)"tn r.i,nel•u.~htft.,., ""'1<'h guUt:, .,,..1eonor not Pfl.~· ·hall of oithRr ~h n ono nor more lhan five 1m-<>tU1t1t..~· nenc.l.au_l)-l\ter ~'OU wtu o• ~nn~tn•T•nt • ,uninhmant tn thl' yftRr~. e1p,hteen 61>11:i• of volunt'U'Y his you w111 Bey eo be <'Ont'tnernent not guilty no more. of' mul"de..- in thA flJ•11t Alloond decree, nor more than you f11111 the prisoner 1n th!! .e tui t'1rnt in t~e nmiBhment Which ah•ll or •~oond '16gree, T.11.trdnr in tho ttr• t e:r not guilt11 lP.na tho.n five not of 1nrJ1otment., you ·o11t111Ja~,no eni in the you tin'1 t.he prtao If d••er•e ""l' 0 you "Ul c1ilt!' ;-\1\. ...nd aacertfl1n >'1ve II: .... ?i n Dollar or un1tt~r:."T.t ,~ 2 90'•) �..• •• • • • • • • • • , �• ' • Con1111011,vealthof Virginia, COU~TY Or KOCKINGl1A,,1. To•wit: IN THE CIKCUIT COUKT OF SAIi) COUNTY: • ,n th1 rorQo att'1 AI'r.ll"in an'i tt!lOn tM -Y or o.-.. Je.r-"'J 11. Loo 1n oe111ig, !ul,,m1ouuly, w.tl1"\1l!i• aM of hts tt'."11•" arorPth011&hl. d.1 nve nn •Q.1t!\ult: an1 t!l'lt the ~11l'1 P1n.1<ll~rbour II er-tain Jlistol. of t!le v••luo or ":n=oo Doll11.rs /ff<.<>'•) .... ,.1th tiho ,aHMOQ ot k>&.!.u C.:..?iJr.Om-·&b.lthtbdn bnd the1·u t,!,f"ln on'1. t.~n-~ Ch'C'"£f'~ 1ritt: :-~npo·-.i~ ,.,n-t !r~tt,n 1 tol "" the S'll• l'lnlt R,t-bour 1n 111s ll!U\d then ":'.'1tl""r~~ ""irl'I r t "'111 •.h,,rfl !le.d Ant •.nll theo-e ael.ontoual.;:, vU.."'l·U·· ,uo,d 0' 11111cnliae at'o:-ed eChL'"£'.O and l!!'OOt. of1. tc, R/'&U:RS ~n ·•~on 'ho na[O J!IJ:CS )I. L n: and •!,qt ttn R5!'! P!r.k lll\Tbou:- with tt& lo!ldAr. bl•lle~ afC"' cnrt.t cu'. ot tt.n r:tstol t';t t~~ M11 P~!lk ?1~tn11l" 111 ...,.,1l:'Ke1 an! ■ hot orr aa aror.,ao.c'1 .11~n rn'i the:r, elontoual;-, 'IJtl!\111~• and or h1a I 111'1, t"en tll~•llht di ""'11'1MI !t'f"o-ethoU('ht '11.'1 etrll:e, ?"net.!"g.te !\TIC!'PO\ M tl':e ,11,14 4f6J!;.Gn II. J,f'e in en'1 ,:,,on t1'e .•'i't chP.st ot: i,t,. the sll11 Je.r""' M. Le-9: «lv.tnr. to htm tN, PB.Id Jnne .. II. L"'<I tl'.en 8M thO'."O -1th thn 'f'ISdfln bullet 11rores111-1 so ,,. afo:e-&aa1<1 dcRoht1l"gt'nd:nt .,t-loh "aid t:<>rt l wn,IJ\d he ~he ea1<1 Ja,;ee lt, Lee ilmrcl ta tel,• d10d. And "o tho Jt•~ore afor,,,,,!1<1 u on ti,,.ir oath a!'ol'naa1<1 :o na,, that thn • td Pink 11~rhn1u·, hL'1 t•·e no.td Jlll:les I!. J,ee, -tn the m,nrun- ~ny thtt me'l:nl! at'orn•ll1'1, I"n\on1011al,·, wilfully• an<\ or 1118 lll!ll1oe aroretho1w,t '11<1. k • 11 ,n,t mu:r<1er 1·,........',.;,"",... Jf#~ c:r .(~,j.u,/. ulJ!,-r /J~~ f.t,.;; . ,/f},'~~ ... ,, J1 n toui,..: Hkkno.c. witr.cs,. .,•. r ,-w1,1111n 1,1,11.11Cto.i11 nllll• nt t(• th,· �•• )(,.,7L./k~1~~f~::---fJ-4<5~ '1 'U(.;-,.v....., ~ ft-~~~ ' • f¼.'°'1_,,L,__ 'r Ji<., c;;,,,,.,/..,, .(j; JI) t' ·' '., J. "" ~~ ~ J·Ji . "''I:,, ' ~ ~ C f11 ~ .... r ..,. f ,,' Q_ • )> -i lJ m r " t • ... _.... '-- --A tt~ • -1 t-, ,,;_A~ € I 4--,n- ;:' ~ '- ... () ~ 0 -::l -::l 0 --" :I ;:. 0 Q Q f ;ii: • ~ • I ~ (t t: =r �•• • •• ' • • ft.:_~ ; j :-"t,,,.. f, <=~ ,.___ L.._, hi ;C_.._ C v<.A • J L 1J A tr~ -2,._.,....__ :.~ 4 (' .--.-::... J' ~.:....... i._-_,r o-.,- 04-,t-c.•-~ ' s---½- -i /,rI,,,/4. 4 h-..- . .. ~ ~ 0. • - , ) )~ {'h;,.J 7 ~....,. f,-.,y_ n., ,/.(_, /:----z.? -x..?....._,_ '~ ~ A~ 7~- 4-, ~ ::> , ~ ,,._..,..-✓ /4 - ~ ku'~J L,.:.._4:_, ... '°"'" ·z 7.,_ )<-<,... . ..,._,__;J ~ ;.,.~_,- ;I·-)--,., ~..../4....._.:.. ~ ~ ~ ..__~ ;J ,,,._ .,_,_....._ )l, /-; ~ -4. 1 .L~ .,..c:_ ...c~ 1 ~ n.... C....._,/,-4.,c~ I►• ... ,1; / ,,,.. '--' «< ~- L-..-. . L ,-. f_, ..__/-... .... ..._·_.. Ti.... ~ /,<\ 0 ht.4- ~) Ii:; C'~ Ji,,_,, ....,__ ....... ~ ) u.,,f ~-,,__ 11._,,~...~ l'l ~/ .a. ~ £....., - ..;.u,. ,-_,Jl.._~ c..-:.r -~ L.,..,U. f- • •••. <_A.~ a.~~; .<l..,_~<-<. ~ .,.;_~e...-, ...._ --~ ,,...-- ·L.....d ,,...£./ ~ ,:>(~ £ c....:.._ ~ /~ ""---<> 7,_, 1, - ~- ,. J✓ '-? ' J...,, J,~ ~ />- ~- h-..J , ..__ . ., .,.._•..-f . h,. cc_ '7J c~, .......... ~ 7 .. ~ -<.._._~ "'-•.......) 'lr It~ •• :. / -~ ,<,,.~,,.<......,..,._ ;,.-.('._ /'----? . 1,- L..,..__, t..,.._o r"'·--.J ,___...-<. J - .t... /r-.~~· /..,-~ .je•, < 6-('-' ~-*""- '-'. ,~ /a.----., ,J.,___~? I/ ,.~ ·- -./4.-:L.. ~, ""-~:J ~ ., ...... ~) 1-:_ ~ '1 r,:.c-..,.,, A•('-;./,'~. IA, /,,,-<.._. t.._._ -L.....:_J~~~ < f-:-..-.-r,')~.Pl- ~ µ,_,_:.. k-....L,,.~ l', t_, ._:;_ ?, V _.___ ,!? ,--Cr.:a,_......., ---..;J . . . C. ,.,,-r'"'----..4 ~ ,'~~ - , ~ /1,~ c:.-- ./4,:J--<7 /,{_ ,2 1 "\ )-/ ,,.,, Lj, t_, .,..;z__,, ~!· ,.,,~/4 ...~ 11.. ~~ f/ /4_,/U~ /u.----.AJ--G ----7, L-- .I,._ ~0 /4?~ �•• •• ' c_~- ", 4°'.(.,,; ~-~,--~ _ c.~ _ ,,_~ .;L ......,...., '1 ~ -~ ,1-1.....,--iJ./"i.., r-1/~~ • L t--..cJ..~1.., t-c.. ...&-.c~~ ti< '1/ ('~ ✓ ,I.,._.___ "'-..:f =~;J • c.-./, t.. ., -'7,' J.- 1~~ / ;; ~,-.. Ro-, ~ ~,- .._ .;.7, -.) OL, " o ·1/.p,,.~.._.,__,-- h., ✓ Ju-...,&~~:; ,_ /,.,_ ·~ J...--.r,J--., • ~a-R.-< • /2.._:; 4~ ,~~ ~ :) /.. -~. • • tL ,_.~,,_./ :> 7 ~ r-- ✓ ,,_.,__f)_ ,? t-.JE- /-,.L ,._ Z, ~ C--..-j-, ..::,J ~/ ~--"~· e~e .:.-,. ..,...,,., ___ ~ '"-- • ~ ~) ... ,,,~,. ~--=-' t>('h.,::, fa! 4'-yi:;. • , • - 77' / . F, ----~ J:,••• /)- I',_ t:. •-.F / ,·<,.,._ ._ , ~ - ,:.__y7/ii.._; , --"--"-.,,. C, < _ ....._- ~- µ.--.:,,,i;__/-:::'} ~ /2::; ( r.c--t:.._·~, 1-~ �• •• &l ........ . "•••••• r l-. ,, .. ' ____ ......,,... ,...... ....' ...... ,.. ...... ~ l. ·n:-.u,,n '\"!t"t'<~ll ,"l' ( '"'l""'All. .. ~A"T•f \\\ 10n. T. ll. Aalla, Olltney Spr11'6a, la. £neloeoci you nll t"•tt:.on;, find ~xco~t1ona and recor'. Pill~ tn the caaa or Co,:;::iorr.,ealth ve. Pc.r.k P,irbour. on paga of oaoaway•a 4 'Wit.neoa, I do not agr~e testimony or le". and on page 5, e~~~ that. oaeaway ueed the -wort18 "upr&llll\d.• or tho words •as though to strike.' '" also d1aagree ~~•••ay eaid r~agefi) that Pubour dld not have the aupeer1U1se to n1m ot· bfting '1.l'un~. 1a LU. l'~ul conton1a that 09aeway tont1r'tod Bubou:r 'll1>neared to hi~ be under the tnflurnor 10 ftam-, .. iinose, pr1eoner PaUl contends llr. duo ~o tho light In the ~~o he saw J:1n or aocetl:1.ng of He~"?"f1onis t~ie Witness test.1.:'"100. ·h~~ 1 r•om orottoe enter~ Wo. 4. rn order ~~ or thst eo~t. 1~) ~e dt19.l.l'P8 (»~~ sa• to the one prepared Very except Parbour •1th~ u to P~'•ant or 1 have urnpar~d a ~1ll which 1a att9ohed the saloon. Those are the onlv dU'rereru,ee In our vi~••• that but that tile .11:t:terenae 1n appearmoo -l ·ht 1n Which 01 ~111 of l•cept1ons tn •he u,etln:ony or o:t t.he oaoo rrorn ,.t H l1'l ~e~t:~on7 LI ~o Yhether •h~t R~rhour ·hat ~aea,ray teattfled uuon the trial 1001ted '1iff"erent l~pt,ared at t~o etablr. ,o or l>etng drunt<.• have the appeuance that of oomnthtng.• And M. Poul does no, oonoedo that 09Raway t~sti·1ed •~l~n•t to 'llllothor ~~ceptione by Mr. Paul. tT\tlY, to tho l!llltter the d1tter~nco upon that pc1nt, {µ7t-£_/! �•• • •' • • • • • • • , • - • • • • • �..' '• • �..' • • I I I .-l- • ��• �•• • Roc:-:1n"'l-.flt1Coutn.y, to-wi 1.: 'Me.re.re the unrt,r11ened "i.'hin Lt~ 1)BrAono.l1•· appein:'I:" ... .._rorn Faul, an,1 mrt'e orith th.at; he eo,,rl of Pockinehei, co t11<>r•·~Ith j s one o'f' tJJe atto:i.·noys iowity vB. !'lnc:·"'"'I to t\efend ilerhc-..-, with o f!-)1on\'; rm<iupon t!'.e txiol ~9;-l'Nll' ~~11 1'oun<l l'"Jilty a:ppointAct by t.l,6 ~11C'l".'!l! Pincl<::1:r; D~rbour tn t1,e ~ooe of cherginf tr.e esid P1notney wl~e!'eo-f' in t:ia1d Oirr.·.Ut .;o-.u-:. 011.111 of' 11!Ul't:!ertn the fl.rat ,ieP,reo, on011r nn e11p111l l"rOlll eaiered that upon the trial i,.,.l tho evi1onoe ha4 been lntroduoed. ••tout In Bill treated ao ~art hereof, for Commonwealth and argument the 'lttorney of ,:,:captions ard w,-11 11<1u1-1>"...d.1,, ctetectlnlf i,y their luty and wuning verdict, duty by oounael the of the 0100,tng erguinent to that a91d jury to .RUard aga1net !" wubetance t1es when the state the error of tailing toward the state and •octe•y. rt.gl1t of aocuaod, peal, Pl>tl&l y the Ind the Court etl8taln"d it had nothing that the prisoner of the defell4ant, 8DD•ars1 tn rt trial t~•reupon the attorney ror etste,o,.nt made by htz,,. to Wh1c~ objection verdiot the trU,l errors th!l.n should thelr p1-oper ,ienel- oolllmltted tor the oorrPct1on of •• to the by oounae., ol>- and advised ths ?l«ht v~r•1ct before the Co1'1!l'onweslthstated or ap- on the 1aw the jury, that had t,,,•n "ile, tt ba1 not bean intended other the jury oaoe, and ths.t, vhtle to do ~1th the prieoner•• and t~e ovtcL~nce au it anything •hlle the objection, to a just lntloate ref&-,.•fld to the •o 'l'hioh referenoe w~s enttt1ed w1thd.rt.wn, '"1<1 that or oolor or to infliot no such av~nue oxiated error jury that of the .,vld"nce, 1t was equ~ll; had pro1Je1•1v ln'lde out its ~vain.st the prteoner, tl\o the St •t~ u d society that the l4w DTOvlded an avenue for oorreotlon j~c ted. plea, toward to•srd ·he ~rtaoner, error tho a<oused, for crirr" anct nroeurtn, by way of ,-eoly oon~,otlon a.iunet ~ro. argun,ent by the attorney the jury ag- 1n~t 1nvaalon of those right• and reepon~ibtlitY 1 1n th1• to be ot the accused r•rudle~• •rd dwellln« upon the right• after 1netr-u~ted ae »o. l, whtoh is prsyed and after opening oaee, of thie and the jury the Colll!!lonwealt", tlurtng tor condition, wo. 4. and the eaid wse y 'l'h'lt l:e had said u-,t tho jury should render a just ~ ao<1or<11ng to the law and the evtclenoe as it a1>1>Glll'ed tn e.eou&ed. To 'fhloh action and atato~:,1" ~he ])~:rt. .. , ...... ,. t.__ Cl.-..... ......... ~ ~ J!_-,_ I.. -.,,.t.~ uf the &tt rneyor the Oommon~eallh, defendant by 00un1tel excepted ~-the A end tendered - this. hts Bill or &xceptions l to Mo. 4 and prayod th~t the '-• .... �•• • e • • • • • • ' • • • • • • • • • �• --2• r•~e be et,n&d, eealed r<>eord 1n th1• oase, and enrolled and be made a part Which ia aceordtr~ly done a-t-t!,e, ot the July ./ 1ay a~ July.--1910. ......... /i_,. l ,...l ..._· _,, c) _,..,,. 7'" .,,_ ? 417....~.( ~- - ~.. ,.,,.. # A e".~...........,___.,,It.., ,.__..,,,. '=--.... / f �• • • • • • �.. • •• fo,.i• ' /i_II I Ju.-/; . !) • • , ---, th. t. -·:i. •a -u: co~.11ti• • 1 " • C • - ' .Z."'ii-- , . .• t ~ ,..~:..·flll' " .' �••• I • - • • I �•• •• .. ..... , • 'l' " -~--- ~,. "' ,.. • ~ ... l th.- '" • • • Lr ')\. 1"\)VG,.. .. V, U::1 "' ('> . --;--.,i • :7 i •\ ... ~ i•f"~"l8~. • ,rn!,•h • n. .. ~ , -·•• c.~ 'u., . • • c::.""..-E~ :,.-,1 t.: :-ea ..en.~., • .. r .. i ,.., .. •,"- f) t· ,,.~, t.-_'t.. p •• ·t,, .... ,~-· .. -·' -~ to "1'd ~~e:-t.~~ • "" .., 1,; or .., r.,"' f" '! i. "1 d•'"•:ia-~ f ...... . .,~ •" • ... " l ' • •11 • ,,. ~:.~v'".a., .. ,,... '6Al':;.:. • • 'l c-:-:n i.l.-: ...,.t ~!. -.,,,,.,.., ¥y --~ ~~t 1r, '•t .•·..,•· • ' t••.,._ '1''f ~··\. ,...t. l 1+-::-1·"'l, ('l;"'t_f"- .. I ~ 'f'",":- • •.I �• •• . •• ,, ..• �' • C • • • WO.ft ubo- ...,.._ --. nusau11. ' L U.\ H l:/ u, t ,., n 'l: ........ ,. I ' • uw ,; an c.t1sala t. 1w 0 • t ..r.<I • r,~ , .. ,..,. •. �•· • • • �••• • '• t it • • ,..., n '-"'1:1:n: 1 • • ,. •• 1 ----'"'"'"" .. ...... , •n • t ..... .. •• 1 •• ''h O"' n . h ...... • ..- .' �••• • • • �) • d • t • ,,..,.r• ,r,n e l • ,.,1_( ,.,.. ' t • • • t ) ,,... "!I t~ ~ • ' ,. ,o r t. .. ·~- il"'("l"'-,p .. , '" •-at •• • • t• .. t ~ ~ "" • t. ~ ~ ' - i.l..:-c lt! 1 t-=.~~ an1>,"'nr,1r:c.-.u ·~e ~ • .. ' • *"t , .. .•• • t"· • • ·~ ....,.,,, • 1,7. " •< ,ri,.., • ~ c• t.::..lt ................,.,._a ct-~..;;!:'"'9' ,..,t, • ~ ,.. q,f"f>r, .....➔ ,. • to 1'111 h,..r Or to 1~11"'t •• r. I~ ~ • • n • ~ l o'.,l I 1 ~ net 1• tl:• f). 1 • ~•~ n C ... '\. I 1 ·i •• ,,c~...~61t. ,,. :,: -• ~J!"•tl • O,.t. t..°'1'• t • �;- • - -· �•• ' I .t.l • • ,.. ' ,. ◄ -i ..,.. -- I ,. [~tv ·- .,. �•. •• / • �;- • .. ' r ( �.. ..; ·, • • 4{1,>..,(_ • �t ., n t :,,-. t 1eon, lon to in Ell 1 1 oo t n • t ton or t.N! •l!T �• • • • �.. •• ('A ' , l1 • l • . ...., • \' • 1: tlv ~ u, ~ tn "nl n t11' ,, n t , 1.1 11t b ,nt • ·1 n ,.ir 1. ~t • ~ , ot 11, ~ "' n t 1 t 1 ' n \ • t t1 i t l • t " ly nl ' 1 l t rl ti•• t " ll • l 4 \v h • �.J • • • • • • �,. •• ., • r.,en t o l Jr tl:s k1ll1nC 1n vL''11l, tr~te•e D'\lir-e t::-o:i ~"'1• ~"l"'t. te'.1b~rato e."ld t,,-,.-=:tldi'ated �• • • • • �' •• ( t I • • elf, .Ci.t_~ ....,._ ..t...a. ~ 1 /............ ""'4A �•• \ • • • • \ - �•k 111il >~ 'f:L • Septllllll>er Olerk. 01rouu, 23, 1910. co,,rt. Rooldng!-.am COlltlty. Th!• l-'J t.a corU!';f I.ha!. t.he orne::- or Rooldn<;hlll.OCounty o lootrooutlon or Pn:X 191n, was th1& d~ dated Jllq or t.ha 23, l910, c1rcr,i-;. Co•·r-t. direoti"W t'>e BARBOURon the 23rd cl4',' or September •x•on.cd at 7,27, A,~. / ;,}J//4,~; (/ Superi..'ltandcn1., Vir.".!Ala Perot.entiar.,. ) �i· • r � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Rockingham County Criminal Court: Criminal Cases Description An account of the resource This collection encompasses all criminal court cases adjudicated in Rockingham County from 1778 to 1971, spanning nearly two centuries of legal history. The records offer a comprehensive view of the county's criminal justice system, including charges ranging from petty theft and assault to more serious offenses like murder. Each case provides unique insights into the legal proceedings, punishments, and societal norms of the time, reflecting how local attitudes toward crime and justice evolved over the years. Beyond the legal aspects, these records also shed light on the social, cultural, and political environment in Rockingham County, including the impact of historical events such as the American Revolution, the Civil War, and the civil rights movement. Researchers will find cases involving enslaved individuals, early policing practices, and the enforcement of social and moral codes, offering a window into the daily lives and struggles of past residents. The collection serves as a valuable resource for understanding the community's response to crime, the development of legal institutions, and the broader historical context shaping the attitudes of crime in Rockingham County. Creator An entity primarily responsible for making the resource Rockingham County Criminal Court Publisher An entity responsible for making the resource available JMU Libraries Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1778-1971 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights. Format The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource PDF Identifier An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context Ccr001 Ccr002 Contributor An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource Rockingham County Circuit Court Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1910 Title A name given to the resource Commonwealth v. Pink Barbour Description An account of the resource Defendant charged with felony murder. Subject The topic of the resource Felony Murder Creator An entity primarily responsible for making the resource Rockingham County Criminal Court Publisher An entity responsible for making the resource available JMU Libraries Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights. <a href="https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/</a> Contributor An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource Jennifer Taylor Format The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource PDF Identifier An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context CCR001_006_154 Barbour Lee