1
20
2
-
https://omeka.lib.jmu.edu/erp/files/original/Rockingham_County_Criminal_Court_Criminal_Cases/ccr001_010_312-commonwealth-v-george-cave.pdf
dbfcf65e33f359e656e0be1980a4b9eb
PDF Text
Text
..
••
••
•
•
y
1:
Wl l
.
8
0
I
i
wl l
~
C
; 1
•
C
t
tl'i
0.
C •
4
o.· •
1:,:
"
i
d I
• t
1
or
1a.r;r
0
•
111 ty
"'
111.l do
1 "o
t),
I
o-
I
n
e •o
e
lo
d ath.
r b
,. ,.
I
V
1 t
..
C
r
• e
r
r
•
!.
a.~
•ee,
ol
ru
'l
"
l
,r,
Cl
d
p
~
l
1
or
t I
1
fl
t
pr
I
0
te~
.co~
•
to•
i
•
•
•
ot oi
'Uilty
.1
t
'Ett"•.11
t
l
l
,
h
r
-
0
e t
iv
• elll'
t
s
dol
or,
ed
a
0 l
e
~
er
'
~
l
l ol
or
lt
e.
J'
1
o-• ti
••
'
•
0
1
•
ll!
8
l
•
r1
-
r
0 •
do
0
ot
•
r
rr
r
"•
l
l
0
,.
1
0
rde
l ,
0
I
d
or
l
1
rei
\
'l
0
0
an
ire
t
1
-
•
c~ le
e.
~
_ll;>
e 1
d~&r"
I
•
0
l
•
•••
llr
•
•
t
'Y'l.
70 r
111
0
or
1
l
lon,
.J "
e=.
0
ot
.,1
l
�•
•·
...
•'
..
,, .,
..
C
,,
"rr
u.
'
<•
.'
"
.
,
,..
.,.
•
"'
I;
¼
l
•
..
.... ..
f!
•
~
"'
�•
•• •
•
rr
ruote to
t
C
I
C.
J ry'
a
lt
o
ot. o , lYin
1,
"a murde"
C
-
1 h 1
11
d
l
~d,.-,,,
e'
,r,
roov,-kil'
a
lllllLN:tr;
. it,
•
• (1,µ
~,.,....,.....,...1....-,,h,
~ /G~~ ✓ ~~-
e c urt
in t
ots
•h
j•1ry
lh
o,
w
••~rlei
olr.
1lty
of
d r 1 t
de N
1
1'"
�•
•
�!3
~
C
'
r l
order
t
l vst•
0
•r
0
)"OO!
e otfe .c
f
Wl'&.1 th,
o
r,
'
-
e
•C
r
•
I
ed
1
b
1
l
a
l
0
de :ree.
4
l
t
fir
t de roe
rder
�•
r
'
•
)
'
I
•
I
- J
�•
••
•
rr.
e
man le
-t::T!OII
0
r
ter
...s L
k
..
lJ'
,t
1
&ll,7
l
1 vol
ot,
l
p
C
--
_$ •
C.
lonl
a •
0
,
r l
18
~
••
•1ot
u.
eboo~lr.,
d'lc~a ed,
• 0
r
0
•
••
l
q
0
0
1
I
1
&
'
1
'
•
11
•v
ro
l'!.30
r
1-
~
r or n
'
t
1
•
id.once,
ot
'•
a:i-ia
,
1 tox
0
rea
0
eceaa d. a
e
wa • ;;
t
1
t
L
r
l
•
1 a\.
L
t'l
'
a.ot,
e
1111
~
•
t,
11 0
...
i
a.st .
,wt',
J
t 0
lice.
1
1'npr
o.
,
U'1
r o
!
t
l
Ut
l ln
~
•
t
0
~
t
r,
•
<!Oita
D
lU': l,
d 11
1
and pror.iodi t
ut adoq-a
u.
ri
ra.to
ca 1
•
11 ~.Y
r
4 ..
l..
.:rdo
'
t
ed
ml rro111
te
" 1
~
•
t
'10 ree.
.,.
�,
•
'
1
�•
••
'•
7
co,~•
e
th~t
.,,
ll
= sba.'
·t
I
l
t"'llctJ
O takon
a
.-~ ·~rrar1rr-.
; 0 c.;.1,1r'"
t'll'r 1.er
t e z1111
la
1
,.
1
>:il1
to lilt
wi.L'lll,
fro:i
t t
!'\'.lo or law la
d t
e •
0
I
Ue Jui-;, t
truct
.1cl lb i-ate,
thi
~act.
L
J 1r, t
-
t
t:
ever
dJt t l, t
0
�•
l
•
•
L
�:11STRtGTl0 o•
d
"
tla
0
iv
u,\t
•
B1
crl1t tet
•
wt
"
"
,o~l
,.rt
~,I
oa
•
witn
1p of tl.
t
r
~
••11
teattf,
'tl!m:,
•
l ••
p
'1'
to.
1-.
t'
•' •
••
•o
""¥.
f1as.1 •
,.
r I s ..r 1_ ..
r
8
Q.il;r
ln
111
t
ce
11 'e+
A
1i11-
•
r f1fteraot
•
to ,on 1dtr
t
~a
r..,_e
tr
ill
,rGVld;
&
1
eotS.a~iLY
or--i: ••
.. ..
er dtt
lie.)
,1r
t
r
Jry- +
.r•-
at d
:13"
I.a■ bee
,ra
cl'.dl•
tes l
.. e
n
it
j)Il10ll
oeD.
J'\l!'
I
1nz: t. eir
un4• • all
Utlod
rt,
h~
\J. 0
t:1l"O:llrs\n
1 'lC
rnn
'
, eli be:::ite.
wilful,
• anC,: tw J.'0 \'JS
t
I
ro'1 ::1ti ....
raeie,
"'+l
rte
Tl
&JV
priu
k!l"•11
oas Gi n
oe.«ll1 ·••"lpon J.n the µrevio1 s
• ,dtbout
is
V •o .JO.ll+t
.:J_.
•
r t ••
l
c.. .,,,.,.;
t 111
ti.
lC
•e
• 019;
0
"r 1,e
.
et'!" de Jea.n;;>r
I ei
!'
..-c... t.1 ~_,
•r
- ••'
')
f':t\tl.i.11
.,,
or,
11 \
or l .ror-•
f'
-
0 h~
I
.
-
•
�-
•
•
I
•
I
'
•
L
,
---
,
�'
'•
-- .
rn m;rro?i r.o. I I
CNdi
t
wtt
•
~
n ~ue
1
Ion
x~l
1Yt1J
1• •'\at
1VLore a '!unb r of wltneaeea
to eao
o·.ter,
tt
vl4e:,ne
aa eq,.'llfy
int
r•
to
ap aarir.
~rt.h,Y of oredit,
~
otfe oe
t• e •"rJ
l o trlal,
:nn·-
11
wi,loh w\tnoaoe~
lvo creti ... aooorJi'lgl)'.
Uat
~
a ron,:
dou t
ble
ly e~to -ta no~
a.rd reJlao•
Rea onablo dou t i:rat
ar eL
e te4
f
00
Ord!
to wa.,.rant
to
aln
S'l
IL"l
It.
!t
~qu' ttal.
or ta.:ts
e:eu s.r; '~•••
'!lf
<-r
...
O'OlTiCt
.
~~
••
,t
• bll!le:1 upe
t~• oT14onca,
r, r:-..at not
"'ai>t
ta!..'C 8
t e other
0
evldc
Q.\1."M;
a 1,arent carclCi' 1U1 'llr-
lr
o
l!lllY e l.oneat.ly
t.· e ovld&noe ltaeli,
lw
tie we• bt or
llrd
and troa all
and t"
1 atru:,t,
oppo1ite
· 1b....ta tl ,, and
co, or ttsi.
d
<L,<i t,
i:anoo
ue• • douLt a
t.-8
dlreotly
• r. ht to
.. ,te! l!r,cnae,
'.l'b~ oourt
18
te,tlty
,sla.:ioed,
rt
6. p ..
oircu
""" JU
a-o
r
and t • la.•
: :..ry,
u.e Jur,v la 1.ot bou.ud t .. -
ti o~r .,,. r,er ot t.eetlt,Yin•,
tts , +,
or
o!
lllt)'
o lll'l:ltrar,,
J.St 1o
!t
a-\
J\18·.
:u-:,
·--·
or 1
or
\o
te,.•
Na
t
0
.la ~t Wltl.:)\.t
us nn'1
.,;1,
tc • ni-
bstu~!el
do"1,-.+ or
bel1e-re
,o fl
lD
ter1~1
:.4 a vr•-
") -ftCJ ~
t.a.:. 01
-
�t
I
L
�'
••
•
•
/~.
t
"
~y
• ri:o
" ur1;
..
tro
'
.
! d
• o urt .
t
it
I
"
"
C•
e &
t
ire
'
1·
0
n
to
'I'
t&
!
1
r
d
l
Q
tr
e a
a or
I
j_t.;_.
r
ul,
Jl.
u
11
0
I
0
0
l
!B r·roved,
la
...
•
&
a
1 -
�r
•
•
•
•
�T110 jury
h- 't°f'lltu
l
~?l
a.'.t"t-
i.n3~ri.:0t
!ntoxicati,n
~ !.'"'qt tbft burdPn
,.,. a J."'!trae,
i,
o:. th"" nc0u3~d,
if
t" p:>"'IV~ tr.11~ wte:, ,-.,e c.,~!t-
�••
•
•
�If
the
jut·y
t'te- .flocuee4 was und"''" t...,f!!influc
kil.lir.JI
~al:en bJ h1C.
for
!r1>m t·~f! e71d.encf
brrlit•vr
~~~~ ■ aid
1nt~x1cation
tht;, !\Ct d.-,n a 1'1y l if."1
u,i.lee:.
1
auc:h 1o.t?x!ce.;...:.i,n
lt:!l.i,1qi,r
in ,r"r·ic
de~~~p
t"'"e
tVt'!ttt
,r
wc.3 euc.
•"
~!
did
:!..... t
sra.~alnu4tt~r.
iJ:r guil tf
thJt
ce -:.! liqu~r
pr,dueP4
the:l belit-V-!
enta.-. captu:dtj.• 1o f~n,
t1.ey rr.s:y fin4
tl-.at •t
t d{'p!"i7e>
or mu..rder
+lie
1"olur.t.:1.rily
1• i~ la•
ff"i:,'ll
a ~iciou•
t1.Jrt of
vo •~~u~f
t 1·.-i cv!.,.@r.ee t't~~t
·1!:n e.t t.'1
pur,0-2~
tl,..•
ti)
lt!ll,
!n ~'h,.. atlc ,ad
of
�''
•
•
'
�•
.
,
•
A
~he Co'Drt
a.11 0r1!!11cal ca.sos,
tba
tile
1:1-trJCtlS
":be s'lWGecl'e
bu.icden o.t !)roving
hia
!o ro, upon a coneidorat
"'ilt
jcr,;'
that
1n th1S
plea of' not £"1lllty
oe:,ond reaaor.abl&
ion ot U.. wh.ole oaae,
ti:•
o! the
cuoe4,
·i.:,
ahoulA .:'Lil
~
not
-,,ut:,,
,j,\la5&66i'.
theN-
o! the
~hare e:,:ieta
a reaaonebl.e doubt • s to the o:-o
llt
hiu
a pre-
rr.
teet1:oony
the
and. the c1toums .a.110•• llhc,,rn 1!1 e\-10.enoe,
jury
.ralsea
doubt.
-.1ta.aaea
lllinda
in
,, ........
L'l
G! the ac-
tFi!itJt~•
~~~~~
~
..
�'
•
•
•
....
�•
(3
Toe Oou.rt inatr.a,ts
a.blA &>abt •• ~o tbll gna
~'1:1lt7,
1.!
vor,
an.:.!1.nd hill!. ga llll'
.caTt
naao:able
!irat
6ogroo
abl.o doubt
ooubt
tu,
s~.a.11 naol'l'O
togree,
t:.-.e • 1'41IIISOll-
of • t,1.o,i tbe priaar.er
that
o ! the 101 er graaa;
or the aeoond
th&;
to illnt1trate
shcal4
1! ;1,e3 hove reaeowiblo
him i;uilt:,
o.!' ;nszialaughter,
And
aa to 1ib1oh ho be gu1lt;i- at all,
L'l tnor
o ! the cowaed
::11.1 be
cl.""bt in hia. t•1r the;
of !lll,Tdar 1n tla
.!' lnd him guilty
1n
4oubt aa to whether
o! :.urder !.n the eeom,4 de 0 re• or ll111Ltalau
l!ter
he 10 gaUty
fin,
the,
if
do"t:"bt all to wmother ha 1a goilty
tl:o :,etlcnO liagroe.
llhould
a! of!euM
11'1;1 at all,
b
that
'l>o iar;
tl18y
it !hey bnve a reaeonthey
and eo<tUlt him.
must :roeol.-e that
�•
•
'
•
•
•
•
�'
' ,._j J.11Ct1f
I
'(
~
,_
~1-J,
•
f I
~r-
~~-
t. (. I I'"
-
".t1,I' rl1 "'I
!,,:;, ,,, •
, .....
,-"':(
' ·f
t' .
~
r
___.
; .
I le,
t/11I
•
..
/
,
~2
'
J
•
,(
,.
A,
I
.,
r
V
t1-/i(
II
'"-.: ... ,t:
,
fJ
/1,t,tI
I'
k
{?I,,,.,_,.t L
I'
.;
✓
~
'
,J.,£('/)
V
J,-t - V
•
'
•
--
~1'/
t'
I
I d">'Y
••
'
j,,1 /
v
�In the Circui1CourtorRodiin.!(lmm
County.
11..t ,: """
.,
'" .. ,,,
~...,.,. , """
rt·· a "
..
tA ( vt.
•""
n,.,,,1,..,...,,, i,ti,,J
,1u., •Y-'N'11,,r,,, rn,;,1 "'
!· - n
�•
••
·-
I
~.
,I
~
F
V
•
-
!:AL
0
t, e
to-w1 t:
;o rt
irauit
said
0
e Ju:-or
0 d;/ 0
t
o our.r4;~or
L 0
)O'llity:
o:t Viz, 1
alth
oq ;i
t 8.tl.
and
&tt
l OW
"1
•
or
said
1d.!..n
1
r
ave,
.J
oo
t
11:oro
t
1
1d,
aJc of
Wll
aid
am
o
c ~ec.l'th, t e
•
r
or
..a.v • ..... 1
1,._
ne
alt:
ol,
d.
•
1d
a
••
•
t
•
aid,
Do u.ltl,
" ltnil.Y,
strl
_o.
aid&
1stol
oresa.id,
•
e
i ,l
•
le
A•
!<ld
Urn
,.. and
d or
1a m11a
aoe
dl
lo
.lll!lll
1
•• Ouald,
'llid&
'0
o.
u
.....
ant ls to
·._...:Dona
!..:1, J.
0 rt.
s.e t
~
0
di
r
.•
tl
-•
ti
'
kill
a
0
-.e teet1
.Ill.. a 1,
.e_o?"
th.
d
0
•
0
J'S
HI
' lo
•
1r 011t
SAi
I
sly,
l
trd.er. a-
• •
an
l
••
10 I
0 •
~d
lo
Juve, I'
O< 0
id,
t,
•c-
alda
L
C
o= e Cava,
ret
aid
•
" ald.,
t e ear.JI
a
1
~
1
•t l
e o!uro!"a l~ar
0
•
tl.e
'
t. e s ld
•
RY,
14a
l
ds,
od.
do
_id
'•
. '• f,Ollald,
Sal
>
l
••
o•
~
Lr
t
oliy or h
01
r, t e al'
1
tr t
so as
0
ir
,
• •
_or.esaid,
o~t 1
1
t
Bid
d
to
ot'l,
tl
••
bullets
h
0
•
e Jave,
0
l
t,
d, 1
lVl
d.
' n
d,
0
0
a.:u
t or! to,
.•
,
..I
, fol
.U
ls
l d,
• Do
alda
el.
ai'or t OU t,
d o:t l 13 nal.!.ae
1d
on tl:e bo ;. or
l
. ~-I.
•
.
�•
-
~
...,
~")
I
..
.. j,j
....
).
0
.:
•
I
,I
t\
' i;l
...
0
.
r'
:
'
...
'.
..,
<
g
.. .. "
iii
...
,;
.... ....
.... ~
..
..
..
0
~
I,'
D
:,-
�•
'
••
a
■
•
•••
•AM.. , ....
011.PUTIU
,-,',\I\
~I.
Ut:LT:t,I
u,,......,,,,,L,,~~.
\'•
\,
t Ll:t.: \:,
t:i•wo, \"u
J
CHAS.
SHERIFF
R. FAWLEY
ROCKINGHAM
HARRISONBURG.
VIRGINIA
L ~ITl'W.■•
l'.lf;flt.'Tl ■ I
COUNTY
J I I.< I 'ii
M<.p('Jt•II
\i,
""'
�••
..
•
�CCIIIDJIF..ALTH
n.
GIOaa&
c...n
•
hlOJIJ
(aurd.er
l
�- --•
I
t
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court: Criminal Cases
Description
An account of the resource
This series contains all criminal cases heard in Rockingham County from 1820 to 1971. The historical context contained within these records is rich, and one can expect to learn about various aspects concerning the social, cultural, and political climate of the day.
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
JMU Libraries
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1820-1971; currently digitized: 1820-1930.
Rights
Information about rights held in and over the resource
This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
PDF
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
Ccr001
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1929
Title
A name given to the resource
Commonwealth v. George Cave
Description
An account of the resource
Defendant charged with felony murder.
Subject
The topic of the resource
Felony
Murder
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
JMU Libraries
Rights
Information about rights held in and over the resource
This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.<br /><a href="https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/</a>
Contributor
An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource
Jennifer Taylor
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
PDF
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
CCR001_010_312
Cave
Lucas
McDonald
-
https://omeka.lib.jmu.edu/erp/files/original/Rockingham_County_Criminal_Court_Criminal_Cases/ccr001_008_263-commonwealth-v-dennis-shifflett.pdf
496ec1a5aa00ade49a960a56de4b5f6c
PDF Text
Text
DDUIS SBIJFLETT
lntciaant
COVNOB~~TJI
for•
••loQ
���f
'
M
t
'J
����f
�•
•
•
•
In the Supremo Court
of •ytho
or Appeala,
held at
1n the ~'Own ot Wytheville
County
Court nouee
tho
on llondoy theie :ta
23rd day of June,1924.
or Dermia Shiflett
The petition
deas
to a Judgmont
county
rendered
found guilty
to bn confined
b8en maturely
said
Dermis
of ublawl'Ully
circutt
considered
rotuse
said
writ of error
al"flrm
the Judgment
•
of the r8cord
the CoW't being
doth reject
•nd nuperaedeae,
ot the circuit
court
by
whereby he
t~,-,,, of one year,
fore
aeen a.nd 1nspect.,d,
therein
W. E. t.uoae and sentooced
1njur1og
right,
of Rockin;t,am
ror a felony
~n:t a transcript
JUdgment 1& plainly
court
and superse-
in a prosecution
Shirtett
ln the Penitantt&ry
Jud8"<0nt. a.toresaid
that
by the
on the 24th day or April,1924,
the ColllllOnw&alth e.gainst
""•
for a writ of error
havlog
oft.he
a~ op1 nton
entd petition
the effect
or Rockinghem
or
•hich
County •
and
1& to
�••
-
•
•
•
•
•
•
...._
.,
~
'(
.....__
~
~
I")
"'
I
~
\
,
•• I '
•
<
�;
"
•
,.•
'
•
-
•
l"
omoo b
A
\
"lill
tl:e
on ~ts pert,
~c:,o
in
•tot,
7. l.7
••
·i..:ton.
• s .tr •
Ye
ow lont_t 1.ere ;,rot. devuty
sheriff'?
Soven or ei ht yeua.
'"
Do you 'tn:l• the a,cuaod here,
..
Yea. s 1r.
"
"o"
ere does
~
»eo1a
8~1fflet,
a··s yon lcnow:1 t 1 °
ong
ad o~ h:!J:
1
in<roh~4
bout
o 11T
u,a or tl:ree
yearr.
~
414 11.,., •~12th o~ Jll:to:1.
At
tl
A :ile
arul
In
oekln
sonn
t,mt!:.B
~on
•he bl'ld;o.
ham •our,,·
y "·
Yoe, sir.
'
::,1·1 yot ,
-r. Luoas,
arreet
I ~.
hiffla t on o. ohltl' -~
• •
�..,
,....
•
•
•
•
l
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
I
,
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
A Yea, eir:
":,,y ld.
·ow
he travel •nr
Q
TA\!I
he:, J .i. c:nae I "'h'J ts1'"r,at
~
A nn Wf' in G '.ord tottrin~
oa:t.
r.b.ut was +· .e cl:n::-re... Wh; clid 7ou z:rrec.t hi~'!'
Cb joct 10·1.
~·.u.
l
1n bod OU t;,;.y 18 und a r.;;m co:::e ,.- d
W'JO
>.IlOCi.:~d
on cy Jcor at 2 o' lock.
l ooje::;t
l'r . .ffi.t:r.:er:
toll
Wbere diJ you arrest
,
"10
what
hil!,'
•
car.
h..a.t !B tho way we
::o'lld,1't
i;o•
awey wl,'1out
ri:10·1
•
!>$rn,ls Si:il'flet.
ro
Q-,,.:1,-.isa1
de1..t, ao111etltng :o
e.
or 081"
""'
i~•
A i"ivo-p,saon,:er.
·1rg.
A We ~ 0~
,
a~ to
''"?
\Tho ftD
A
<l.rl ·:\
rem peoplo
:.
q ;n,.at klld
roe.I
to thnt.
"f.ou.neodri' t
anene:I t"!:.ert.
thet'I,
on unnd
OJJ4 l ,cld
bin
,l the r&..!'na~or,:er pl~·.:e ... i,;,o
to ca::•
'
•o ~Drrluoo·•urg
ao be :'U'11ed
�'
•
•
••
•
•
•
•
•
J
�t
3
O!l
the latt
road to•,-ra:-dnt' o Sl.kton ate-re,
•~o oroo
br1d oat
•~a llttlo
to~ .....as 11ui-r1eo 1'mrr,.
! navor
I ou
"U-e you goins
''l'l.ry
&W&,
•nrnod
en~ be Juet
our.
"e
=tnr
1'la8
~
l.if'e o oopt
"• fOt t
tho :'irl~r•
to coo.rob b:1.tll - ha eai:I.
oar 11ny fro::i "'~ tor liquor~
•aa wheel
-~ cnt ~in -- a suit
Bl!d
ln
t?w ovorbod.1.
10• bllva a oba•, -~ to ,.,t
111
JG
A't>out l~O :11,.rds boforo
to tn.ce lbii,
tt
t4JCJ
=
bed lho
+hn truok 'lnd
01•,-a.:ieiS
out.
the
11
t never un,lt
aroUJ1d w:
~Ill"
ae (Ging
oaaa elx 1nob~• t,t~k.
..~
-....,_.
I Gid
ten or tMtl"l"'a mi"oa
A e~1t c..ao botnon
1·~ht.
all
:,;,at 1'• said.
Joo
dorm ove,
':'ho car
I oal ll,
it na
en
b~t•e~~ her
him.
t"1•
J.
auto:iobtle,
About l 'lO ::,a1'4s.
:lo ou roo10ll "1:etl:or ;,cu he~ the curt.1rs
A
Yeo. 111r.
~
Al! &r a.,.n4 •
A Yea.
Q
A ~•
air.
About ll.ow 111th le 1t at
point
thle
trom Wbero tho orant oaae hit
'ho alm•~ent
on t
wbero the
car aft
t e r~ck~
A I moaaure4 it a 4 it o:eaauroa 10 feet
t
'll'llero lt hit
the rround.
~
How fill'
:i
~" t Too,:~
.\
"'1:e ,·oclt 0:1 the 11but nnt.
;.
i!ow far"r
la 1t to 'ho 101nt whsro 1: "1nall.Y
A 1.bont 10 :riot
af~er
it lo-rt
,i
in the .liver
l&n4ai
C'no or t>co~ iarre
to thil rro1uld 11horo tho our tire\
L
atonoo
t.i t
be wal1.
flow rnr 111 it froo
whore it
fl11a.llY
J
<ll• top
1&11ded?
ot
tho nbuta,&r.t
to the point
-
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�f
4
I oonld
-1.
..7(-7'~~"-'
~L-
•
1efi
first
just
exactly
he frOund
hi'
/4
2:ow tar •. but
~-- ✓...._..Ac?-~ ,__
fro?!" ~ o.ud ebou.t
abc-u+ ten i'eet
t, • ~ar
not cr;eacure
...2. O?' f.3 fee•
was
it
/., ~ ~~,
-"ram 1il:ere
:t-,:,. ~ •
waa ahout 32 o,- cc\ !"eet "'ro
Q
It
"'t
Dest;1ribe to ...he j•Jr,Y :ua!
t~• abu-:n,m t.
1,bat ~u.rr-oned aftcrr
the cal'
abut • t tha- mornill€.
·1,
l'Ock, '-'l<4 th•
:uat ,. • .,. rieht
oar
cvoi:-.
tt tt
u'hon ho swni,
ltit
"'rout
~owsr.
tli•
oril
o
,.a lhe curt·.in~
""" on.
'':/ lOf! ,ms rast a
ched
id
aro·.n1,l and
to
I tried
!3~
at hi.1 wH
out of 'ha •~t~r for 2f or W minu •a.
:iina1u.n:'i s-ot r.1m out,
00
au
he b~ lam,
I eulle~
~
~"z,=::c:i:·-~•
ourtaina,
a.~
ton
b c
,'but pos~tlolJ
wa.s +te ~er in wnon ii
i'ine.ll.y
:tmded
t1t1 water?
o-ver.
t'n
tl'"r~-- it
o.D .it.
hoy
o~ the ll hta
·na a""ill
burninr.
·ae burnillr_.
I se::,n that
myself .....
tu.:,.
J
Tt
:0\\ 1
1cop
ater ..
II
Yes.
A
It was o~ou~ -- ! e~peo• four or fiTO tee~ deep.
bout 3:30.
A
Yes,
sir.
intt~e
in
�-
•
•
•
•
•
•
�' ,I
•• •
•
•
•
1111ere
:ton corooioua
1
A
ti1.2a':
a.11 the
v-~a. sir.
sll
~1ew
..hat Tw.pr---ued..,
Yea.
D1d ;:o•, ehout or hallo"'
i.
·,os,
..
30
l..r.
...
I hollo,..,d
~1,:-.
o: 55
r.i'tllte11
T.acu.
cuito
r.nl l"r. ~-ouderbnch oo e •
--
IIOt!!ltbl.J::,~ l!.:e
t
the
·t.;.
• t L'lJ=:-.
;w:y
1:r ~.
o.,.. a compo,
:,ou
t!!l
le
~
l\'ere yea taJ:en io the
A
Veu. GIr.
'
'!ow .. onr- v,ero 1011 tl-.ore
•• 23"or
'
+-1, ue
t
T
3
we·e,
b•lis-;e
liOU,Pi tal ~
~
! + fJn went
110
0
,.nd c"cie ba.ol.: ag:i 1!!.
7ou a.re w able to € t arcmld
LOW e:t'"Ct3J'!
1
o:.· c?"1;1tc·1ea.
"' to use
T
no
wht.t hlB
ltlt'I
OU
•
l.: 4nl"l -:l!'llr:".k o:- so or"
oorli
u
to
"Lill YCi\1do11crib0
r,.
lltt
not tell
ar:i
I
,rn9re It
,ue.
ut'f",
...,. C.01"8 def:.nttol:;
1-r,ri,
�•
•
.
'
•
•
•
I
•
•
•
I
I
'
'l
•
•
�'
•
•
•
ore waoh -- l:.e ,;nn 1n
no of ""e toi~
.. houaea on tr.o Uo.rnab&rFer
rouli.
•
- r.t 1s U.e r a.d l a.din_ oa.st !T0"1
11
... A.oros
pr10~ •h
old.
•),is,
railroud
ar sbt"ree:r
l-J .tondUl
...ee.e.
O"; t.i
rord
on
o • t is wa;,•- to
•le
e~e.
nt
o,. • 1
81111 r.as 01 1t aot'le c~ tteoe
i1
..
the
I
de
"""hat
0110.
OT.. r7
•01m o~ illtton
·-
~le- 1E o!"e wnat1
na
Q
o :i...-er
t
C.!!.ae ft.O
old rc.ic1.t!a. Jtore
~
1
1;1
•
S1'1tob" ap hue.
the
~o
.~ter
70u ercsa
u.T'nsber {'~T ew1 toh
i 0 f'C r· ther
l'ar,:is'berf~r
ooTer
t,..an
tJ,ore =ir.~o I 'bees
to 'lmsh.
"'bat• s
horo
llllf I
oon "tt re
1r.
Y•
k. d ~ en doer.
:rellow 11..,,e.
ia~ fOiI
~
E ot eidc goln
"
l:'Oll,
Q
:
.,..
,.i '"h ti•
aw,,;:esv1tle Crea:: co a :!.n be two n l tc
r,; oun1
on
A -I
porollel
aouth
orfcl
ewl.tcb.
"'Nt"B
&
r e
01;0 er tt\e 'lcrlol
.oe+eru~
BC~tt. 708 Bir.
,ortt
or c,uth"
Gil".
ter~
o
raiload
t 1B -l' a ror.d r,m IJ:
alan
Jil'uot 1-=all.J
�'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
.
'•
\
'I
Yoe, Bir.
A
•
Q Ion ~GJ 1.110 rea
err l"athe-c 'tbe
•· ere,
tc P""3
on you
l'1V r roa4.
1 t!io tow,es
J 14
70-c. ca14
'"1ffl.et's
cf
not t ll
rels
*-hot r 0url do,,..
.iJ
ir
dol:
BO
,011. ,d
lves.
•
Y•e , Bir.
A
q ..t
.
c-
t
~
•
Yea.
r.1-t-e
you did not
CCll'lt)
aorosa
tJ-
Vo~
;roud.
!'ll.
ld rarnsi>er -er plw,e.
611".
,, This
1D the ri-ver
,.no "hut
tho r~d)road
and tiler•
ie
a cro&""""'n:hero.
•· 1
ortb.
l.ll
\
4oW'l t'io
-~
t~i■
a d Lhll! we11t.
Thia iu ti-e r.,utei I took.
h1:..1.
'..'J:1e la De;init.
I .:OL.et.o,;:n.• ~arusOer er' o
Bblfflet
there
•• houoe
-- onll of
•
•
.i. Yea, air.
..
•
Yeu. sir .
bervor place you•
rD
r.or:b.
,
llol"lhweet.
,:
You. orotEert the hL1 1 t ov.ard the hotel.
Q Yo~ aoid so~etn1~
r:arnsbergor
J1l"ae
about
:,o'.l t ld t~is
co:rln
,;p the b~ll
r.,an you "·,.nted
at ta•
to £0 to !Je.rr.tson-
bure
1t. Yea.
e\r.
~
roa1s
t.t.ere.
Orie t,0•-e towu!
l"al4'S
old 1:-on abor and one td•,c:r·'1e tho i:ot€:!l.
Q
Th•r~
i•
0110 ro1<i thAt
goea out
to
the euat
of .;11<ton.
�•
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
••
J:orfol
-eatern
...,J..i.lroa.d.
"'"en to yv,.r r1 bt
la ¬h r road•
A Yea.
A
Yes.
~
l:etwem
n.r.~ :.at.n pie
\
;hat
<>l!lt •n4 trllere ycu ·nrn
rll!ht
1a t~•~e aey riYer~ er a:?"oek~r
to "arr1eonhur!.
Yea: one tTau le.
'l You £0 !":tl.:"tt.13?'
n-:irtb 11~0 ...ain Streat
;.
to ·h•
"o,nade
!!igl:.t
bu:-p, llllil s~ra1
1-.• aheai
ne turnei
t'a.tardl!Tllle
~rul l•i't
to the ll!?ol.,Bala
l:cuse.
of
..l.cton.
to,;,,rda
1!arr1aon-
oorreotl;,
n
veo •
.,,,,, ,ou coma on ou·
Ilia
th• llla1n ro11d to -akton
1h1•re
t'111/? ooourrad"
,.,., ~fas.
nn:,1.J:
hla
t1on
1,. i:!:'. l'm::::,er:
~ - ....
uc~.3. wt;.e.re 1ou ar-r•nJted '~.
house la r1r:1:~ &lon
aiie
ti:"
orfo:..t:
:10 or ~O ;va:,,ds o! ,r;!Jo:o tie
a d "'1thln
!o~n.
ar.:l I he rodd
public
o~or •hloh
>,ot•l
1n 'he
e1lst,
thtJ aa!":6 as 1f yon i,ere a1•l1n
1 ht
;,on
roll.i
aomea to ne
ant l11n-'e dl:-o~tl.
hera goinF Ou" en.at
troet.
ow ur.y ?, I
A
A.
Yeo. Y•.
.,~ a
ti
Jo,ra
:.oo;,arda.
c •
l f't o
a.r -:ha: 1 1
n
cit
�,-,~
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
.•
•
,
•
�•
Q ""'at
•
. ,..,.
. ....r
l
road
l "9.:S
-;; ?:at la !::now.
"~tho
"';;.,..~lee
s
i,l"
1 Mo ro•
-.
·nc
•
••
• -'
cu·
~:lt
1
'
kr
~
•
or . t •
SJf,;r
}_11tt
.
-'"I:
0
r-
T.O
·•ttle
o,:¼
t t n,:p
>,111.i.
•
rt 1
arr.lllll
A
Ye!:?. a water
"
AF
I
brid;:--e.
n4orntoof
I dor
1
'
l:llo,1 1.1' too
,·ou. ,,.ou 011111 tiim-ei J:0s
'o be· e.
ro~11
~ al-"'
4or
l11.: t
L·a),.
•
.II.
A Z"lree .,~!'11 thero •
~
,;:~at oluo
A
Jugs a.
"'1.ll
on "b.:t
floori
~ C'l.'lll ,
•
A
,;"hey ~•:1
tl:s ~•1~ betwo,n
1t o
'"" 111'111 r.
+ne fron+
J~lf!let.
I
sna
t.
'"'ho
t1J i
+ ca .je
ws....on
�'
,·•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,
•
�,
..•
•
'
lO
•
'!'he - 1 t e..ae
was o. •he ueat
c, t
1111dt e luf'I
A Yee.
A
Yeo.
air.
n&t
1!1Z9
Jiv: rre:r· u,~,.~
one PAllon juro.
Tl'..r~.e
'l'hreo one rallon
Yt1c,
~
;'11€'3...
ir.
!tow tCifJ wue u.n o.rdir., ...;.·.,, or4
•
e_· r tr
A
the
right
Ye
Ir.
'il'.&Te
l
.:1;1.rw ic:
tlJ.e dI•iYcr
··s
o14e<
,o do r
I e l\l...,t aide"'
or or1r~t•H o
A llo,
ir.
Y'!,
,m ycm "oro
t'let
I '-l'i
!'I
Gtaloi
on •he r I ht
if-
left?
Vos,
3ir.
in the ba
Ar.ythi~~
b!i ...
'1 11'!:tbt 1nd of' fixt:ires
\
Jur,3,
an,,
bot•1~a
·,ac,: ~he1· ?
~'ill!l
Jif'•rent
--
inda of
1o e a: in" Too:: mall
1D.
"1,e
of
it.
!
~
"Ion 1lid
lot.
I
•1
o
J3.
I
•col:. a seare1; 11 t.·
,
evo·
lrar..
ar.:,,
; irn
~uet
t,l~
· e na sellµ,•
it.
~
o• ..n fn t1~0 wo.:-ll ;:, caw~ bl
to & ite
oft
a· br14
...0•1-1n • e:.c.oept a.r-:-.est t1J:t •"e ~ a'& I lo
l!e :lid r.o+ ros~ t 1t
A
:o, sir;
l·e dla
l7ttnt per!,:,:1tl
A
Yes.
Sil'.
O!'
mu.·o a fi
not.
qu:h,tl,/
al t
;;•
ft!:.10n
1 o.
�•
••
•
•
•
�•
••
•
11
,iedl.roct
•
, ...r. _"'""' ·
.. C,.:.l:ibJ.t A".
~
oxa..:1 '>tion
,:r.
ConraA:
1 !!ere .tl1 ~nna •"
JC•~ lc.1n1ly exa1 ir~o lh
dill
to the j ·r;.
:ina 111about
~ll
whore the
.:Ar hit
Juat
!liia -:-ee an~ at~· ,t,ht~nAd
top o
t ,o
•hn•.
"'!.l •
,.:.,o,rt "'ow~
A
a.a :.5.
tltt
abut m•
It
~
.i:.a:
A
A.rou.:ld jut1t abcnt
t:irnai
-- about
It ~1. t la tree
J·it
over
foot
ta,
- • etrai
ubo--L
fTc,:i
the
11,,nod cp,
...oont ...:-..or ..:-3 feet,
or..i:k a r ..L?lt
!'"'ltS
tco a!cr.
~t~~t I
11.uou+
bao.; up.
:cet.,..
t_ ....,,,.,
-
tzp ,•~~
La and ae t dow:-1t'-er,,
h•r~ •t-a: rost
_.l.,
c c9 '.as b~e~ rut
Ul d explu.111 it
Sare
Jr.:,. '
r.cw t · l.s
it.
phoio(raph
4Y
E: ~ ... ~i~
....
o.
11 ,~a1~ tlotm-•11 to
aro t>cae ;,ro plctu.re•'"
\Tl. tll<JD,)
tho
Olld of
tlo
~ •1t
the
.,,+id
t. atl
8U1'.1
otiatlnr
wi.ere
tba.t pole
10-u
if
0 1
,mt U littl~
!3
--
ueo it --
~lt
'IP tlu:.t
T;.ph1: •'111: a iJo
e.,,., tJ at roe::-:
1-:i,y.
"1,e
O!U"
had
1-irl'
A
Yee. tir.
t.c~es.
':r.
•s.mer:
A 'Ice ro,l:
Q
• nt
,,,.u t)iat
d!i
,ou l!:lio1>te
suei.: up.
at
tlUll ~•t~
You l:now l ta
6
~nt ronr
or
�•
••
•
•
•
•
•
'
�•
•
••
lI
I 11:,, t ..u1r,,
A
1·0..:'.t
wall
!llong
rook -11
ro~k
st1o
~o
pho•-~apb,
•c~
.,.
J • • ~urr:ia.1 :
tru•
l"1dtr9.
/ha•
\'!ca~ 4001
::ea a,
C·
+},"
&!.JWJ;; 'Ell
:l:w Wc.t"' oxter.la
o 1s
t-,r.o o
that
"" "-> trt 1 X' yo.r4l
Ye-.
t
'he
bu,;;L
.P-::r-c,
r1't••
+ •
ioU
r. 1..!1
ere
"'blit'
trom "1 •
•h
...1d ·a~
p! ce &tia "b.ci
:o.
-::~ poi e on • al:.itJ.
+1-on toe
rl
"le .:.! •'-o b'rid "'.
~ate
t:1
llr>it.
r! ht thPr&
,. 11!1 otnen
t
!B a. otrer
there
rldce
'r.erc,
•
co: vc:-
1t~
~1"
hl • ! laph
,:, p-oL
i!:3. 1 l, t
r.4 1 hat r, t l~p'lone.
~~l...,.,n •~c e1~otr1c 1i ~t ~~••
ol.'.
1
to:p nf
iml!Jate:
po!.• o!"
t
rs
• •
~1ir.
·, ~d C9t '?ecn thAt
A
,o
)"?
D ln ".J>:l:1~1t
c.r p!'"or,ibod: i::e al>c:.· ,.~ Jc:1r tlle c.r.r .a~
tta
• :ol
'iene r<>ll 1
iD uO~ul 30 or (0 feet
-~not
'!Us•,
04
jUBt
at of .,...,e l'fllte
a '-1tt1e
~ror •te
the
c
t~e
~~~~
,t.,ero 1ou enter
~i ~.
1 rur~her •~1a •• onr t
,
tla
1e at n!) e:tio.ka O-~ •';ioro.
A "hat ia bael::: 100 7ucla fret
,.
T"-a.rt o!
the toad,ro,•'
~ho"
Uo, +-1,e road.•.ra~, ie hit;he:-.
out or. the en.at o'
4
lee 'l,
is a l'uot or n<•t. from tJ:;.t poi, t u:r to wl,ero H,o
Mr. ffa .=er:
~1ce•~J.~
ing 0·1t tboro.
o"lt 1~ ,w-nro, tho oar waut o,·e,r.
that
bag1r,a 1 J:;• •001· mil 1 la r.irher
A
•1
I he
atlc:Ce ou• thoro.
It
feno•
~ •0111
3!t~
not.
lr 1i1 "'& t~or.:t 113
£s·
1 •
~~
Ju+.
J'tller'
..."''
., ~,
�•
•
••
•
•
•
'
�'
••
,,
•
13
'
•
l.CL'l>;;m11Jt., ,. o"h&r ll"itne
E. "
ace
aehls1~,
ll:-.
.t
A
r.o er.l.n"' •
... r.
wh._t are
en• Sida c-f' the
J"J
'".
1.wr.
honc.a..io~"l
•
ot hcer
r
• ,>U
:-·Jen:,ory for
A
Y~a.
~
JI.lOU
t
.L
Io ;
t t ""
A
ocr:ne
elp o,
'
Ls
oecuion"
'Ill"
Qi.!".
or 4c,;,
Ii
!'.at
it'
ffU;
3: lO l
"'i.n.e.
! va:,
in bed •
.•'bout
h~•
rr""'
•ar ""''
lt9r• ;yo, r<Kn~
at DO 00,
"'ee, e1r.
Jo ,1 we•. l
alo
1vorf
I l\e
"
Ve
'
.. cw,
A
ei:.
JCU
I'-
1, ..
11~,
..,-ound t:
Yo
,-1,0
.ArCan,
lnititis"'
fClll"'
A r a1r,poae it la 400 ;ards,
ut
L- 'he
'"'~
!r .
:>id
rzsrtle
~
:st 4 l,r t•"O'" , exn:n1
c 1 • i'i
... Yeo,
l I rol
tell
we:-o.,
wl!o •~o
......~" 'a:J oue.
".o.• 1!.d • •1r.
on
/J
OU
oi
t"-'-'':."~"'
"r.
L-
aa,
�..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
A
I t me o 1- +- ln th'9
~
i'11u1
t er,, t!le;r
• ~z.
:.u-=ao a
111t.. r.
1
1:,·a1-,
On
iTO
•
""'
t 'le trid
•,
- 1"f ...
f9C..
_:l'.
en to ..'8nn1s.
.,4r LI
ju t 11
It or ten
ti
'
oao·
and
on to Dewi~
' ...th"
1a.
"eel
if·l~et
~"" ol~!-:i
th
'2 Whet •ostt ten
..
--
~o 1'
"'1..c:us1mfl
r
i Tbr w out
., ir
na It
--
1• n W:ool
O!l
rL"":'BC:
er aide...,
• rond.
t
lO!'Z
ir.
-..••=.
S'" 1fi'le1' -.u 1n th., ..
L~:,a .m. 'tcl41..,
ti
head
.\
up mrt
A.
•a•er.
Io, 1 e w-:~ tmoo, oJ.ou~.
Did •on aaslo~
A
,.l!J
Yo ,
l:1r , • •'lo 11ate--•
l.r •
•
A
10
ul
O
i"/herP 'Illa.
it
-tto•
1 :ht side
half
A.
i1qt:Cl".
i,
to,m l ~
;"a
t.mu.llllore
rnl lo:i :ruil
11ot 4etoo
unn •·
r'I
the ea::-
elaeo
n::,"
\t
t
cm,.
oaor of liquor:
.\ Y••· &1=.
'l:
A
odor ali ·lit
1'retl7
or otr~D ·
st!'on~.
•
�•
;,
•
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
15 •
•
A
y
cir.
If)-:,
.,_...,a
..:, ·uz
.
A
Y•s, sir;
~
Do
"'
0
-~
•
Loud
a
leedt
4-
ba
bro
•
'
•
>o 1-
mjuro
~
.
..~.
yoi.;
~< Jo,
'J..--nr.l!l Jhl'".,.lot,
'°"
boi'oro th& t
ti'
·ou ~var seen
re
L be!'
I r.erti
♦"-'\
10
ot •
•b'!-.
ti•
<
• At
,::.t I
"1111,
" ..
0 •
11!J 'l'!'9d <
he w:ae other'" i11
a'>
.now hi
o had boo
!.
leg
k"lo,..-\i~e'"bor
'70U
never
/J. !
1
-~·
•cn,Uttcn·
ev•r
l:: ..ow
t,o
"""·
te:r,
11. u
•
r
rea117
11d ~ot.
tb
•
r•
Yl1l
•
0-"
t:
'he
C
I..Po·
..r1.1
•
no• dUll 11,li t r t .
J.
ti •
A
Ye • fli'r;
.., m.ia• •i
1_ ,o
Cir
1 loo~od
"J
114 you teJce
L
-u°te)" r
A
~-
..•
te::,
I think
A
l.,.
he!"e "JDdn' : .• so
are c ,
tho
Jt
1-'l.4
e to fin
t&J:en
1·....
tra.Jl'S .
tha-;. eu:ii,.....\tior.
0
!.ncac to 1ho hou .o.
c'clo.,
P· u.·aa•
tar
.ns : bow.
tc ct orv-e t e=. for
.,-
tl::Gt diSt&JJ:co,
tro
ci: -
t· e
�••
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�••
••
'
•
car lo"'r
He cibutr.cnt
on l h-l flt.-t-'·
To.r.e tbie
tho tr~,1 o ror eone distance
weat o• 'l-e poin
•ll.e a ut ent fror,
J 11'111.cea: you flral
-i,_e loft.
&nd tro.'.!t
rhc'orraph
w"t-ere tte
ear le:tl
•tere
the trr.ua
Ir-
basic.
et!ll"to4 ,111,~blo;;.
.,
wer.• bacl::
I f lrS7
'
~
Ccn11 you 81'J~?
A
'l'.ea. sir.
A
~1:0 plain
t Le
a lni tr<l>Dt _
.. Ill--&t;
.., on
eee. •1! to
I rllck
or •he
o::.r.
I traced
acut,._- t:1de ot +-he road. 1l.!l'il
the
1'
O!l
It
ot t!h .1-r l'
zal!lo \ e curve •
&VPt:
ourvo
to
;.,. Ye • eil".
lt
in tha e
ter
e-ooff
"t
so~.r.ad to be on th
o"' the
~ou-b Bula.
It
~s~
Tc,;G:d.
• i...arca."l:
C'l !Jld
ha oar 1""'lnc~t
cw +be uoutl: or 01 tho north
• rl tt bl>.~ aide aa lt ea....o •owarta
.a Yen.
\
A
or tb~ pica
arr!nc
t.i~o:
or·
R!.r.
oy aeer,o4 to
,'ma in a er,
YO.
e moro on tl:<I llOotr. side.
T
tl-.nn T-'here lt uta:rtei,
did
1
•
not
follow
o curvo .
lt
b110 an;- t'lll·thor
•t
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�«
•·
,.•
17
•
A
or 30 teet .
c...,
l<r o
Q
A It
to
•• eee4
~~
• =turnl
u."To.
;j
un11'or
Io vdl tle
l>le
1n It.
1
~
Abo·~ t,o"
\ r
v.orld you cay it
'Ar
did no~ oath
llccnil1np;
®3.
tl:alt.
auured
Lauaorb::'ll:.
Q U'.
feet
l t.
.ma J r-r 1)
oa I w<lera• oi :rcu, • "car
4"r
.t
· t1'!a·
,,,..
A
ffhl.i'tlBt
ffll.t'
YOB•
o
,.-au ot ..,nre~
L-tr. luoaa
.,_..
\."'S.8 411
ldc thC't
I
the ecr up,
r ln ~he wo.tttr.
....~ nn
•
•• Sit•lr.
on t
1.
1ttu;:: o'! the J"ror.t neat .
1
{,n .-
-!I
::i!e next
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�'
.
•
lS
•
ic>-
e
tort
~
.1..,11.::lh!fflet
'
'• •
A
rt
- •• '
d't
~
'
Wu
-140•
1ft.
"!!
l:•r.
ta<'
ut ih,
•1
.-ho le"t
'"'
•
t or l
~1
1a
n
A
<
11
clU' e.,.+irol.,-:-
ir,
. .
ur -·
~
..
arr ••
•
'>e
..
or:
uPe
,.,
juat
en~ lor,
••
loo
~t
•
o;,t •
OIV
1)
o~t
id
I
do r
..
l,erd t
•
1',
.
,0
ra.l.De
,
aeo :cd to
of 1:k
ll<
1.- •:;,
cu.
,-t
.,
CV r "'1!ch
tt
C!Lr
~
n
to
ff
1,,
ru
~,,,,thG,.
t
o" rao· t
,>r
"'lJi,..
1bora,
:ur:
t r~
oTer or
·~nt
Clll'
l de
raleed
urde .. the
a.• w .....'
11
,ow.
~
s1>ut ant
(.i
•
to
ie t?::1t 1'e11ce t:. at's
j1.
All~
p:U' t 0
:::ad
a
l,-
~
llltah11
ll'US ·•a st
.ni
l)n
Q
bonra
ul
.,, pbo
o l't.l'h
• ..,cc
00 •
B
0
~
uvo be.on
•r
t'
O\"
1t.
does
v•
l.?'089
ont,
~oea
1t ·
t
A
'2
1 '1 l . 1:
0
l
f~ll t
'lou -!lid
4
y
~Ott
~,~tr!l.t 11~
+
C
llO. lt doem.
~
luoo:i he,..•
;/OU bOTO
• e t:Illir ill
1
,
":la1Lnvc., that
a 11ttl"
JUr,~
,rid
~- 1':t'ler
a.
w~ un."o ~o lot:.s:
\r.
J>Oi>lt is ourr11d rl ~t
thn'
left
1• ee
the
ow.
..
Al'.-~ • he road at
.i.
h~· ld
l9B
t t
~- ~r9,
'h•
.rlde;e
! bolJ~ .. ~/i'
as
cc
tllnr<> all!IOst atro:i&'it.
Oll
f)";.
to-
r
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
•
'
19
don't
t
• o
ri4
•• at be:fo •
•·
.•
~-....ar
,1d
r.
••
t"Vt.:1
1~'
•
1·
tb,
rbn
ta·,
••
ar. ie
~
• ~ust
to tb
or
:m-y "l.e•....,,,.:-
C."'.t.. 'V'fJ ~~ra
rcnioh • a ;rid
ona quo0t ion,
the
car
t
h
'?ls}::o
o:tt ti.!o
"-"lt rro
to do•
hnt
thors
ttcws •1
ia, ...
r,.l oe on the br14~e-:
•
ll
-,. :
•P'
u• en•
a
c.:x,..-
T
1 •e
i:''.ot.,
D
e'
:hat dt- 10•1
•c+ure
'!"bJ.'
loaa•.
roa ! 1
�•
•
•
•
•
•
�'
"
t
.
'
20
• -.0"'1e-b11.c; , - belle
not1.
-t·
of
• " ba
1
1. •
•l-1;t
10:I
C-11' -
!i
o,... ortnn 11u1 "• 1t\10r u.
hal:!'
nd •· _
:-1Ter scr
/Oll
odor
~'bo,~t +-:t:.ere'i
1
ft. Ve
t
Eir •
1:.er,3 Ners t-h& 'l:!rot•e
~lo oa of" -1.r.:3 •
n 1" th-"' o~r an1 on ...1:e b~
a
,.,.e i • rol ~..oa dam
a l'ur•her
tate,
be.l.!l; first
,,.arc.
• o""
J.i:t
"--1-
not.
..• n.no tl:.P.r w1 -;no
iu.1,.- sworn.
ed o.
tro::1
,ox,c 1ned by
r.
al
• tr.
V
or·
• '"'ir.
yon to
Di
"II°~
•
t,._i.!: c~
Yc:r. e.:.e 'nll:i. ....... b~.,.
_8
o'".• ·t
river
..
.l.r.
-vea. uir.
UQ.
iB
•on t
...ho hank.
t'. i.a ll.'"Jlo:arot saith
. FI -
. J.
,
r~
y ~~au! the ~l.tlea.
.J
ovor
qu• ot
tho
blfCl•"
ca .....
11
•
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
J
�..
locx.
10.
• ... "'1.
J
•
y
. ,.
T
•
~1
0
v~
'
•
ez
I
•
•
"t.
!
9
_r
e
•
l
•
•'
1,r
ar,
-
r.,-
.. oert
1
ar,:-
l
•
"'e
i~
r~
11
t
'
u
1
do
1·
t~
" 1
•o
Ii
it
1
•
-
'. -o
l'.
•
1•
•
ro~
t
l
-
1
.,
ac•
d
•
l'.
a•
'
ll4 tu
t
ed
d
!"
•
4
V8 lU'
0
tr
l.tt 1
cat•
c"
UJ)
t
r"
• r.
o,
•
doe
..
Ir UB
Loo.
=
1t
-
Q
• o".. tt
t
t);
i'.o
•
ro
tra
+
re
•ra
a.
I
.ua
•
•
11do
Hid
1
snd
Bl'&
a•
Ol:'Ar
•
4
VO •
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�..'
•
t,._e t-::-o
Q
Yo • air.
!
~-::•
'
t'J,~
aar
"
.1
'
: i~ci
"
~
~
..
.:r.
c.f liquor
llB
".
:i.
retuence
w1 t},
11,r,er:
bee
In 1t.
a'
i
,l
t
r
pteca
lase,
t..,_Ol":fl 1r
., m,:-e
•be
r~a
A
'.It
left
b•re
i·.
l? t
..,
. O'I
-"r
fo.r
-+-
Ii
t"e
A
~
-
wl: r
~-
1· s
-~,,.....ll!'.
o.
..'
ot
i.•ecc
04.?'1.,
l .
1 •.
-
jcr
l. -
Q
oe-
...!u
DCU"• v..,.
T
.-
('
-.
e.
t
.-,,,4
':%''19
of t?ie
--. =
tc
l~r
.....•
•t
{1lJ'"t0
~
'OC
i:t~
88
rid
i•
\',,0,!t
T
13
I
"c
,lust
lJ,
C:\..l"'.•
.,
tm
cl.
p•._.i'
1 ,:1 '"U1-
lrl. r
\-t
~0 r
~
~
' "
!A
-
.,~¼!1\
'
·>-e res.~
&
a
"
• I .,.I
..
~
••
•
t·1 \
J
Q
.~
" ..rti-, ••
'
t•'ll
.. ..
Y.
aJ +
G
,._
...o,
0
0'"" :.:irre:1
l.r.
411 tb••
l
,,.!)
'•
re
'-(IIP
•
,
•
•r
.1:,.
'
J.l
~1
tl7
ri,c
t'l
t6VO.
no1•
•
o.,.t
C
·~·
n•
to i:r.ui?:•
:i:ill
an:;or. or t~t.
o.·--rri
i.
ll
II!:.
-.
t
t "'"3 etc...t ...
• ...... tr:" 1r to
. et'lar
ll7
..
0
v-, l
!.,l.
I
ti.Tn
ne
ther
l:a.• e soe-
r
a,:
e
au""._
"'
"
..
I Jc n' \.
ii
ro.~ f "'-01o• e rer,.
i.
.
• e • Lr • ri ~t '.?:1.r~
l G pOtJ1 .,ou he.ye C on t.ar..., ·or,J :at- taa
., il L-ar
A .,e!•
t ff"";
~
•• •~ t u
a 11 •
0 o.
t11e roe..?.
Ye
'r I Ii.
-1
,.3~
"".A_.e lad
0
~1
•
a"a.,
"'
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�••
•
•
... •
r
ea i
a•
r
er, l'ord ear
l.
•
l
r
CCJ'
.
~~,,,(
•
• 1
r,r
d
11•.
1
<i:) t~at.
ir;
•
or
A.
...
r
er
•
a s
,
t
CB
r
o<
al
•
i
•
•o
-'
1
t
d
A
1
,..
lo
r
oa
or
•
il
tr
~
•
l
w
tr.
..
full
ot
olea,
-
Br •
•
1
i
e
t
Al
'
,t
roe~
• out.
1
t or •oo
ir.
•
• t
ord'
1
8
V
111 r6ai'l
~
ar
•
1:
,u
l ro -1
r
.. I
e
0
..
• ...'
1r.
_,c,
.ou
~
1-ar+
hi>
•
'
1
•
r
tl
0
•
1
0
,.
1.
1~
• •
'
0
tr'! la
at
r
!.
• t 1t?
_..,
~
1
•
•
�•
•
•
•
,,
•
•
•
I
0
_J
�•
A vof!,
sir.
You eeo thll l!Unl'4 ,•&il in t 1
nt U1er• for son:e llUle
at
eJ.on
om l:e b'::!.dre.
abut-
tbat
'G11t :llt
•~er•
c,-z· w1mt owr?
t.:io t~
ti:~
~
distruu,o
pho•o;ra1'~
A !To, tr.nt wao
ut up las•
.,.All.
or olon
1, tte
wmtor.
·1:ct l tety.
"
"C."•
il
tho. t ~s
f'.:-on
of..n,• on,r
J'lJ.t up">
• 'li::.;;.J.:-IDOi''°'.,.:s..,B.A.c;:....?...
another
'
•
r.o; thor~ waa .Jo::e~'"'
inf' oi:. the othe1· s11e • owo.:r.3oru:·iaon-
A
i..et.s.lf.
••f All,
to
tl:91"9
t>o1r•.. firat-
dnly cworn,
You live
Q
.exniJi:1.e:l
\11tneas
l>J r.
intr0~"tned
•.:.o
..,r
l.
111 t:i:.•lCD.t!0
d(l 08 :~ aa ~ol.loYN,:
,llclon~
11t
Yea.
i
\boe+ 30
yenr ■ .
or
1 vo,1 nre a "nth~r-1D-law
J1r:i .r,oer.t~c.t·.
"'ea. cir.
A
"" ron.
~
t._,~
:res, sir.
A
'Tcm l!>n• h
VO JOU
lC1o"21 hi
•
like
st L.
:r.
s orti,
WC'l&i
...ea; seve!'
aatnoJ,l
11'. there
ta.l.:1n.r
a ,at:t ltquor.
l o
~be t8lmo:ry
··,,,ence or llqm-r
in•
th9 oar ran ott the o. ~;
i~
t and u:Ji:rc4
''
A
! live
b<l!o•e lbe
th
OSZ.Ollt
-·
us 1',ere 'tal,:.iru
the ·a bSJi: Of iv place
nd the rollrna:.1 -- uovera.1 of ua nte.ni-
1111 o:- £.'14 I tl: u ~~ l:e "'"'
I Oo no•
,.,,a ~-•
--
.t.I!O"I'
ror certain
1d. "Wall,
.•~dn:r tt.e
a.:d
n
!P.-
ot to t '4.-
butor-, I weuld bu tn on
I•
�I
•
1
•
.
'
•
•
.-
•
'.
'
n
. ..
'
'
•
''
•
"
.,
Ti'
•
'.
l
•
-
"f
'
�'
••
I ,ro l
l:r.
_¢
r.
!. t •
T
r+
11
I'
r
V
A
y
1r.
•
F lio
0
..
d~
·c
.
;,, 1&1d 'l
it.
r
\ne•
"'l':
11
~
'
t:, in
a
do l
U l
aid
'
0
0
•
u
.i.r
'
0
1n
•• 11,)
01
e u,;
uf!
ut·
r
l
• L
0
368~
no.
e1ni,
1"1 •o
relat
~,hi.,. 1 1<
1T.
•
111- ~~-1n
o.
1r.
Al'l,1 1 ."'ere
'?
'
'1
0
,.
o.
t 1n
l 1
&S&
t
IW.
a
.
elstio
•
'
~
'llul
r
...
0~
•
r d .. t·
Ur
•
~- l
r
•1
r
a
=
"'ed.
l
6
or:
diao
-
t~l
..,,
• i
cu
e ie-3. ..
l
~-~
t
Y~u.
r.
.,
o•
•
e"o c'
-
a:r
.
is
i'
•1
~
..ou•
"
11•
"
1
+
1 do '
1
••
Jul
·o
ov
I
"' :':<ll' •
r
1r.
,2.,
Ill
~y?
,
.....
r
�•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
" ..
.
~
ti~-i
took pl.:l
'
.,
'
r
~
-9
I
oil
"
l"
, 'lr
!au'
,.
~o.
•
•
r.
t.nr-w
fJJ
0 /
."' 1
I
c. •
"
~
•be--.,
J•
n
JOT.
lh
,i'OU
·t• •
a-
4
~
..
4<-
r.:ia •
le
dr!ru:1n?'
(ii.
Ill "I to
i:::..11 at
S1rf
~o .
•
~ll'i
11. in
"1;,"
1r.
l
II
~
11
l•
·- • ...,
•
•
~
nl
drinl.
••
,JO,
J.
41',ou..,~.
a-
~
Yo 1 den'•
-::-1:i:.~- - 1•
r
V
1T•
•
'lo
A
•
,_.
,
r• ee.-eral •
Tt re-
11
.,, tl-at
t
Don't cow or;,
•
A
r.a +l-a. t t;ore l'l"•
£1
T
~o•
~
-~.
1,.
t
.uac: OU
A
'
ar:
a
D..11 l'r .
"116"
i11• in
,•.at o.
ri-4
.,,,._,?
....."
.Ai
Is
11
1•
t'"=-
er
to roi.7
I e• F~d
lll'
to "he · 01"1 I h~ar~ n°
••·
-'~• , tio :,-,11~1 tow t:ho the ..Jrc.,.-•was";'
4
!JO, sh· .
.....
p1.lloe Wit~
,\
,.,
•
• :11
I
:,..othar,pe
,ed to bo i1 tie bar1>arar.oi: ral.:u.s
aboct
•
�.
f
'
•
•
'
'
•J
-' ,
!..I.;,
0
r
'I
•
•
•
•
1
''
•
•
..
(
"
•
1
...
,.,
'
..·•
•
""
•
••
'
,·
u"
•
'i"
.,,..
•
,,1·1 ..
' '"
I
C
..
'
" -'.. ,.. '·
; ,-c
,__
~
-- .
·• r- I
7
.,
.
•
V
<I
"
.. tt'i
0 j
...
~
o~
•
_,
~
'I
•
•• •
""
.
'
•
•u
-6L
-'
"'
�27
•
~he one batore.
ieh ~no o--r tl:$
'
Tho lD.Bt
1'/ho
-.
• ?
were
I
yo11 bl,,,thnt
·r, .
~
to-:
L:tn
;10 ll
it woe a hunr
Lll.::llS •
•
l'1·o als
'
O"'l~
•r1 la~
0 t'IC
t
=•·
SeYeral
in tl;o~e.
- l''""
•
0.
I do ~ct kno~ 111,otoc:Jirre~ ot
that
ff>- t did you tall:
o ...
I
ilh t 41d
es •
Y•a. tb n is
!13 BB 1J 11 tms a h
coo•
•i,,e.
het we aa tl1ll:1np
ju:.·y.
1
bnr.t
h .. is tho , n::; the
~ "ht•
lei
c ~e.
ro.,. -to +aU.l••
it.
~
l''!". C1'f'enba~J:er.
).ow did you 'lap1)6n to ho&r tbia
tion ot Dennis .h1fflet•s~
I
!un~ h
&n~~ ~s I on::~ ~lo
m,,.t t;aS D<>1
nis
t.
Jt
nd
dotn11~
.:.:nuv~rs .-
�•
•
•
�•
•
•
'
•
'
ata•occ nt o! ;-o re a -ut
•· li!'lot
did t •
t
O
t
y
~rvin
I
"
un
deposed
a
' 1101111:
12 ou
.ire
uoaaT
Jr . ...
. tucan·
1--
t'
r
&9
~
t
A Ye •
•b
A
rt
r
ClU'
1
t
1r .
~,.t ~1 ,, of da,; 114 yo:, g,,t ~l:erot
wa · bPfo!"e ~a; .
.!ho id 10:i find
I ro"IU>l 'r.
LUQ811
t~
It t.,mat n b ;i,en nrcnmt.l f'our or f! vn •
ro?
ni
th ..
..'.Ill
t~'.lt n,•
there.
Oftr' •>-e :.b10.-
t,
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
-'
�•
A
i1a,. of a i;ate
1,oat.
Pow mnch'='
lf' f"11c;
A
./. l..1d r,1
see m 4 bro 01 .-•
•
!!,at oao~.
i en I
L.
~
.s
~
'he
'1""
1 • aey,
p·t•UI!d..
~
• not·
odor
e
al:out
r,la
ti;
·~~
aJ·..,,a Oev,r., on
is o 011::ler.
""h.itnot."
11 kl dn o!
~
or -- on
•
'ee, sir.
Y
I
~
1 ,vc.U•d 11 t> r.nt , ti:! r~ ,.,.,.a :,.
ci,-a I 1-u1· ta•J ti-
'"'
A
ou dote
414
uot ~o..,,•hort
"~o.._.ia ·.:r.
«- 11.. ,
Ji
n::ils•
dn"7"
•
ni.au stoopel
jo.r •
C r
la
.114
., Oi.!
·,r 1 n.,t
en=~ fro
~J _....
wl &'ti.
8.
.:t~ae•v--e
.,..,
.., .
• ..,_roo
rlvorr
.,
'loo .
t
f'
t oa:o trao·
•
l"O
d --
t-
�•
•
•
•
r
'
�..•
,
30
,..,.
ti
G
,.
·•r •
•'
.J•
♦
•
"
..
I
n
.."'
•
lf,
1
;
•1:
l
"
•
.,
• .a
th.l
~fr\
!• r&:'
.•
-I
l,il
'.1'1'!"8..
•
t" C'
'.'!'
,,
• rcc
oi ......
1,-...t
I!
:n .
.,
•t
tri.• b• 11
•
a"tt.
-
ia· o.1
,8
• t'
-•
•
l
11
•
•
r
•
t
·~,
•
• r
+·
j
• B
~
-~
o<'
1 ,,_.y.
L<:1
ff
l
t-,-a
t
•
h
I
.,,.~1
ll
.. -·
... '""
.,_,..
••
•c
,.
..,
1. t
1n
0
io tr
o-. r
.l •
~CO ... l!!ld
~
~
Ii: •
•
-'
•~o
'
I }"
I
.1 l •
ide •
~
1
~
'l
C
.
'"'f!,4'+,..
8110
1
r
•
' t.
<t 1
r,
l
1n,1.d ·? • :r.
u
•
•
th
. :ra~. lo
I
..
• 110
.
o·• are
A
,
.
•
c-r • to
yo.rr l: 'n ,.•
;
,, th•:re ..
"le. l~.., a a•
•
r'l:
4
atol.
..
rl
,
r•
t
ll
.
"
...... 1•
♦
•
•!
~
"
1a· 1
....-'
r.. ,1
•r .
•
I" i.;,ed
,
••
1l
r. 1'1
.r
~
Ir,
, t
t~
'"i
•
1
Ir •
•
•
u
+
~
~I!T
,.,
~
r.!.da
...
•
'71 r,_ ~e.
_, v
!l t
I' 1
C•
l ...nFl • <
"'ll:.
u('".eJ
)1~
·o
••
111
""•
!t
St!t:!L
•
1
0
t 'l
.ll:.
1•
•
�•
•
•
�...
.
,
1
.31
•
p llod
i • out,
"
blt
o,
A
1r t·
••l d •
••
•
e~.
~
b-o .en
"~
~/'-0
•
rn
'
rJc,tieu
14
'•
!I
..u
ir.
J;ar
•
,.
he
l
£un. I
+.""
=
•••
.. t 4 C1'
l,1 ......in
n1d
DP
1
onr
.. ia
be
ic.
I
.1
C
tep
to
.,, 11
0
,,,Dero .:'Vt'" n.re,_"
"" !
,,,-ou b:.o
l at
b
11.. •
ell-~
>o
"n
•
~o
a~
.._-, ....eitc ~ rei.
o4 t•
L'l •lJe
OT.Yt-r
Ir
.
.
... t ,, :,on"
0~ t"Q britl
~
.:.,._~
1 U"--9'd
•
r'Vt!"'"'"
i?'"•
•
•
•• l
an
•
0
,L
t
•
·•.:.,
to,ue
• 1.rn
•
'
l
c' t
l.nat.
3orvo th
o,
....
,.
.,
•o
J
I
.'ar
r
"
• " -~ • '
uo..
)#1 ..,
•
1.auo~
rl;;.e ·
O•
1d
CL ri
::-o
ir.
~
1•
le
..
.. '
.,.,ta
.....
t!t:n
e; •
l-1
•
J
....'1'•
0 ....
O:L?'
"
bo
e
1 •a'?
-id,
o,
'.
�'
•
•
•
•
•
•
�I
•
.. ,.
r.
··~
;
t t' •
i. ..n'!!
u
,,
tr•
'
.,...,a.etr .
t.>·
".
"
'
didr
0
~
,
~
'W
• t'"~
~
a
1
'
'-I
!o
J'
o•
,,
~
•
0
:~
-.
lfOt,.
O\\l
.l~u
:1:""
te
..
C •
t
1
t
'1'4 yo
~'II
~
Q
~l.tt1
c,
•
~
..
A
a
d
&C
'JO
r
++ l
l
<'r
•
'I.
9
ocpl •a.1.,.
.,
ln
-
l
..,,
•
•
""6.114
V
?
e:- ' •
0
, lo
...
>-o I 1'•
~
<.id
C
••
'
e.eo t.
r 4
old In
•
m1-t1
1m•
•
••
.1
....
C
!::.
~l
II "'
i
~
0
•
l.
0
,,_
1
!
0
•
ho+,
•
l
.
,,..
:L
~
1
..o-:a.
~ '
'1
,at •
I~
• ord. ••
'•
"
r
0
~
J
r-
~·t
•
F"
~1 ..
.•a... •
a
il
teJ,
poaaum.
~-aer
"8
•
.. ••ny:..ayw
l ht
\l:.a'
0
4
l:
'
fdea
1 OD4
•
•
'•"l.
e
ro
•
0
A
!le
I
th1L-'-
14
...
"
•
.. ••
'
nbcut hi.JU~
lll,thlc
ld •+
1
~
I!,, I •
0",.
ot th I
I .1'
'
-
+•.;
f I •&1?
4
•
•
a t.e-
!i
•! ~
r u
1rn
t
ir.
1'
;.
1
..
d14i 't
0\
• ..r I.a" -
ll
hL~ ...
,1
J-:o
• I wn~ l' t
A
t
.:; ~r. '
• ft l'
V
r.
J .,_
..
..,
'l:A
"1" •
•1,
•
1•11
..
·,,.
at
'
�•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
lil5
11.. , •
Q !>n:.r.,l ...1. D
• I "t.
J11rt ab u• d~,
A
In t· .. ni(l:t?
A
In •1-,.a 1r·.t
•
....u ,-
.-. •'
--,,
'1
! 4 ~
,t
ha.-.o
a::,Y
!:1d .}'OU t~e• ,fy
,:.!
4)4
~.•
..
••
•
..
!lit
•
~
~.
.
I,
...
--- n-,o.r
'
.J,.a
t •
I ♦
11q ~T
c.~
O'"l'I
tn:l-U}'.
rc:re·
0
~r
n•
•l
i.11.
4-
"T1
""
Ola
•
"
'
-
,r a
1
• '~
Ut&"
'Gr
'•
•
,,,.-1
•
'14
t
A
l
-I "'t"=
ol
\·,u.tci
....
r!.
0
••
l
y
•o·
he:
to •~a
•'1
..,r•.
.,,l •
a• • 1
•I
r.:a:. not 0
.,
~
rl
1..
-
U'
+
""'
I l
1
,,
Jar.
•• •
...
1
•
••
•
do,i"':>
•
't
•
••.nc:...
at
1"
.,.'-(I
11 .. r
l
~
-.,.
'.
•c •
•
~. ;; "l
,_
~1a
t' Ii.
it
'10
, '
..bl•i"••'i'
A
'toe,
a:
_,,uB
•••
Dill
• -:I...1
ir .
w.~n Nl
'
to~
~
l•t•:ua
~
;or
·u
.
Jc
A
111fCC
olr.
~-
•
"'"
'r
Q.
I
:l
-·
G!lj'
1 aed
l
' -./ .....• 1 ,.ra1 , e_
+rn,
I. I
l
0
,
,you cl
1 Qj.1
l
.,
~
•o
OL · s
,c.
•'a
h 1rl •·
>11Jr<' tl.111\
4.,.,, 1
~"
in ..,.
u~l.,
:· l.U I
Ii-
c•r•
-
• !en. It,
t •
• r.
\, er
�1
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�(
.,
•
.
'
~, ....!
A
w
.,,.
••
l " ~t
0
•
•
:s
w l tl: is
i:
'1't,;.
t~.
..
r
""'"
..r"'
',a
),
• "'o-: I
•
•
Q
,e
a•
a
::>0011
T
.ce,-, i•
••
a
A,
r
f
£.?..l
~
.. t
• ~·
ed
0
I
t•a
0
1 I •ti .
•
~6
tJ..,t
•
uS
c;:..
'i
li1'
r
roe
rid
10• t.
•
I •
tc,
• 0'
r
-
ib!t
~r
]~•
ll
,.,
"
1.1.ltlt
'"
're,_,ro
.ut .r 1
•
t •
•1 tl:
\
l
r
r
"'
b tn&
y "·
.I
tot ILU
A
WO t
"'re,
Q
+"-ot
T'
"'~Ou:'"'
ro
,•O
e~~
I
+· ~ r
t her,..~
T'
VAry.
i
ll
6
J'OU
~0.1"/
little
1.to.
""l-@'l
1
li._
l"Of; ,_ •
c.urv • il'
•
<>f
t ll
•
•
ll'1 '·
!t
, , '
...,+o '"w
-'C
I•
•
••
tr,
1r.
b
~
u
de:
le~
...05~
ol •
h"
"
I •
1r.u.t !:.._o•o rbp
'
-!lr-.(...,
• or
&t
.,10
e•
le.
••
~
t.~,1
•
"" r. !.
fll)\lt
""''°rJ t 1'
w
llav
•
' /)
a-r
...
•
,,+ ,ll
Ii
'
•
.. !
--
'
•
J u.:t"t
ri: I
tie
, t.
••u,t
0
•~ord c~
~
:o or
e
l
~
',
-...,.
'
_-.,,-f
•
~c
·,
•ha • tu"; •
'l'!,,
n• r·
" t'
1 ok..a 11
I
r• ht c.rc•111/\e
1J.j .. ' .. ea'
h
.,
l.
~1
C
•
e b.~l~
l
0
'i,
e•
••
1ut,r.
•o t"c
)
a d t'o
..)01-t.
_., ti
J' ,.,
• to •
-iudi l
er 3} deST·
..
..
~
abc1J't ..
r l.
I
.. ..-
!,a
r
"
to
<
no::.·.loo lnr
�•
'
I
•
�"
'
•
.,,.
• 11 .·tn1
~~
.... T~
Q Ar
• ·1ri
,t
.ro!J"r'
".ltl.f
. 8 i.!.-:
I .'llt:..:
1· dOtl •
•
,o-i ""~11 toil. ,:-1•
er
a:.:.•!T3ber,or rl11,Je.
'!lorJ
~t
r
..
~
tb~t
·~t~J 1<>l:l llV€'l!.
A Yo • e:ir.
It 1 r. t -. laid
!l..z i.1
h1at
iom·:h bu
""M"
t l'rn JOOm ln.. d.
T+ u,, :tt
t•'IJ~
,. ju.u
...
•
l
..i'"
tr •
n
or
tr
1
Jt..)ae
l.at
jarft
oo e
ena.on ot
.~
~...,.,ro.
'
••a~ l
•
Yet.
C I 1' •
JoJ'..,
.. Yee,
n i•
V:ia.l
ot' ...r
t
r."""l~d
r, ,.en
li.fl,i
e
er:
Lr
,•
,.
odor
t
:"'
',
0?'
llt
of r~np.
." rrvrr.
9$;'
•
r ..r
,:.
l
'h•
aud
= _rs•:r,. "'~,t.,
.....!n,
I!
hQ..i..
~)
.3'·•.
<
�f
..
•
.-
�•
•••
•
'
Zu
-- .•
•
•
Cl
,
,
A
- -·
•
~-
..
,~
,r
'
.LC. •
~
lr
rr.
Ycu are
.., 'tr
'>t
9 •
,.
.....ir.
.
•
A
Yea, •ir.
A
Ye
JI
I
-
""
•
•
-~
I
y
r . .ar
u: •
0
1
ivtt n~IU' ::lctc1.";
•
war ab
.:'11et
he, .U1do6h br ldte
r I vcr?
to
l•e ;TJ:y 'he nature
looate
the trs•
• eonl
flll~w
ii
1• na
--
a Jrt,u ""1:'d bo 4r·v•r
!.o'lu""
of tr.one traoka .
H,
or follow
b, 1c poab1bl,
:ant a n4tllr.o.l ~rac.... j 1mt 11 "' a
o r~Li 1n•o ,., tl er ~r•ol<.
~
on I he llool<l•1&'i&.111
I thillk.
oro l,oo-:il
·ont over
o.t:-1f '4'eet --
t):a
t!euoribe
•
,are it
he
,;t
t 8 o'oloo
ror..J 401111 ln•
ft
•
Lon
Yea.
A It
l!
~.,. I
r
V
I p
" ..d
r,.
1:.a•v111
lier• yoo over
·uat
..
l'
•
Q
A
o"f
r
'
D
Yn
<ff tte
n ll
h
.. a.II ,.
~ur+
"
r ,
,Oil
0
•1
~d
,
•
1rreg,:lar
I sir., nottit
into
r •bbly
a o~hor road.
ab n• it'
pocular
i•
baok
II ilst.-rioe
£UiJ"' 4r'v1
ab 11~ H.
�I
..
•
•
•
•
•
�..•
•
•
'
'•
37
11atural
hU'n.
~
,1a you noo ""l liquor?
A
T
dld nc~ eee Any.
I am~lt
IOI!l.B.
Ti ~t •v ~e:18"~s 7,-a: •a..~ce cf 5::.oi1 a
Q
ana lr.'1'1• it
up a jw,
a11d taken
.it
w!-.nt he 1:ed 1 W-:':lld !mT&
?'
ur nose o:.- a• ell
~
•el~ as ycur alght and taste.
.:JU :you ee~ uny'
.~ l piok•d
b•
l rec.or. you ~~va a
You raid
ho.,,e,
"ocul
110•
- Junt ., ju;.,
1• ao 11' 'll170no 11s>:1dme
ee:-:,ethlne t~ •l:ow •~om.
a. tl:1"
~·,n, :iJaYo ;o
r.o
•
tno +raal: bnolc "bou• l5 !oet•
;-011 fel1o~ni
~
oob a•opper,
I takon
l:en you cnn't
A '.!es, ttir;
It •an
" oorn
w!tl:
15 f•e•.
en ~ru-n1?1Eat a~
= le
of =.b"'" ~-. dec:rees·
A Yea, elr •
•
1
est1fied
L1l.tii9r
'3.8
"'o1l.QY.a:
Q
!lil ;<<>11..,., ,eorre
.I.
~
Q
nr.
A
Ko. air.
w
"errltlf
a11cl lu
o?
'l.i.o,
Ceor~e
"~rrlng
•r.d ""'11thor Jhif'flet<
1 do no1 kno" wl'letber il
I oqw ..1h1f1"let.
7io:.-e ,u,a tao poopl~ 11n,oarocl at m;y doc:c.
A rro, nir,
tf
l heel ht1d lt
11 n~ver
....n44"u-nor -:·1.1 ~(lpo:-.ont saith
11
•
J::.er 111,iJ•Jetr
ot.
\l.it'ls
he;
wonJ.~ <. wont over •
�,•.
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
'
�'
"
•
\
.• '
ITTIGTI":.anctJ!~r
DR- J. 1.
behalf,
be.inf;' r lra t 4nly
u·
wit,. ee
S'fttll'n. e•G.ined
r.
.;7
Q
~ow l
A
S 11,JO 1914.
Q
I bel •ftTD :;cu nre " =;;ucn.
?ttlV6
1.n•roa1~ced in 1Le !:Wllti
.;-0!1:-&ii.
depose.fl &u
a your rrofesaior ,
you been p·&ct 1a ti
Dootor"'i
l'rnctic~
in ·'1-.a .o~1r.£)l~~
Yea.
n
:.
··amcrl.lll
and 01,erata here
and
E~ep1tt.l:
•1r.
nt tho U::ivera~t,
;otort1 oom1n~ here you wer
Eosi:llal
et '1,&rlo• tesvi11 o .
.A Abou., eix ye.a.rs.
i1e we
br,,ngll'
\~ th• >on1 t&l o~ 'J-,, nitht
ll
Yea.
A
"'1-o Univere.it!
Id.id.
too
C0ar1t~1,v,
!l • ook!nc'n11m 'nc,or h,l
air,
the. car t1ent over
not
1Tos1,i1al.
A
llo,
1::it.1-a;1-,im.
<:
I tt,aucJ t ~>ou "ere :here
t1hen l·
Wh3
brou(lht
to the
._ iro.
Q
~- o,: Shl.!!let
I ...
wider •be 1cpreas!c:,
rea~beli
~., 1:J • !ul"
Q
,
Y·t. t lil
tl e hoapi~i,1.
·•:
f--rea4-
l.
J.
Lu.ca(-(:
t~.al • r.
1orig':.t
°Q<l
·•ue
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,
�"
•
39
r:;, 't~e r.atuxo
•
. Luce,a I in-
ct
j-::tiOB,
I aaw tr.
"'.,uoas aonotim.,
l::.ad ba,n
hor:,.,. end a!l.r.:.fl1n to se
.Pra~tu:-ai
41
Q"
~~e
lo"t:or '!.er,.
t~• sl:1n rro::i nioh
oa"lled
1,, bad
1
o.
ro
e
T
~e.:Jt o1 bo!!e ),
~ t~
ni:..oltn-r9'd
one .C-iob 1a
or 1,,ose bone ha~ to •• rd: end.
exo.mined him le••~,
lli& 1r0u.~d h•e
'1a uo,,m•
as not h;,alc4 \
it
b
11ct•ei; ou: in!eo-tc:
Lao~ b1ok.
no.
oee,, 1n;u.rod.
l-fj
":n t.ad a ClOa:po·uHlco:r.'11.Imtod
4 ')Vi4e1
"we r,tocog
oo·ooir.,v911tlo.
"ave. ;·o
ti
ar~or ~e
baelel
baan'+
other
o· c~mr>~~• 11 ~e3lei.
1et •
.,
!le rec-,lve~
l.1l.1urlea too,
4
I d11 r..o• ec ~~ose.
be7
d111n'
a ~irst
.l. seal?> <1onnd"
recet.~d
1nw tta
~oc J.tal"
etr.
·ts,
_ i ~nr' 'le
1th not.
t 1· dei:or.e t
A.5 t.~ ill boin
&1.1.
•hn "o•...,_om·aalt..11.
in ohiof.
o:
evldenoe
tl,~
th
1nt:co4uoeci en ·,o'h:ll:t of
deff,1:d•m1- to ma.1 'oin
tho i
tut
011 ':ita
e· elt' 1T1t?"ochHH_,i1
. r.
··o:
er.
1'110. 'bat
dohoses aa .,.ollon:
f)
aHn" if'f
'iPLl!l!P.
lli·.
!ii 1 lord . e.t t:?::ut l e l'.r. Luca
w.a.o ln 'ured.
i'OU !Bra
o-r .oi:,.....L'l }I
.1.
"es .. str.
"
A.."1P
A
Yes,
~
bS
,s 10ur d.e
!U t
1"'
ail'.
/b.r.t t1
d 1, ::-os, hear
:A I ·12:-po_. i • wsa a a-t
.If
o:!' the
inj
r:, •
& o • cloc'.l: in
.r. Luons?
h• ,:,en:!
�•
,.
•
•
�..'
40
iho brol. ht h!.ui'
Q
A
•
•
•
flO'li.,
re nll !~
.o•
11?!0brou.e_t
hiJ:I.
-:-hree
~1:.1. .
ns:u.t fille
Q
I
•~r.I 4o
.!lo•
!lo 70 •
•
'
r.e mu,
I
l
• or t
"'I-ere.,
'
iv an u11coru:- t
oc 41 tlo,i •
"
! c.:allod
u•.
ftO
Q
c ...,11•tcn
l
Do
:;rou
011
he
011 I-n~
uno.
I/AG
Sci~•ID'j'
•
Yon, r; Ir;
4
• r,~nt
cl
e•t
11wn7.
I ee t tho
t <'er Dr. l! edle-r, 1
t
-
"A
Did ye,, br•a.:
(I
-:i.on 1'1'
... t ~Id you do:
A
~Of.
l:ere
r.
~
r
a,
&4
tl:~ OMl' out
1,0 a011bt l
I
I id.
r,.
""8
i,
r l 4 rt> , I
&.lld t~e,
rlvor
.., Di
7
•
a
A No, ~!l'.
-
il'.
(!!le
,.
I a1~ net.
iQ You d!.dn' + iut
·o.
110~6
to cc
r
anyono
414 not.
thero"
::u,
86
14 be
hoz::e anl 1,,.• .. fa
lt.rg "'1a ~oL r, £1gre
A
o:: ••
t~.s apood 11 it?
ot to !h~
_
ti
•t
dl .. tol;,
ttc
:lxtOL.
et
to ~r.rrlao
W.NJ. ... 0
,._,.tao
•
~u
w!ti, tio..
do n 11i.t
+-here- nn:1
k
4
►
Cu
•
on
leJ
l:d~
r.ie ac:~i.:lv.nco and
�••
,
•
,
•
•
•
•
,
•
•
,
�•
'
'
l
"
•••
l
il
'
•
.,e,ollow th9
toll
tra;l.(a
..l,e jury
-~ t'le
in your
·t•I
ve t. OTi'IJ"..he ew ""tlitr.ent•'
oi::n wn:; ab\'J'" ltO\?
>
,11•
I;:
cc
+no •ru."lts ,rn.re.
,!ur;, ho,r •1J111we-,-., " ii
~ r.i.p.
4
I~ I bll4
Q
You ,code.
A
Yoa.
Q
An4
If tJa.
~
t'•·
•ro
1
oe:ate4~
--
I loelievo,
'he lA>a• trial.
Lt
o. dr•wlne
roir -
eelt•
~
I uz.,r h&na. 'JfT\l
drawing
t'u:)
;-011
r.aa~ &t • r--, 1r: •an:o
111t"s:•1w., o-r ""1:.e Co:..t20"WClt,.,_ st
1-.. "":n:ao":.11aalth iu ..;.11sw~r to the
tio.o •
thaf
A. Yes, air.
llore •n the gi:te.
:i.
+-hJ &
..
."
Ht
'7111"
::ir.,...
or·
etarto~
l·ia
•ii•
+• • r1 ,,-1-1r11•.
1t,t
T},_.at
~
!}u,t'
11•
'r, ,•.h .. b~;roh<i t-h_i.t
brii!ge.
Ii .-,j
o4r, o" t'lo abut#lnt
CO""'
out fro:;;
rt1et
+'-i1tf d
Tint:, ..
• car
•,-,,ro 1'1..-=.
~er~
!nto
r..-o,:itlf'l'I incnth
r,.t•
1'-
here,
cf
at
rt
l•
..
' ::.d•>
tho tridee
•
the rivor.
,,
d1aeonc.l
t·
rftU
rra.o tlu, r.ortb. a1do tc
t:..
t
fo:l.!.rr l.r t'
in abol.t.t nix or li8}1t
sq_nt.l'1~1turn
•·1,>it
?Jo,' then,
tr.,
sauth
Anil tl:en to
...t1tt nortl:..
sn<I o'f"='
It b\ltiT&d b11,,Jcto the aoutL iJ:. t~ ls d il'aut1ot1 1111d'""do
1-tr;"1l
and
nnt
Tight
over.
'ha,-'a
tl:,:i
•,ro.:,: ctatea
1• 1,erore.
�[,I,
•
• llO
..
ti
l
't.all
•
'
u
'If
--..
...
....
•
t
0
..
•
••
1111
...
" .
..
•
•
•
•
'
•
0
..
,
fl
Id
t-i
I
1!
0
'
l
•
.......
,,.
~,
•
...
rt·
to
t cJ
• "l.OYO
I
;
' 1 bf(f'I
•
•
.......
a
,
a
"L
-
•
."
! J!T •
",ii
...,
..
-~
�•·
'
!Ira \o • ha ec.i;e 1rner~ "~
1Il
a:'d 'h~ • i" cc......~ !ro
t,
or beyc;•1d this
adgo.
ont-
t.o
her'
~&?:"!h.
t
and
e4.eu. a.. 3 tren
..na.wnt
11,('~
t=nea
0
•
i t
?0\'0l
Gpp:
t~
.Jent.er a!
i'
ur on
the
Tt
1+ pu11tHl b¥Ci: lr:t
t1
\·11•0 Ir.
ac
G.}'trOli
DI%,..,. eif'h'
wl:bin
!! .; -~le
curvv
A
,..,•
~
Tho f•O?:' t..t.r,.E
•
11
tc e,q,l~itl
A
yoo,
I did,
on the taco
or
'Ex!, 1b1l
'" 1e
ln•rcdoued
~
~tcfq...,nt.
~1~
are!,u.
~
fer a-,,:,bo a.;: to eeo.
pl'1il
ir.
You r;.ad
yo, r .dro.'I'•.'n
esw:J'lAt
J'li.1 11tr.. l
t:
1o .,~
&
eitua-
a 1r.
car
•l,,«J
di-1 nm
to
ll!'
of • ah?".
t.r~oi.: ran.
omes
You
Yon have
7 baQt 'here.
•3"
t<Q
at,1;:t-ar.t1 a 4 011I etr.u.l~ ·t
th('
t:p tho r.=>:'ld1 w1•1ch l.e iDJJOSfiibl-,, in the ver;
tl;,g
<112-
•h• rioutl>, a:,a.
'eet
accordir
opnrutiori:
vr.i
" T1Yer.
JI.Adot1 sharp
bJ t'-
br ldgo.
REd e ,<hero yo11 ap)'rOE.cl
nru.r the
ht,
t't;:e
nature
of 'tl'lir~gs in tt•O
tl:u.\: ls a .p:enerr.l ou t,1 lne o"'~ t!?'e vP11
1:,w,
""'1.7
1:~ak
tho ga••
ata.rts
•~e
r.er"
DJld
jOttr
abu'1wi::t
z:.eru- a •elepho_ni:. pole •
O"t.rT"!
..r tJ:e
e"oo-r1c
liobl
pole.
oppo«1te
1J,o II""", but a r,oin'
You start
;.:,u mel!J1 to st,.,. t at a point
J.
""
011 p.hotogrbph
opr,osite
I ..,.
your
OJ'JH>Bl
te I Le electr
\>; the
e::-e are two
role■
tl:o gnto,
l
1>>.illt
baok h~re
111..r the electriu
f07erll';~
"~".
~r~
to
~t
not a poirt
pole.
llrhl
io 11£h t pole
Lid
or tl,c
ap:prc,,:.ah of the 'bri•l'c.
on p1iot.ol'ra:ph
kn0'1 if
he wnnts
or back do,.n hel'o ut
C • 4'!111only ona polo
th1B llllll'
the aloe trio
to begln
11 ht pole.
�•
•
•
•
•
.
•
•
•
•
•
,
�..
\
43
"'t e i:nrt
A
goes be;;-ond •r..at ll" to.
'!'he~ tl-1•
Sturt
your
?.tarted
!l
l!no
reur
up there..
the eleotrio
e
tr.at brldgo.
iroca
tc, th" bridee.
"1th1fl
Th-'3-re is o lon£
r;•l;t
that
sneh
b"Ut tt11
rol~.
I ,1bo ,;overnod
111•1~cu...;'I--goini::- 11tt1
0~ the ar!)?"caol a3
It
cf ti,o a:ITronch,
ou• the tact
w1th your word des.•riplton.
appar11r t.lv riflJt
tl•At
tho
)'<>n
dra"'lDS Boes
II mliko~ " orarp
tcrt,.
he bo lrinlr.11!11
of +'be abr..tr."'nt I a alu.u"p t.tor-H nt
ut
ri r~ w:.;1eo &crc~r. th~ rout.
her9'B wl!er~ tha
fraL·1
to th•
foet
etx or o1ght
I 'Rull't to polr.t
,,ot oorr•~ron~
ooai:ne
drQw\n
l!..,."Jt. p.ole.
t,..e tileotria
l m•W'l tl:e oar •N•t
Q
ga:~.
Your 1 Jne ahou.l~ be
govorna<l1, Lhe telephor;o
Vias no;-
b~· th1:t approao'\
o:r
pole.
lieht
you hr.ve mnde.
dldn"t it?
pole,
A I
rl~~t
ttnt
You d~n' t o:oan to ""'Y by this
trs_:::};: n..e 1QU 8:.:t1 extended
ph 1
ln "~ !lrror
:!ra1'1n~
w~•ab a a.bl" could.n'
~..,. •·e-it dow.
1.xton to-mµ-d the
brtd
,J.
"h1.8 1.s 1:
an4 this
th•
ao.
:-iver
re~e•e tto
ttis 'L' :r-aad
rallllin~
eaoth.J
gat1:1 £3 yc,,1 t4P:,r,...n.,.•b
the bridpe.
A. '/el'I. str.
:row. ,,tat
A Tl:la
"'011s
thl•
did
line
the abut:: nt
menn?
.~ •..,., .pr'l"Oaeh goinf
into
tr.o
t"ract:s
of
lert:.
\.
}10.
Q. fllbllt
'fft.S not
J.
O.'I•
A
lio. air.
!r
a.'ld •~'A
to be n draw1n•
cf
the
111).
'"b.i1,1 repr-t:sentP
l:rl:i[o.
ten'!e
,h"' fB,te.
the a.but·-unt
and
ent'J'.-1.tl<,:i:t ;-,
"1'9r•.t'a ..ho <}enter o! ..ho tract:.
the
~at
�•
•
••
l
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
.-
�•
•
••
•
1
44
..
•
irnillf
t1,., .-,:.y yo>< t· OUfht
l.lld1,,ato,]
ca.r wn.s ovor here
A. ~1•
to
tho
trll11C >ioI'.t.
0
+1-;_
rlt-"-f.
1.0, !"1f:ht iv
J
0 8
,o~e wire 1'nn1!~.
~r e111l:t i"•a I o! •1ta en-?"ru ~e of th• brio
A i'ord
A
ll e •hnt.
ear
~~n
doearlbll1r
.
t
It .:ouldn'
on the .rl ht
Ml8
ix
o 8!14 :ade a • ,r;, l l. "
ao znc:nt any-th1n
Your <lr=.\1111 Jooe thnt.
ll!'ld .. ~,,~ti YC'IU a:'fl
1J e tJ\11t w1f'.h.in
"ha c!:.l' wont. rnt.: r-r.u.dually
lmv
!lee, &a ;ou
~s.!i:,.
hWJd
Yes 1 eh·.
center
r:f th
!"Pad .. .,d
no·tl: aide of •·oe
ur,
•
•~en it tot
t'ltere it: ou.tVed t '1~!1
1-,...e
al"' won• atr"I 'lt c.,.,r .
ff.t
•
c-n t1:
1:0. olr.
l did
'(..'hon yru
o
l.i••1e
A
?'l
'(f?e.
A
c.
O!"~
A
11":G01
41at»--"'
e.z:!
tlp~oc
r!. !r•· .c r:1 a14e
t
uo-
Sfle
trc
t•
th
•he
I tt~rt
1, •
6
e~:r •
-
m.~-ro mro
only
crwt
rr. ze thst
:.
:J.S
tbnn two
t:-e
1 autiOP
141Xti.-r.
t.rrld..,
lof~
~-,id
•
or ..hree
o~s"'
two or threl:'
_,-a tl)ltownf
,J1de
re were ecverLl
you r:::.rk' ,J
r
•1
~L': •
t1 ere.
.!leui11r 5C and
t:
-
ilur•1 tha':"& Cl!.eL 1 went in.
�•
•
•
•
'
•
�•
..
••
..
-rr~,u
r_r.
.s I ca.rJ br..c.. ur,
t.her
t:100.J"'
11
wert1 a. D"'11.J&r C' pG'OJ1le tr•:-
e _.,arc. i •t!J·PI ea i.:. or 1r, car •
c.. "
Qllr:
von'
-a '"'• nu·t
fro
l
runninp
ln.1.e.-..~.,,;1 fo:-tf
aoroe~
::~
tri
a
•I~
V•~. s:.r.
.,u:ror
P.
eee ~thin
I didn't
!: 1:)ody o~lod
o
lh1r~,
.t
n, t•.r.:~ tl3;·
~·--:- !l.tteMll"I!"
14l&d.
to ill
a1r.
:,o,n
I'd
A
it;
to~
11<1Dv1a1
~1d
1
• hn•:I.
Do. air.
voe.
0
trou~l•
ln c- "inf
lt
or in
1:.011Ji
r..ot!1 ~a.
le
'°'
•al_
to
,c:-...uit'
~1.r1·101- af'tor
w-d
Ii,
.,u ..
..
.,
ho I.lo-.•' •• ,
,. '
~en
,
•
•
�•
•
•
�•
•
•
_,,
·~
ov:d tlo
Q
J;
•
1·r 1
•
as 1
~
stu 1 e
•
L-
r_+
l
.r
l
n
Ill>
his
•t
•
1·
I
..
•
..'
r
,..io
.,,
-a
•
•
e,
..
""
.Jo
isfl
•
r
l
I
•
•
l
Q
C
'
Yo I
•
quo
Y.
+,
l
d
•
~
n,
•:iol
1,pJ,.•:l,;.
..,
,
..,
ts; d •
llt
•
•o
't
st11~1t'f
~
le
:u:::•
•
""
1
:1
10ml
8.
.. ,,8
".
I
•i~
,.
&!"
..
,
• +1
f't'J-tl.Ou on
t
A
l. •
u·
••
'
1
1
ot llq
I
:l. Yon a011l I
drlv'
Lo
•
8
I u?
al
0:c
Q
'l'l!
~· o+· ~• •
A
'
8,
11
'
~
Jud s:
,
1 0•
l 1111
'lDC
l!ll. •
"" c..r
•
\~
t
l n
•
11~
. .... 1
na' tlon
.i
I
cot
0
1: •
-8
"
•
Ill--. t
A
•
tt
"
,.
••
1rr1 t,
t ' ..
~...
fl
I,
l
"
Ju
,1
s
••
j
.o.J •
..
.ar a:. e
�•
•
•
•
•
�...•
••
\
The _on1l itilln
c~ •l-:~t
Yon r.:,u1-! e~a l•;t 1.:o,c.ila-:
4t
":l.1
u.n.
tho
I, o"" oo-.irn~, r!'id n..,,.. r.. ow. a.n,l t
C':our;1 t'o....
mt.l
r
-..11 ,,~..-;- •:nu.ch'.r.te.1,·o""sa.
to
:lld .:;in
•
ilh
~1•
:o
A Ko· T eot- ~.,. vlothoe
iill&!
:·1.U·tnar
th l
:I
d9f'Ollo,1
to ~ow.
t........
!lw ~-:.e~""-"'iloriousl.
~~~
•
i.,
:L
:ia
did nc; a~drean All¥~.
t 1.c;:
,I
You oni.,
8"
A
Jut
h.iJ:i
a
·no r:oop1ta:l.f
t.nt
t
'h.urt.
cit' a,a
u.1tt
.i.i.~~.
Jr,,roce-.1d..ed.
t'1 JJ
t
u.
�•
•
•
•
•
�I
..•
4 tl
l: ...l"o,.,
pol
.1 e_
t"ol 1.on:
Q
J..::-....... Utlet,
tc. ,..o"l llv,.,~
wbor
A.IUlu7'u-.f r
.,
Y• •
A
r
..
.:,rref
D
I 5o
l
Y••·
,;;; r~•
·,•
'ioa.
,
Yo , air.
Dtd
A
i
t 11
;/0"1
no•
"'
c·
!:!or
,
t'
~- l"t
I 80
,o
,10
'tt.
1....
I lr,f
WJ,a• 4.._,
aw,114.~rt..,. t:':11
.1
~
• 14a;•
...,
... 10.J:
o\°lr·~n-~,L
1
to
,.
D11 )
ll
co~ t •
tey
r::«=3n •· .,,. •'
,
l
t- ...
;,1
"
I
J.
u.i··
I.!' •
.: ttor 1
A
,&.. .. i(tr
or tl!, e"',
n orothe
•
thtt
...
• , ,.:, rrod.
~
tul
af••,.
c::~,~
t,.1
lws,,a;
~4.
J
t e hoffpt•al~
l•l:"'
~,
!
-~•
,.~
•
Att r oo•
'
0
ti-
u~
tier tirct' or lln" " -rr•
r
bT tl:~r,
...crrlH "'•
a~t you sail!
fl•
t'1l.
tll hie,
-. . Ll•..a'I
"i•J.'J.
•
rl.,.
t:>.]Lt'ld.
~a ra.Je'
I tlo1.
.,,
o:f "'"l-fli wrtto:C.
alJ.ltal1
b~ }.G.! h,:,li!
�''
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
th.• et or
an
l
£
\
r
.:,r a
• "
I
•
0
·oor
••
0
C!'OBS
L
t
'"'
..,.
!ti
00"1
i r o'
.r. L oa
tt
•
P.XA:li!Ultior,
r
11
A
1
lom-lld:
~
"'
o.
I 41
uld
•
e:ro
0
0
,. ..o.
"· ..,.,
•
~
•
~•a•a:1~
no•
n
i
•
IJ
t i: ..
•
• r •
Sl
0
•1·
t.>1!
at.• .
>- d ho ltu6ll i
l
...0
l>
r
1a t er
1
l
0
l.ittlat~
Yea.
u
Q
.,.
"
t.
"
'l:&lle;r
....o 'lier.
"
lot
•
0
nit.
C
•.:Ui
h
0
A
ll
he >,o
rI
"ea you
al
+ "J
•
a I"
y,
""
J8
no.
e not in t
ail'.
!'Jo,
t
A
H
!n>.oc" ur
/JO
h!.::I
0
u. •
Af
l> lJltt
t
• .,
ur:h.
:,a 111
Bll.14
U
.wo.'t•
h .ul tl\o hollow.
""'.er or
A
lt " •~rro4.
:11r~
ir&.
You '14 n t
..
a.•ter
d&T
tuir•.
d
I 4o
y • hilr
b•
,a
t
1
t
I c,t rooJO,
hJ" 1
•
r •
~
h
�•
•••
•'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,
�..•••
60
•
-''h"' 1ou
l.L"l ~nd l1Jl -~,
ln t 1 u., i.'ro t 5oor .
ti Ht
tepa.
lll
tc::-
,ou
1i.. 11 "'a.7 to ~ot to • •. Luoaa'
to•!:
.71,;ll
rleh:
*e".1
.. ti.rougt.
an~ f!O n• 6
rooo<
. it
1.l~Ir
"an to t'- ti right..
• -.:;; lth
~
--
' ,,+ ...ln
1'.
iTnut
4
I
•te
tUJ.
111'
'•e to
a~ ' t
,.:-,,c
t~a3"J
•
•o ;>e:ruia;'
,c- 1
-·r!.aa ~i
u.e Ct i. -111.Ti"
C
1:•or.
=~at
J.
J
to
th
�•
•
•
•
�••
5l
•
A
i:.:;
om1 t,rot'her'e
Y~u _,gye-r
car.
t ~•. '.auca.a?
knOl!tt
~:.:,j
,I.
..oybod3 Jtet" to 11.t,l11ca 1 I.:
ll
..-.
that
t1'.e, l'lJUlted to sea
la.a t.n,7 c;,thar peroi.ri1 1.:r. • ho room?
A
Jiot tllAit I b:o" o~.
•
Tho 4!.~ ~ou &"~ J>o:",l'zlc.
ueai.,
•
r.-o .,..;:i.tth..,.
A
A
rn.1:-e •
f'E'rt'liontr.-:1 ..
T f.'1)'1'!' 1n r:-ith
wltl• hire .-, ~n t>e -ot
rrc:>T
~
"ll:1.Jle, ~eor,E.e ··o Tillf.,
Pe
\Wll1
1•~
I wae s.lo!:f,
tut!
&Jtd )'O"-l are
tm&O~
d.14 not tfl:7 on; ..it,
to tell
•
• he :ur;,
tfou
to his
at her It waa -
�•
•'
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
.,
'
- -
•
,.,, 'I
•
• 0
> ll
"
1 '>n"°
p'>n: ~
...
•
u
JI
rr 1
•r~t
::."I
•
~
..
.•
,
•
•
• • er
iOI
..a,
•
a
'
•
A
t
..
lJ
.,.~
C
u
.,.,.
-
t
•
.1
•r
H
re.
•
I.'
I
10 ...
., 11
L
<'
-
f)'I:
•
lt :rou
lilt
••
..
•
,.
.,
11
,. i'
, .
...,.
or
--·
•
I.
•
...,,
,
t
. .,- •
~
.,. •
'o
•
•
'
~
Ill'
11 O'\!-
~
l
r
I"<
"°•n
nt '11'
.,
,...,
1
0 c..lo
.,,u•
u
J.a•
11.l1
-
UQG. •
•
• "
••
•ro
l
•
l'
~
o·
-...,i,
•l
}O
"
$"7-
,
Olll
oc
?
-
1t
• '
on
c.;
•
th
••
t U 1011.
u'
• r-oo •
.
... o' ,.,
• •
:0
I
.
or 1..
..
,, t+
"ninr •
O'
1
I
:u,•t
'fen
I.
1n 'bor•.
\r.
&'18
t
1•
tor
"
..•
I
•
t'
o• 11 o'
•
., "
•
••
ht
;a
a
••
+
\5.ea
J
ILB
'
•
<
l
o• .n
0 ,.
OJ •
,o
1t
il:
• ,,
.
• 0.
...,
,
!~
·- - "
D
T
;t<,.
,
• o'
•
•
• 0
.. •
ot
°1'1
•
1.•
e
r o'.
,
•
~~l
,'
•
..:e
~
., "i
.,_ :at':l
do 1
•
•
-
o' l~
"
'"
"
•
""..ey• rur
0
+.
t
!"
·~ ~.
pl •sl.
0
~
...,,.,.
1•
9 ,...• -.1 •
"
n or
·~
o' lO t
t
'1a
·"
�'
,
"
,
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•
'•
55
•
'
Wf at
ns
~.
•o
ent
151,en you
acid
L"l the
Jfln'"~B!lt
!lO'II'
"
anst waa an1d be t11aon ]()U
l
I dou 't kno 1¥ ll'h&\l
I n
Sn td ;,n thou
t 1n
h
t.uo•,, that
t.ook il
he
10
tr.ere
· a4 co 70l'8Bt1on
abour
a~t!lin
waa 8.1:lJtthint <•" id.
o•id.
008
n
Sl!f:11 .in
t}
he
o~
"lJ'I
the con';'-era&tior..
steer i.nr wboel
n4 tn t);~
I
~
, hei, it
went over
in lo SP.0 hi,
V,'°!l
ho
ocnswrv.,;:t ion it
m:~ ol&i •~ t et he had hold
rrect,
•J,•
ll
'3e L. 'h.o rooc")
:ad holJ
tl-lerA,
t~
fJlld him?
I wer:t in to se-e. him tllld Wbi
tht.1 ·sall.
c n you
1th Luo,.a?
tau
!lo • I do vot
4
when it
rooc.
.l
what ccnvt1rsa:t·1on
ha-i~
1
LUCA.2
the 11teer In!' """el
went a,•or the 1L"llll..
t •lao,
UlS nn1, bl' JO'l to hi
if an:ThlJI<:,
hil. to you oxoe1't •hat l·• l1J11d
hold of tho steering
ffl>n t 01'0r
• or b1
w~eel w,,en 1 t
t l::e 111111'
o~int
.l
else
'\. vo.r; 1 litt
A
~
coace,:-nin•
1- 1 know or.
lo r.rhiltt.
Yeo, e1r.
"'\ tid.
..
sail
I•
"OU Bi-;
aollll'
. 1:1,- •
I ~appose 11 hnyreu,
I :at tr.ere
a,:-e
cl:ai~
L tte room •
...o:co 1:ere chair a ir1 there.
n,;
certa.in
a 'he aa1a he 1,,.4 hcl:l
,.
tb
•-eor1re
1'r.o l.
o" does
,..-er., in the re
lhe11 i1:o ear weut over?
'1
I
'iSBl.1."'t
thinRi:ip
.!Ul.:,t.1'.iu tin.a ['oinf
to corne of tr.ts
et
�l
I
..•
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
-
�••
1 d H not .:eep "'
ell.
;yo,. hl1d this
After
Q
raco brance.
wl rt him, wtere
vuraetion
001
did • ""
fO the!\ t
,.
ant 'lul:e.
Dltl not to ba;;k. ur to your brotr.e.-r I s .r-,o,...'·
I d.on't
-now ttat.
t
i"'
"111-11
it
A
I do
110 l
"
l;'Jl
I ditl or not.
Do
1.
ii::nowtl n tinrn r.-e left.
urr1'A :rn:n70-u out of
1
1
roo • d.11Sn
't ~oy ...
;,..
i,i W!:11" ft
you know 1he n: mea o
do not tno
~
l:01
you l.t t toin?
r!lll
" doc,tore. cc:~
"
e wet:t
ll:ero.
""'"~
the ioctora?
•
an there ~ore tban onet
:-em r.1,1er. ".'be-· 11sk(>d us to
T don't
a
t•• ~1
the !"002:l fo:r
-::tee.
i
i'h T •tr-Jft
JOU leave
"
of 4~.
co~ia
-ou
I ·lo nol now ~·hat tice
thq
"
3. or f.
t0YI'!'!...
e -o co---.uon"" of tr.P
Just a:3 eoon
e.
leavo
:J,nt
0
1
~""
i7e
osr,ii:al..
l!l17 iiea.
ShH'Uet
'r.
.
olook.
llo\111d ua to at ;; 111 tl>er• ·
'"ou s.a1& n. Whl:"..e a o abOll't f'i Y'!
m1nu-"'s.
Tn fr. tUc.ar:' ?'OOr,J-.
Y011·hen wnt
I uoi,-~ to":
1 h v• told
it.
l!!ttl
::;ou
that'
J>"•
ple
i.:ome? 'lut ,ou dcm' 1 blo
ell
all
:;·ou bo,Jrus9
l
.ow.
"71.a1t t~ Ln~oa• roo
dor
ia t 1s: t~e n~~e
raoc.
pli~4
£0 1mll.
d vitb
oor
nd all :'ar 11e l o8ll ritu.
011 know I ".at
t
Ju.at to 1r.a ~~or of iuo~s•
t.~
o,, oxuct 11.
a1>011t
11 I C • eey.
J::r, ,hifflet.
~hat
T do lOt:
ho di~ not
you~
ro
fa.,)
J1d rot
ro•
~.e truth
,tout
ex:
t
,ou aat'ed how ~~flt.
end t>mt
cc e 1n •he roo
le i;ll
or
n
tl,
4
our
ro~ ,r
~ ~
r9-
-oonveree.tio11
and &it do=
ln \to
�••
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�••
55
roo::i
• nll"
~
Ia11't
the 1'tlwle tr:itl:T
!lo you dony thut
I h v• told
ia the truth'
Y01J '111 l i::I:off.
la e.U I h&va to Ge;'
l:lu;t
l·e trnt.t
notbino
•
ant
e l.ae.
:nd fnr~her
a :t'3G
eL~r tirnt
t
depo out ea.J.•h not.
thin
;..."3
ma. •
witness
i!ltr .3duo&d 1n "he a,a:e beha1f,
duzy a1:orn, 07.nml.11od by llr.
Dannis Sh1rr1ot.
n=or.
doronoc
e.B follor,u:
JO.'lrrloa ;:onr dai, htert
I "oel1ove.
Yea. e:1.r.
"
Did y--u cot:& to set' ., ir-
Yes. I was u
1.~
tbe hoepit nl ...
t.e~e on
I lh1;!1:..
!?r1dey "ornl.n
Yes.
rot 1iere to thfl 1-oor.it9.l,
il'<on yo
are J'O'tlbe..-•
A
~
1d not tncw
Ii , b,
di~ hn l:Do•.1 J;oii?
.
.cu.':a.::dey "".11..in'"
1 ~o n01 ~ow v•het•.er
I .-as or -nol.
?e
1en you sa
v;-n_s ,
ot con~cio~m
ht..n. 1nu1
#'- ..
lJo. sir.
"'
• ~•l<tn
I
.')'1.itflet
an 1S
!.:.r.... ath<::•r di ifflet
\:&r.8
l"t~L ou--
Yes. sir.
!ll4.
•
\
Lolley
,
ihoee
r
""'"tiB
t:t:bJ
;;cur aon'u
Qwne '-1.tb uo on
.•;tt,>
d1
:{011
c=
1· 1!88 Zello..,.
1
JJ
!l..3Jt.G
--
unde7.
"0 ~- 1::•
Cr::::-•
t e one ne-t- hers'
ll
thrl'.'e
ot ue
dlln'.$ •
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
••
'
fjf,
•
Vas .
L •=d
.\
di3,ovcroa
dom
e =do
0111~ en out.
to ce.
llod
i t'lffl•4
Jnd o;
t!td you
Yea.
'
1
I "B :ed
don't
1'0<11
UlOW
whu
•
b n!I on t
:us1
Oroee-exOJ?;il1' t ioL by
I
tito
boi,t
of
.,.e.d".
that
.,,..
~
•o e
doctors
1"•e-
nd
d ,ny
C"t-t
.
Fu-risonl:iu-
.
I ta "' 110 notice
~=
t<>l•r~'bly
of
ht t 1,,..e o~
a...,,.
et to t'le 1:oepitnl •
e rly.
o..,.,
ctr
trt·
·c
11 the '!"ooi:::•
.:'UAt eat1m
J+- ':Urht
11 1
!i
'..
1 • of de;· d 14 :·o~
tra:i
t t _. etc.rtod
't},i1
<i
TI
l'CG '!.<?
dG.f
wl:o.t
urte
tn
ban
boon 10 or 11 ~•~1<:>0.lll., 'lS r.c r u
I c.or.
er.
1"4!:!8!
oi:, wer~ 1n tbe
,
did not etny
i-,
I
'1ocpito.l
~
ut
11.if'
an bovT
ao
in t1'ere
1uld I ll=Ti'
!011r r,,ysolf
.J 0
o:i 11000, ·,t of tr.e md1cine
&ilo
out.
ot
..
I boon in -he
lcmr wh1le .
'.?l•i:Jtty
a !:o aai-i
c:.,,.r
!,ueas
ltto•u·
C'\"eT
•1: • 80 I
.,u-.
l do not know ti,.•t.
1to
air.
r.
T'
net l:now nc: e c~ the doc•o:.-u i
~~
:i,at
11.&bo
.,..o
t·•\18 oar wror+ ove!' tht1
........
ed to draas
..... "?
r.
domt
s•o:.-t.
~a r 1d
en
!:rC•l1t'
etDE'!"I - 'll'hool.
e 1d
i:l
"""
rot
CQ□
no I 1'!iorh•o:!.
"eelinF,
1JA
tm,1 QS ...
;e .J1ii'! .lhtffloi-
"e :,.cr:riod
�•
'
•
..
•
•
•
•
�'
••
5?
t
7c tU' dQU,..hter
A
Yds,ntr.
D•nni• ns u:p ~,
1r■'
"tea.
en ,-ou cru!)f!:fo'ml etai.rc
L.:r. I.uoo.o oe!.led
tho hGU.
i'fJS,
s.r.d were
to you from hio roorJ"
1r.
Aa a
■ tep
A
-• wna
?
Hie room Y1ae riot:
~
dom
dter
that.
a I
!!,e:,
•ye•
ovo1 af1 er tl14t.
tell
the·
o.
etwoer:; ..he 1·.c-ont door and tl
&
ut 1r
~
11.
t
bao.t in tl:at t:l-
""7
1\1
;;o• en
Yea.
oo
I
he
bac
l
v•r
II
hi,.
d1d se•
te::-::!!wt th '::.
~"-"re is Gl1 ill
I tonu 'i
feol1.~
b
wi>:t
it
ie
r.
u.
-:en'+ a
Ot
"•
"
lo hca ·1een to m;, nlace i,everlll
an
•
ie
~1"'18
lld
y~
•
~
"'
&.ti
·-o
at
"
. - ,.,
~
t
0
01?1"
..
~o
tt,e,re aeTeral
8
t1 ee.
t v1
at1ll'
r
0
le.oe
t
1r e•
ce ~over l t!'l»a.
1np
~
1
:bo•1..
t~ see
to
ea e do
,1r:·
1•t you BO
-r.-,........
bl9
OOt"'
no
t!r.es
in er:· 11.fo.
r. out
anyt"l
so ' -.,Ol:.r" <>t" i'iVt·
11 I
1
he C.oi.nJ'..,,
eiu ,._ ve bt<en 8'Jl
.ed
o·· 'or
od
hss be n to ,;iy pl
I do not
,,
ar,·
a heer •o
0
o 11 a ter!lB an cvor
~
e
...0
l"
a st1
Vlll
e
Vlhat
tlM
I
t~
tt •
OT
L
~n. red on "ir.:.,.
"-enr.
~~
I do not
0
o 1011e 1 t.
.
�'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,
�'
fi8
I
..
•
ttdc'tt'"
«t1.
ovflr.
, '!lY·,,l't & 11 "ttl"
I never
eel a.td
0th.in
:-,,..-.e
doc-ors
t;co
r..o r c tdl of 1t.
el~c~
owe
1n .end es.id t ....o
mntocl the roor:, nd
n.a.
t•s
all
'>ont t""e cor...-ore t1o ,.
ooa
s
0
d ru:
,cu rece::ber
t.o a trna: , to trl3~t ,. l c: P1J.4.
41i''iMJ:ltier.J
I!:
-·
,,...u,-
tc
•
•
I
"'"'
ot :.I
n~ ~..,d.1c
D'
'
~
e ...,,4c .e
ir4u
·o~s otk ~·on
D1.4 1 l.'"tlet
J;O
•l.
• 1'0 ~\.Ct milt:d
"" 1'1;;Jon >•1 "llet
,..o~.
l: l"'
111:9"
j
VI)
'
+}',jt.'.!" ...
to
t)
ro
1
s1c•
01
t ..
• O\:~
on •oo.
r.1 t!I you?
.Jot in Luc ..a' rco ..J.
~
~
l.
£~et waa 11it.· 1:18
or~~
"
H& OlJf wl th ·•vn dorm the
ri
!>id the doctoro
ro
~
Stc'r'B?
uot':..l'!n to dreco
dom in J. r. tu.cur
~i
room.
,er.1 ie'
owl.de.,
�•
•
•
•
•
r
�•
,., You trow
\
Yee. ir.
A
01,m • t
ococ iei
_r. .Lei~'¾tcm ··-nele.r'
cm a k "ill
~
re~e .tly
.u:.,t
-:r. l""'
t roo
t1
J-e l:oBPlt<l?
l
~io. s1:r 1 1 did not.
nd f:::r+."\-!!.!'t't:1a ae o.."'ent enith
not:.
~
l)r..!W!~ s·-·r11:,t 'l'. 11 W1 t t e-tB intrC'dUoed 1n
·,et,
flr•H
duly
lleume,
r
A
exw,11104 o;; l!r.
morn,
h II old
tiB
1'ol1o'l1~:
,u-e JO:;.!
and r.Oll mw,y children'
.Ht':ried aJt4 hn';'O • 1'H'
ere •~e, m~b you c
~
•n~• ni
~t~
Le·,
Yes.
vow, 111!• nnd ohil4ren
wen on to the hAUJIG an,i ;,au
L.:t-.!.acaa'
!rltl'l
i.
ont tho
4n,,ceea
i.?'1-:;--t'cter.
'1 You ..,..
WL~
ll~i:.
18 O ·.n beha...!' •
~- y wer. l on ,;o tl10 r.ouae.
·ar.
Q
I autn d her 'to ret cut
"• toox the
5he h.r,.d tl'l.e ar.:aller
one i~i her armt;.
...:ter
lr.:i ve me to '!arr is
or ton.r.:lo
~5 t.~ t>.ror.e
o 414 ~ta:,
I ne,er
"'
lilld ho thl't'TT
About t> e oh :1dror..
the booie eoat asleep,
oronej
i,;,
what"""
roouih.
rr,; 1 ife
l!r. Lucan thro,,od
her out.
oi;.t:
l'\e noy watt in
cit: O"'tutd'
Ee Jw,;,ed cm th~ c
l'
~nd
id
Cltt!ltn"p."'
:as ;;o,;.r car
heado
t~nri
tl:e
lu~
ldre
!:c=tain.
east.
.n.1t on~
'"ownrJ.riOft.flt,
t""\Ull'~
tl:,
1he
t rMd,
.., 4
Icna1ta.1n.
1?1.&tn.s
tt~ next tb1 ~th~
�..
•
l
•'
•
•
•
•
�••
fO
•
A
•
,o ~n+ on ove~ ;ho top of tte !irdt
~
t~lk
:;ou
1:.o.-.-,
6llJ'
to rr.i, ;.!'.•h.enI'o
do&' t 1:no>r wlult it
"il-11t tl:<1 Oevil
l
elly
peat int
Rlon
Croae-e~a
·•
•em:ec!'" 1:.e tooJ.:: we.
1 l;r.
er
LUd he ':it
! r~•ir.bor
nd I OAid
v.;"tu.•
·;
i;,,
rs
~e n.-airl.
~ i.:l
Ibo hoc it l ,md..;;
Ba.YD,
oll,
OC'IS ·~!'"''1
tnation
_., '!" • t'AT~<t,sn;
;,-aa ha.ve 1n ;rour ca.
now wt t 1ou rr.Jved
Vri
'
~
that•
"ie.t ""8
1
11
Dei:ni.11•
on me.
1J"
t in t'h@ r i"'e yau
ivo
tn,f').
11 e Glld r.c.id ey fC e.
9'1:iat's r.t t 't,._ttj' D!S.-:''l.o I io yon ncy'
1
"'
l.ut
n-.~t'a
no1:h1~-.
acid
~&
t
1011 •.
..1J
~1u,t•a
in
1
I oa1.4,
t.
d~ •
'Yo':1 b- 70 be "1l 0':l
:hat ild
pn:ilea
ena
18.1.::ed nn to r'-~ ~,,o• ot the bed aIJi
·10n' t kHc
""'
er."
ycu •cir.•.•
ce
--
• . tun.
hmc
1l!l •.
1hen , Ito l'
~'Oras,
dr!.111DR:tt~
~he ~ext t~in
brc \i·er
L:Jtrsho.11 J iveo,
on u.,, ne ot !:er hill
·~ rto~
D14
!!r.
h111 ie r.here
The f1Tst
h11l --
<J!:ai; yot, • id.
M ear ....
!lo
JOU
�..•
•••
'
'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�..
••
Gl
•
•
\
J ha·e
,,
Dld. the
lt
p.c-id any tine
:urv
:u don 1 '!u'111d on'" o~ thf' car
well
fl
"
r.tJte
llll
t•Jlll
lo :?t te
th.al
1orni:1r#'"
r
h&r "P in '1a er~"'.
he
~
1d .
ai.?".
V0t1 h:.oll'
O
d~1Te
1'!)
one,
a o:ar"'
,.,ut u~en
1't.on ~70•1 :rourhorl Ha:rnebe:rrors
.Pro- .,,,,.,o rid
11 e t't. I.
no•hl.r.g
to 11..:.i.r:-i!lonbu.rr,•
rri, t.olil :,.·o'!J.1'.:'I d:t1ve ti.
hill.
bl"!" f
J'
1~ -h
t
-:r
l ac -:o·
10'1'
rt
no-t sto'\"'lriod it.
• Te ,:ct
the diste,,••·
:01,:r-rt "t ,·o ~emir.
9 a
U LmC~
~
r;~~"'·1d
"rew Ul"'lr
...
eoTI lrivit.J
,
::. L.u.a a
•1
Yea.
~
.,_t.
eott inF in the ob,; 1;-.
e didn' c ,,1,:
"
t!.rle.
t:.1Et,1)ce'
1\ waa 11 r1
~d
!t
t1:✓
rmd nulled
·., =red
it.
ttvo
tlle.
~il~~
1 h• '>e.
"bll t
arnal:ori,er hill~
s roinP. up the
Yes. ntr •
., t•o rasl
a
I
wer, you roir: ?
FOi:"
m an 11.1,·••
r-1 he m..u t ,
ln~
l don 1t b1ow.
my •ife
•o
rou'
to
l Sil.ya.
U: to no wb•n
:ii.
ttl..r
''Don'r
to rJO,
e.lkiI:E' c.1>out?
T v1on1t
~
th~ c
!"'1Imi1,
t ~na be
: t!~i be l!C'
'le s= ,tad r,'ll.
,J,oro die ho onoc·· you?
!
<ln both
~~~
cl
I} """
on tb
'e r.horo l as
on
of t>,e head'
i4oa.
w•~•a1•t1f
l· t
On tho eide
l lC!I
rt
le!t
bend aide of the car•
ee r-t1..-....
ht
l, r:l
0
8 \Oa'
..,o,
�'
•
•
,
�f
"
•
'1 l!o l'.it
A ·:ee.
..
"
o
you rol.nr un the Ha.rrrnberr r ~.111~
~aa\ were
~
1 41d no
o
ou d:i~n~
tc nh w o 'tu-
D!JJ"t' •~
T
I'ow did he hit
vo·., on
tr~ loft
A , ..~vbo I t, ....,led ll'o .....
nd.
"'
You. tur1od
ti
1-.flad,
I don',
"hor~
I do ':lot
Je
•
.
it
a oui I oa$e.
a oi
now.
:,,m:r
lil
on •l:o o
t J,t!lln out ot the
I oouldn'
1"nD
JOU
I
hnnri a1de7
!U'Otmd ::ind l:J"': ii::i
o
t
the b1ll •
.i
:,,0111
ta
Clll'.
J,Ot, beh:een
"Vm.sthera
~
i ie
:tau nn4
!Ir. LT.lo G~
to.
r,
,o!"e ,nor•
It
·e a 10 eo.
~
sot"JO ~ur~
-here?
,'ht..t do 1011 eo.s..
I\:
;~
J ""
"
Iser o the
"
3us.,.. tell
!11 P1J there
u,
~u.
or not,;,
·.:.11""~
...,f.'lt.
?"".
'llhe•l:er or
n.J,._ ..
,ere
re
s the!"e"
A
! Cave
"
Jaat
A
I
..
A
~t
,'1tat 1•0111,• b7 11!'.at he :ollft
,
., ,, or
~
tell
re
,,., 'heth~r
ru, :t'ieh, hl • tl'.e
Don't
:rou
r don't
iron.
111fti:,e
rnlled
0
,.,
lf l t
I
or not t lie :ufllJ v:ftre th ore.
o tl'.er
llhul
to
:!!CTI'
o""a I
on t h•!ll.
Co.£0
it
now.
10·..1
!. t:now i:f it
.-oulO tell
-
Tri \h-'I
:;or.
:i:ucxa.
~:! 117.
�-
ll
.. -
•
•
fl
0
1
I
•
r
•
•
""
• bcnro
• I
•
0
•
.,
.,,
•
:
•
•
•t
L!
•
•
.....
"
•o~ ll».,..,t •o
'
•
'O'"t :f ..
•
•
....,..
•
•
I
•
..
u
-- l -
""
.....
I. • I
..,... ""·'
.. ~•
•
•
. tor.
t
•
,, fl!l
"" LC•• '""
'l'O 'ftl,Ufl!
,. ,~""
'tr.1
•
td:I
IIE! [
•
•tlo''IO
110
u ~
"
a:urt :r.m•r
"'1
t
dit
&11
I•
•
r
l
4
• •
IJ1IIW • ao
..
..
~
0
a:alt
• ·06
°"
(
1.
.
t
'J.I
•
-
t
••
1
�f
G3
•
Q
Did ,on buve yo r h t LIi at
r.s iiml!~
A Yfte. I had it on
~
l<r. 'nos
a
,'hat ia •h• .....:.n.ractftr ot !'h" ro
you un t
hit
bent;
tlo
all
lllo
b.,re
·.ood or ,ad"
rl.,i,o'
O
f:torn the ,·,oint
ftrB.
ll~ 1'
o, , t roti h.
soo
atrai
hter
I
ne
Yo
od
,-en 1n tho ro"'4 •
Cl'1
l .roa,e
r eTOl' boo,
ovff
o..ro
curved.
l" y~u Wft.re ,:noe1,no1cua. J:ow did
I dor,'t lmov
Joith~
• -•
troTa
You nre
70,:
tho
I
Tee drove
'l:,t
! :: an!
l:e
A
I don't
•
4r1nti
tnaw 1! I
! oo 14n 't
ell
A
I '1 "• told
..
l:ia
dr L'll:t1111. l
ftll
70n
ct!
r I
tee
4r1.nt1n
WD
or
!101; •
0
abc• t 1t.
d117
u~
You lDOW. do 't
•
l
1'l::o o..r?
it.
"
l)n!ore.
O driT~ it.
oc drivo
I oan tell
rou oll
tel11
I
otl:er mat"'el".
""
Ir.
,UC)
a
~
1t :,on u 1ie
~
the hO
, did ho break
the
• in?
A
cy s ull wee.
"
Rho told
abo11t the'"•
•·011
! 41ooovei-lld it
know ,~ .. t ""s tho .,:,.ttor.
,.
After I got In the boa~1 t&l.
l IC ,or, tl ey toot
"ne ron 1 noroes
&1
I dor • t
X-rsy.
tho 11ou tr.in whero
ou pot
hie o<ll" or
oo~ or ba.d ~
ll mow1tni11
0
Yo•· id not l-nve
If' I h d I
!teeif',
11robo4.
V0ll4 ■
0'1ld
n:,, tronblo
•1
v• t'll"•~4
eoni,
it
l~ose
tho oo.r 1n t>,e ro d<
nd lel
i
core,,
�..
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�f
u4
•
Q
711• first
t1'.e
A
I ion' t
ti'"'·
t'\,,at
1l loose
l ~·o~ld rot
l had btol'IO UJTt inp aoont
"
tnrned
)'Ott
h•v
l!!9
1o
r,m r.:;;nolf 1l tl:'•r<> if
1t •
ne it 7011 ua.y you • 14 to LttolU! th11t o!l·ll!•d hi
I a.ou't allow"'¥
• 1 eayn do, 't •o.'Jc to rt.o thllt
ta.Le: to
wae when you ,ot
lih9D I
11."l
wife
to
•o
tho oar.
driYin~
n4 1
A
Ee bi
Ia •b
alO •
1
11 I aoi~.
"
?'
lao:
Jll'f
at the tico
Tea c,.,..,
that he lia
A ~-••
111,
J.'l-. Lue•
:rou 11n6erarrt11 t tor
the
rl'lil!E
;yc:2 tc
tr"11D crtiJP
ola1.ca be arre•~•4
<> 410
~1th.
••
o~ an,
..~1,,.,7'
•er.
hn• I
n
cbu'~od
lie said l~i.-.. ce to Harrieonbur..
~
ll1dn't
you all
1:1111
wbJ'
.\ llo. r never o 11.e cy :ou!J:.
0
roa Mk hi.!, ~h;v he want~d you to d:rive l:r-
l.
!lo, I 1evGr a1una 111 thnt.
"
"Lou 11a-.i:r
him ex I raot
I he oor2 tx-oc. or..e of
those :u~
to
&n4
the om,tanta:
a:rell
A
""•
Didn't
the
l could
not 11'1lto~ 'h•
rood end s·otob 1-im too.
All I c·w
,-m dro"" d 011 rre ,
~ .. -DL~3Ci:'
~s
tr.
Q
You he,ird l'r.
TT~•~r.,r :
nJ.tve.
•
C1'tenb11okor'G
etatl'l
nt here
that
you made
�•
•
•
•
�•
••
•
4
Jlo. sir:
attitude
that•a
~h•n he arre~t•~
Exoi ted
Q
I don'1
II oethillg
ao or. 3undoy.
l at,:y
o.s he ano:r,r or a:i exot t o4 mun'
ou.
:;a,i.
Ia lalr. Lucun when cia..k:inr.m arr~at,
in t~e hub1~ o11re..av-
Ohje :tlen.
r.cod <lll~oot 10 ••
thar9
'1 llr.
~o.rr.:um:
I\
Shi:!'flet,
Jr.
"t
you e VJ l.'.r. Lueu.
the point
~.owoloao mo
fOl1,i, ur, the '1a,-rcsber ~1111,
hit
l t to
you
'b p
oue.•
~OU r,o 1r.lo hiE Tlaoe.
"
About ho f r aa from here
A
:uat eo.ut.
~
"'he C.01:;...!•e
18 1D
A
"
:,ot1 1
at t inp
erlec:-1;
!ine
l
do m to the road.
!'lain
T'!.sw fi"o-a
ohop 1 a betr·een
~
era
in v1~w of th• Chni, I.om or 'Arnsberger
8t&!lcJ1r g
-" r.ct qu1•e
".'he placo
&ul 1di•,rt
th& Shop.
behind
Soce trees
7le
?'tel&
to the
That r,la.co on the road you ea;,i w~1ora you
111 pl
t eTo.
1a ye:ri
over
over
t ... to
to
the :ro!ld ma
he hit
t!lt!Jro
•= eoc,.:
of the bill
¥.
Pn °'!e hit
r.ouee •
b•Jil:111
C":"8"!'
··e.
•he:,. he hit
the ho11.o.
yon v,as n~ar
tr.e pate
roine Jnto the
Chap le.ra plaoe..,
A J;o ie,.de&.!. co did
I:()•
,-e- to the i:ate.
b•
rate's
on
top or the hill.
Q
ao,n ~~t.,,.en
~a~
it
llo.
I had don
?ullod
Chap L ~••
one hill.
rnto
,md the rood
e other
htt1
reu
ie be-
�'
••
•
'
-
•
•
•
�..'
•
•
Gu
huen
us and the tu....,, or tl-.e roll4.
,.,,_ere 1 11ce4 to 11,;e -m4 ha
"' ~ie
Tl:e:-o 1ZI two 'b.illa bet119en
11 co oc •?,e lAat. hill.
ro
on. tho ~o d co~•• u•
'hft ~!Ul
et~•
llr.
11.'tt:~ri
J,;~
r
r
objeot
to tbaT q'leatlon.
rr::ar1 baa ar -,t n ~ t
t +- etor
,
iJ
1."tl'17
:repoo.t1,,,,..
"'-
The Oonrt.
1..na further
Dr.
..
' . ,.
1
ire~
•b1e 4epo
t
ult" not.
"'-«hon a• n1 v,hen ho arrivfJl.
,.n4 t berour,on
the
�•
• i f t.d •• I. ..
lt
m;
OJI t
t.l
AV
-
r.
:l
•
•
tllJ
I
•
."
•
•
ri
•.
..
r•
0
·u
T
•
• •
X
�•
67
•
c. .
.. L. l'. U'1l
1 tne • r -> lle<!
exru 4 nod 'bJ:' ..-..
.,110i71..:;
.., to
>\ Yoa. aLr.
v~u opfH' n tr, a. rlouri
r
... co..
11er 1
,
~a-..
1-
,e .
·~.
•
~1
c-1
0'
bo
O!
t
ac:- ,o H o.
•
•
r:u--, ◄
de,
t tl1e b"' i.r1itl'.Bl
o l
.. t:r
iI!
tr
e'""
+ion o!
r. Lncc.J i
l
li
•
-ve
1
~~
1
"t
• r.
,., .o•
•
••
0 '"i'e
r&ll,;
•
0
or.
re -iar~ ('14
•h~
i'r: tln'-:1.
1+
,..,
e:..:..!
11.104 ~y
,.
L,
-·.
I
Teo.
,.
~
..
• , to.r:.."'
tr.at
or.
•
""
ir.
T r.ill
C
niJ 1
.,+ .e.,.,-
ont
lr-
n
1101.
:rnc...:.
P,
;a, ::-;::nn
der.ose4
_
raJ.lo, e;
'
1r.
You no
,11 ,-;e:-e :,ext ~oo'I" ne1 hboro •Jnt I l it,·• f1.ro .
..~0.
~
VO
•
e
�,.•
•
•
•
•
�'
••
,,
<,
\
68
•
•
~
'!ow lcu
!
A on~ 20 JOUB.
A
Yo· , air.
CJ+a+
1.cVil you knoffll. h I IL?
to
,.,,, ,1ur,,/ 11het~1"
it
i.o POOd .:'T 1'ad •
·oo4.
hi.I!'. on 1>a.•~'
o\lld ;tc~ b•l1ev~
beliove
T W0"1d
Do JOU _:,w
~.
him on 0&tb.
C!fenbaclcer
eir.
A
Y
•
-
Ile·· r l:en!'~
1t qces
re.r de
yo~ live
•o
A
~
faurtb
lieut
;., It ia
1.:ioJ.
trom
11!.~
of a lllilo.
cod.
At t~J.s ~01n~ !Jr.
~.
ireb&n~t, • w1•~es1 tor t·e d4t
1
o..:----e!·~91.'1~ first
dulJ a710rn,
o.rpeared u.11~/~a•
o.si::ed •he rollo 111,. uent ions
:· ::. " c er
,~
yoar-
"avo beea
·t~o.
~lvtur
v ,o. sir.
~
l>14 ;;o-.;
~
ion espoo1ally
to
-ray
1>orl:,
r.1:r.
:.
+i,c toepl
your attoi
t 1~
I did.
I hOV&!l't
rry rMaordu
w.1}
""'·
Did. llOl lulv-e tli,ie
~
de
�..•'
'
••
'
•'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
d
�..• •
•
69
t~
ot
tt•m.
~
"• ..,,- 1D the 1losp1t.el at
A
''eo,
•i~.
it
wa
"1111• >-owns 1
!:>\.
o:t tho t l!::e
:lB 'h
uJno oi
rt!
11cc::s :siOGs.
R.B
n1at ..,id th.'lt
A It tho"1e4
~
ri--h~ Bile.
"'il
;,o,
. d1dn'
Ii
he t!Jr.e!
or ital.
-ra:,'" disolose.,.
fractu:re
o" th
It 1111ath~ ou•er
otic~
ny otr.er
.oti~e
an:,.
You 11 :e 1oe
'le
or tbe ekull
plate
on
la e.
lo hin ~erao
1njurlos
.bl
ot eo:e
,,,,tor
i•
a..1 , ea
piotc,-eo
c~
•
u: ed t
r. Luoae•
do.
leg~
~ctur .. dlaolcoe-:rooor3
rrfl.otur'J
:,or inn•ed
o e.
loooo
of
here.
lho ler,.
I toot eon~
it
~- I +~
eri:t we:-a ·even,l
l X-r :r Pzam1 a,ton
o,
1
a
'ri'a
,ii,aes
of'
18 ler .
..".
d
f
.....
er
\."Id th.,rouJ,on
-.u
• r.
u
t is dercnont
the
.r.o.:.·:r.y
"'"'
ani +.., T'!:O
t .
Jo:r.e:ozn.c,a\\h rell'
rocalle3
,,-
•~e
nua.-n on. de 1 o nod at1 fo 11 ow■:
"
'r.
~
Lonfl:;- you li\'o
c.ilee
~cutb of
n• -:.kton~
1.lkto,1.
ed ter
"o=11'9altb.
robutt!ll
• atino"7
Dlrl •=load
y
�1
"
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
..
••
9
•
70
,
..eo,
r-1r.
e:: 1
II
Dernl r,,
"W h1n
lie ;ro
tn
· t 4cn 1n
t;:o TlllUll
i ty .. •
~c,r tr•1tb"
~. I
t
•
:noViL
tr.
r '•
on
1·
! do •t
aod.
t .re nut tion
'l8
0~
•1
1· 1
01:ld
0.
'OU
re ,ttc
olievo
001-h~
ir.
vea.
-,
..
, ...•
OU
-
lr.
e
•
•u
I ne~r
ta 1 t
D~-t:
h
J•
r'l"1U
ta. •o
di
.:"".ta.£'
1
r't
buc:..:-c-
<('.
a.
I
'!Ver
hai.r5
In t "1r., •
•tll
-e
.'
0
,cul
leve
'r.
tell
•
fu~ h.er tht • der,on
ctt
Q
truth.
,t t
1th
nt t.
c~
,
tt•
._.t.!.1.!'r:-
1
�•'
•
•
•
•
•
J
�'
'
"
••
70
\
•
71
•
fr:t. 1'. :. LtJCAZ. a witner.:5 intrc,du.c,
ta.to,
rooalled,
bein
,.
exacilled
Luo
l:r.
by L::-.
..er,.III',
•if•,
~!,
ct~ld;
Oelieve
111 one c"1ld.
~o aai
Ull!
or- bel::al-f" o.,;-"".:he
dopoaes
toa<'ifi•d
l)e1,n1e 3r.ifflet
l:.a:1;:1o!ln:rr,~tlld him ('In th"' ct.ar e ct
fT>bbea
<11
;,eat rd,cy tha1
"l"a.uB o:rti!
1'0!!
. erd throw ttee
os :l' ollo'13:
liquor
;:011
1 l,' ~le children.ont or
b
car.
one
~id ~on
~o ~b~t or not•
li:l'o, Bir.
I ncvi?r t.ouchf? t.l:.et'!.
l •rndorefoo1
!Ji
4' n•c.rcb
you to nay ~•qaterd:i.y tbet
t1 a o.ocueed
rna•one
for
at 11;:,t
no wecro•1- 0:1 1a l')er on and you co~
A ,,,
e.-el" touched
I)
l1l ft
the
IJ n
d1ot
'to
!:ad nn·ea
ii:
t you bea·
81de ol' the "-esd,
1 i. hit.
to l:1
1J!towr
r.nd i
lie had a ~Jlt
,1ver
thor
t'•
~ir,:i betwoen us.
ouee
l:.ill
of
in. rr~nt
tho }:Aaa -- r.it
'tic.
ho .,1.i1d
tnaoncroiouar.ess.
c:;.ee lJetWO~t' ua
bl.n I <>ouU no--=i,.a...,
up two root
11p t!ie !larnshel'.-.rr
nc1 frO!Il •11~ s· ..ewudcah
hlll1d eico -- r,.1d lmoclc~d J:1n: into
:ri•ht
ooc-aeio!l
aetti
on to l a.rrieonbure;.
•11at i;olnr
~u:ther
L:r. Chep !,!l.m1a ho'Q.Detl
on tho
1m• £Ud fo md ~e bn~
a.! aJ.l..
:'"e
O!' snot
ana:e;ren
aono 1t an4 ~a
Y~u o n't
U
be~ -:to
outc~ ~old of t"e
a teer in~ \The.,l the t """.
~
Vou 41~ not touch bir:~
A !lo.
A!r,
"1111 ·lfit
·,e treat•d
Q
I h"-d no OOO&R!on to 1,1t him.
!lbOolutel7.
,· il
,re
i:e • oat 1f1ed yen =re
,.
,
\r.l8
I.av r tcuoho
• B1l'.
" •eati!ied
a e~le
etll .;,'OU.
<lid
rot
lo the 'rid
tall:inp
to h1n~
e.
l
�'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
I
�'
•
•
71
\
72
•
tu
llllon:
to
an dr1T'n
l u•vor eoi•i
A
11
'l '.licl '10 a,,:,- th ~t
t
·h•fr1
t(
No. atr.
SfO
stairs
~
ital
Ytorl to hi•.
~
;.er. 7ou wre
tlo, air.
• pa~iant
tu the
. ou !r. a roo
ockinf"=
bo l • an ~e
on bao .....
=ooo wera JOU 1n~
ertt
18 room lS..,
.t. Ri ht
stra1;,:: t back.
t ar•ar
_your a tart
the lefl
at
;oo~ 1
llo j side
in ~oo~ 10.
1
t~
the
tn 'baok 'Uhorc t. _oy ~ave dirty
ljl~1.-:Jr;;{.
~er~ ~canr,od aroundT
Jh ~~et to ttnother
.,. .an:•'Oll~ cominr
b• ildiu11
~l wey or
the
pass
roo.
9ro l.r:'
;;,01.:
J.. r.o. s-t-.
rooQ .
d0\\11 ro::i unfltairs,
front
4oor.
ould
wo-::.d thl:t
a s1n
out of the
f'Oruon 1n ~oin
tJt-e7 see you~
out
"'.0L1ldtei.e,., ee .,,ou:·
I c1: · U not see anybo-47 J."'.::oc •;;at. roe:::.
:ou"id yv\l see cuoh
1
A
here
h• ,~flco~
Uo, eir.
1 Y
l
abc t as ,,,,. as no
to ro n1 stair.a.
l2 Yo1>□~,;JI r1Fl,t
ereca. ~ro::i •ta
roo
JOU oa.ci4!)i. d ~
~o. Sir.
Do you
stair
onl:,
,ioom l·:l.
.l
·
ta 1 ell to h1
I ne•,or
mre
tho ! 1rs t time,
'ffllo,t
o
'lfUe re UL
e:,tr=e!
a::111tbe
1
•llow
to ci,.
r
A
I dc.'t
he r.over do1:e 1t.
i! ll:r'. Lue•~.
·e:x,r I 1
cc.
tho
!'d.
~mber ho'l'I mnni d.oora ;;our room ,as f'rc
'!:'ho
QDB~'
A
It
iraa 011 the
left
t ml side
•ite!'e tht)'
et
i~e,
trn.tar.
�•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,,
•
•
•
•
'
'
•
"
'
'
'
•
,,
.•
►
•
\
j
L
�73
and etutf
room betml 11 11 md
mother
w,d
r om Ti er& tbe
1--ondr
e 1
to
ycur
o
I
"hey r,owd
I
oo
l un1r
• up etlliro
u: der ""th
n
1 t ,m
nd ! wn
·no ri
Yo
oir.
on lh
old
• 0
.:r.
Ltt0as •
eor
roorn.
in
o operatin;,
fro
rid
"e o h11rt '//Oll
o
=u:
• left
•
estit
er:11
O ~3
to ye terd
t .-
'1at
>?
~.
·oar:e to
~
ou-
nv( -raa.tton
itb
roo
wtt-h
~thor
one
.vao h:10 •, 1th you l3 .....
errin,c
hold or thB ctoerinp
ou ~n
·r. rtvor.
r n into
hifflet
·ou -- I ha-.-o to1· ot
or
..a iJ.tlet
•
l
an • en
side
hr.nd
art.
Just r ' rred
the 1l!It'ia7
conv raa.· to
OU
in
in room 31,
he
of t.!le bllildin
t be
l!·
i
18 .
ltB.
th
o o er
acros
1 hA11d oido
lllld.,Y ~ollowin
4.iJ.R'""Old
""
"
o e
tl:~
U!ld~T
,-1rht
Ur.
4
, • "" it
y.
11
t !-:1!-ow,· et.be'r
Jiow on
were in
e 1
room th•
Only l ma on
room.
4irty
~ .. ,e
c:,wnrd tr.~
room 1.8.
f!!/l
--
h n t ,!
w!:eel
con on
id yo.;. ha,
011
w ethar
.d +·
t
cr.r lof•
t!o_ li.:e
••
•
Sever
d oJl1
o »~reotion.
0.
ro•hor
ho had two brotl-ora.
he:n
t
Witt
"J:ey ap •U-"0 there
1
Bir.
t didn't
le.
at •ry door.
t et,
AllOW
e nurae broui,ht
ere,-
1! o ep,;ee.red ,~.ere•
~
e r::a
Yo
. Bir.
et'e
oi:
tao
'"be, Ill
! • l,1 I 111 r.ot -:,. 1 var
W"8
Deur.io
nott.er
a+...r.d?
1-Tlf)
n tha~
!Te iB •ho
a.;
i~flet's
irOtbe':"a.
~rot.er
ood.
!!e :itood
::11011he Jlli
or4 to the .... !c!" I woe ntraid.
ow do you foel'"
S!l,'8.
I d't ··,l'
~t
r.
'heTe
t
T
!l
0
I
e&id he
ver caid
ac • wL:i.t tlose
�•
•
•
•
�..' •'
73
'•
•
74
~a llon
...
ttoro
1-Ad aoo,
~
· nd WO'.·.:e4a. .qy
to
o
•~au,..tb&T'!t and he h.us nr,ver upo eJl to 1:10einoo
that
atl.ll
a."t4 ho 1rar.t r1.-bt
b:y ::; Ehor tor
~
Pow lon° )las \h•
t
A
!\b ut •,ro ,eara
a.ny~o,:.
n
Yn1 sr.7 tl;.is
mtll'J
b~en 1n ;;our
barbnr
A. Uo ~
t
~
clon't
A
"'''o
._;r.
I arre-etod
·errinB
him w J tl:.
tee.
booc'
L.:-. Dillu:-~
hna o,;,ver apo4cn
arr• utad n.Lm. llo you kl1ow. a~ a matter
he
a~ ,:e.
shop ~na telJ:ed
cr,·oatod
to 7ou since
o:· -raot.
tl
r.k.
rou
• ..,hie ~
to ;-au•
ir.
;,ou t1ow
11& well
'!:hat this
1114D
hnd ~ Vlll.l'ract
1aaued
a..'""n
UlBt
. t1r.
A :ro,
£.r; l :iou I t kn:), .
II
Oidn' t 70·1 do t le for l:m•
A
uo,
e:1-r.
~id!.:' -t ;ou
A
~
io,
the.
h1'Te
1nl17an "
etr.
Did"\' t you £0 to his
A .:o.
11.! Eor:rt
eir,
bo,,a,. ab -.t dog ta ,.,
I did no1
uhoolutel;;
o tha"e
n-o t doir ta~•
warrcnt ort ~i.r:r ttere~
?
ltc.
l
·e
llrnce
1r. a ,1uot1,~ or th• reaoo.
nows whether
!>!4n't
A Uo. oir.
l served
rou 4~ t-1:at your,elf,
I did
not.
7,,
l!A doee
i-sn.,ync.~ere or 11ot.
:r,4 1ou b1ow 1·?
not serve
�••
•
•
•
•
•
,
�•
,;
•
L::r. Luo.as.
you Cid aeo Luth r :>l:t"flet
e-r
n na
e;, ~ood in
hlneell.
,
l.nd th:ire
ot er u.an.
""o
r.
if:'le
abaoltt
oly
ere
l
,.
oee
t "•
1 •oJ. -
0
?ou
00.
r
1•opet
1n tbA
1
ron
n4 yoc.
r,
aam> to
•
s•
80 •
-c?J. sq
'en a-
we=e .t,.1 b ei:ad.
yo
.
0 errulo
C'~jeot1on.
•
t o
l,im.
in &ll "'these
nolutel;·
'
04,7
e ripl,t
int
a•
b in
&U9C•rately liod.
,id
be 18
ADd t'iat
o
out l nev0r
orr
aa• ~-
you
"feB. 21r.
\
er .
those
felt.
owl
z:o• . itb
l'l!l.
ccoe
ho.a
bout
r.,o
at1ke
erri
d.m
rot
elt"
Shi "let
l'r •
·u.uJ
coc• ius1de.
tho door ""d newr
ow-; u
1-0.
his
ia no q'!.1ast.tou
er,eo,
Ba1
'?
...
w
a
deor""
Yoo. Eir.
\
. !,ucae,
a· cause
on
' 8
,R •
ie1
l;v mi.
--· 0
hCOpi tal.
,~
.. ,
you ..re or.
en thle ~n
OU,
ion.
C
llod
or
0
UC1
Oil
\ny cbil
:;o
er• bat.
woul l~a4
th!l
1
0"""'
0~1
..
h~ ot "d
friJ;Ol;,ten&d.
to
PS..E.=:e Oll t a• he
.atian
'1cvJJ hcon fri~hlenecl.?
:10uliht • t you
eottld
have
:;c
c=•
•
end
tk~ roo
I
l
. or
0
o,110~
01
You :en"W
0
h
a- t
61:i.li.n7fJ
ia
"' th
4
ro lo
r.e
no t
,O!' •
0
0
1n the.~
to t"inl:
for
1n there
thu • y I ""'"' on
llll
1,...ST
•!]a
de:;.
'An
·cu tell
o,,r heo.d -- yo" s bip st
t 1a ;ur-l her•
11 art
t!tn1
:nan, 1111off1oar
ny n vl- i ea e
who is proud of
io
�•
'
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
,
�..
•
•
7!i
•
76
hioeol1' for
were ir. " houo.a surro mdod , ot by one, ·,ut
h l • courape.
by do2,au.s o:t ~ oi,i e,
i:l t , l:.au-+ of the
t.oM'\. you we.. e e.!l"ild
4u
1r
~
ln
~hat
.
I
tr.
:
e!"e
••
-
or hire?
on was ai'rai~
A Yeo, sir,
nr
Wllll
efraid
of him. and ;iou
ld n -
0•
ld hav@ bQnn
01
turn •
i87ft
.:l-s./..A,d
4~
r.
l.r!' 1 t
:.e
iu~aa.
! dou I t aunrose
Don' I ,'!ct l ou-a•iy.
f'I
i=d at
iu not rey ~-a;ne. lt'a
s.·o.. -ftla
o:ff
s a
exoit
le
er o.
wid
.. r:
i l otri
e
f l!o
t;
for
lea.et t 1'1
o. cir.
only or c.ertatn
I h ve not;
t.
oo
'JU•
eions.
t
ol
Ol1
0
•
0,
A
•
rr
rt~
f<
it• '"l•ere
,~
l1ot •le Ollt,
In
llinJ
t
to
.J-;1'
r
r'"in
t
t
to
!7"b8?'0
~
ll!l the
hr
+h
ol
d I
1
WUII
~Ollll.
d
I
01'8
tl-er
l h
4
n!
1'::
··• en-1,
11e
o.r
.,_
OU
ow as 11011 as yo
fro
the
• out with
t.t!d
t)1
is ,,o
for.
~-o
eat
'1
bro ...her.
fll.)'
be , t lJ.
in
i
.
t.
'Id
'h
tl-iat
ho fi
IIJlleS
J· t
u•
• era
he~ WU8
•
+_
•
~l
;voa •es-1!1ed
1
•
r
d
a
t'-o
:Led
)10ll88,
w r:Ant
on
-
•
t
or 11
i; tuiffer ar
tour of ·no
CU?'
liq
.,
~
Ul"1lr.-
'iad a p !1 I <
f•l'
re anil
l!l'
ht
on
,. • o<'
,•t
out
id
tarre.
l
...rr i'l
~
• ., r
a ot '"'eor
a
t
Witre
~h 1.r t}, '
lhi
I c,t took ! 1
1de t
J<I
"·
�'
'
•' •
•
•
•
•
,
�•
1
••
77
..
•
'
co..,Yioted
I...,
~=
1+b r..eor o
it'i
M1 liouo~
3ou let
err1T
an you
~
!)id
\
'lo·
tx
i ven
ont1 t .
a; ,ou testified
asklnr yon to
b!.m
of~
•o.
.,~
...,....... 1::-.a
'lI1
>-J.y
C
_r
.~
,.,ilil""
ll~Ct
1 oi~o•t.
,.,o, air,
~
1 ""r1' .and
•o
ltic"
JITC80t.".l1e
T
IS 4!.dr!'
'-en
;D'<' ,61!',E1::eit
t
to
,Cf1S~
roaccut 1r:p.
n
JCU
d hiz:..
M I:
e
li
uor
7
..
'~"JS
~.•
Yea.
·l r,
~
,_."1
<A
'
d
"
tri'll
,.
•
o -~e4 •iero
OU
t'lAt:
,n• up
,.
~
•
L
·c ttd
11a •
in
l'lOt
..ne'! that
h'lt
Q
h
,
""
I ,Ud rot
-,
~
bout
•
di~ 70'CI co
l'" or ll
at nt,,t.
4 vcn c
II
"1-+on
t
n;, wrrro.r. r·s"'
nt.
t,tu"~'"
on did
Do t yo~ ...,.,ow,-
~.••
1n
ur l:ro+,:•r •
11Hue,- t~a
lrucri
;,ou wa
e-:-o d 'I!
1:• 1.., I in
.. ti,
"her1
!'.
ro r o" ti:
1
llY
UC
0 1 01oc1..
,.•
,.
VO
so.
tn."T
•
'l.-nr
=....
n1 c.-
"'er
o c-
�•
•
.,
•
•
•
•
�•
•
•
•
11
••
''
78
l'o- ar
,.
Bt
•
I
'
a.: •le
i
1:r.
o. air . .:. did ""Ot.
:l14n't
.-:0
..,i)U
t
,...~ 4ri.,.. 11
""'-tt
+
t
1. t
+-
c-,.
c.-
Ir Cut 1,1 "·e :,ard.
Yo,_,,,. :-o'",..":!' C
"c"
~
e•- .
l)o
't
.ia"
•• • I.I!
• -t
,,.,).1r·.
119
•
1.cl.
1 et
a
l
u
l
r
• tt !.n
n
on
~onr
1:,••
oi
rtmr.(n
"
t:-~-.irl: ~ie
•n
., ru.l
'"'}1av
ot At ,.•1~ lie
011
1m ~co.
WIIJI 0
~
!..5 "l.c:;rt.
l
[
r-arr 4
[~.
. .. T)OTtua wel 1
~
'
tt.L
rul
err•
0,
r~
alo~r
,O
•
•r
no!tTer uhot fran~ie.
t
,fl
"""
.
,t
.
t" r---
lder
0'
l,iin ..
t"er
•h
.,
ver oat1~ to'i'r-rde
ls ocat
o. eir.
- .at
,\
I •~over :::-·ot "'1'7.
'l ,Hd
as ;ro
10·1
ever
re•
car,
r.11•,
11•
t an.
IWJ hl
wild-
at !:it:.
I Y'lcver ahot
'I
VA
~
ti:
0
C"l
Cal •
t·
nbontl
OV'Or
•. ·,•e
<'V
r1o1ct to·,.,,;d
ror.-Cile
it!.
~t
other
t al'.
~
r
•
.
Yon ·.u.i
�•
•
..
•
•
•
•
•
•
�••
79
•
r.ner
::n
A Yos.
tl•
5id ftp
t
.:=
.. rt
-
I au
·r hood.
r
C
1.°i'f"8....
j•~"'!>Oi r
ffltl.Jl
ur~,n
a, -stbody
.,. e
no-~ l hi
iu
,
he
'
•c
.t·· -ro.,.e-1..-.
,-o lo.
110 • ~.
~O"lJ"~ t
ad
I
ft.rs•.
;ie
r
I.
#
•
ye-
'Vie
e
r
I
t
t
-
1'!.~
•
tha•
1n
~,
I
"
'Ril1.1r
I tJ.evar
ll>BO
lG
Lu01l . vou ):a'<e
-the3 "i
+
tt.
Uc.
1 ic,:
11 •r10• nn1 his
A
..d
u,
bou.,. ..
o#
tfne+
.
bro ner
• ,nil
ot eo
'
ood.
o !:O', 1
el t,
uo
.d
.e
,""or
n
• 11
n:r
OU
ev
=
, J')C
"
I
eliovo
A
t.t
li-o•
o~re.ted
••• ther~
/t,;.
wer
I
..
e"
11'l"' ':l 0
,. r .er.a
~•
yc-u aur'.!'erL
I Ind~cn
in
-r,..
), • bo1o •
o t",U·d de.:;
r ever
aul'forl
4-;,""
b.lnes
kDiT end 1 w@nt ,aok
on.
nd 1r.
t 'a
<'.teelin., :P"Yl'icc.I l;r •
rl
t
;)
Shiffl
,. t
•
~
'\:re " .
10
-1 I
...
d ••
~!lllit:.
I i::o seve, at1•o>es
-,. tat •
ooa
1rton"C'
fe l 'VO:J ~ood.
t
1-0
~
J1ll'
I •1d no
"'
l:o ooor
'
ere
l
•
ei
Iced
tr in:e1 nnro
et
ffll.8
'" r
1
111
i::uoh.
e i11 to
Lo n.e i:oapitnl
md
�••
"
..
•
•
•
,
�f
..
••
80
•
•t • d
btut
Yea. eir,
O Rational
t
••
t
I
u 1 1 h~ tie<
z-.... Si
·o· 4 I!
~
you
f
8
he ·1-e.
All
did: 't
t;,
O'lt
H'fle'
r:et out
-~.
et
.1, ....
Yo,i
4
1r • I ma rievGr out
,0.
,,::-
at
"·~
0
!l
-."Cl'"
.... •1
!">~..:'fl
,t 1G 1'
. 1~ z
1our t e I inocy
in
oar.
O,f.
.,. '"OOk
"1
t .
1...
'I'
i
It n
""' 111 ""
J~ euit oaeo.
1.o.rJ soen
,
You say 1 L ,,as eott1
•
Yes, e1r
•
You l1 ve lo!'t
~, li:h
j»rs
?ea,
It
•ff
=.,,1rn:.t
,:. •
npr1,ht.
'!o+
oaee •- ~ . .-,11o.n to Day + n!:"
1 t l! you
cnee ~Ba r1 ht in that
( ! d le•\
ben111e
.ne J·U7 on t " L re
saa.o.
i?c
hat
,,e e·11 t
ot linncro;
1r. J:u-s of liquor.
wea o. • 11pe1 u it
cnaa.
•i:e color
c: t4t
t?-aro~
l ;e,
'le11.
o.
p:ot:-,,
t1 li-,
r-j
Bir.
•~t
11 114,.e re· t,
1ore ws
ti
p!enty
~t.
iitb
o:.""
roo.c:.
:curt"o:- t':118 dapo.nen• ::a!tb not.
;,
1.m ir-
he:-o it
8
�.,
•
•
•
•
r
•
•
o1
I
I
..
,!
•
r·
l
, ,.,
•
,
•
'
•
•
I •
"
L
.1
"'
•
•t
•
•
i
,. •
••
"fill,
.,
r
~
•
I
u
•
.,
"•
11
-
"(' "l
~·
'1
•
•
•
"'it.P
"'
I
L
..,
"
•
,
"'
I•
•
..•
~
•
..,
•
•
u
•
• roe
••
.,
0
I
l
.-
'f
0
•
l d •
~,
!u
! ,1
•
•
•
,
•
!1'"!.
I llJ
_J
�..
00
.•
81
D . J. l.
"\~Im-m.
the aerr.n1dnnt , be i:rJ'?-first
oe1
4tJ]Jr &\'Torn. extU.:in ad ~..:, lr.
nr.~1-1 o-=
Hlllrlti'1~r• fl~ -
"?Octcr, ;ou are a TT otic
A Yo~.
"
bi
04
u follo•a:
~
on
n.1Wthor 'Xi tno~a i .....
traduced
i■
=·
"bis
c--!'
1'on be
Ir.
o
ent
Olllll9
to
Der.niB 51:ifi'let.
.r
t"h
who aits
l:B rid,::e at
boo pit al
:i:t•on
ti:.st mor.1
ha,·e
• s~
T10.s1nJur,4
,q.
at•e::ia
ll13 ~"
g~
• did.
I
A
ao"scioua
"'"
l<>l'!.ed o;t
o' lock
obrut
c:::;,the
·Ot!li"l
lt<.
of
to
•
t the time
T e~it
P
1 him he aear1•d • o ..,e in a a~ t-
e any r pl1•a ·
•
•
t.mdsr1:·ood,
for 1nst!r11ae,
yo-c ,e•·er
e· out.
to
or
1• an;~od;
,,-thin"
11:ce
:t
i "'114 !he hollll-
tr.
t.
""e oi:
trae '1e oonscioulJ
Ire
el! uh
"" ~ctod o ,,1~~
I tllin!. eo.
r
ferl
J>rott;• certain
. ..
;;
r . Conra1:
J...
o~ 11..
.4Y 1£:, un•!l
ho left.
1id hi3
�,.
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
•'
•
...I>:
•n1
•
'l
Y a.
11.kUll.
hir
1'om:d h• aid
"•r
,·ea.
•
te
I t"'- u.c1• tbct
"
~im end aea
oo se~
3
mo da; r.e , ut t"ere?
o p,,-ol>~bl }d
•
ia r,osi
w
;01
l\O'<e " ··raoturo
to
o
o,·14
o~: into
a rae1o
re
a fracta:re
J":S
1
'!'I
1,el,1..'I~ t•e
,o\ _ de1roaued fn1otu,-,,,
ir.
I ce " by tl:a• he
A
:. ,,,
! toll\
tr.e
tnk.,,
cs tha X-ray
just
o•
"°'tho
1•.:t
bra.it.
o,a"
tJ-.ro<' little
rou~a ., ·,u ~o-- woula eno
to
111 t!e
a ele~r,.
er.. .,...
to
e~
r.
iicrnped .
t.:.n:.,
1 ""
noocrci!ll
d
i:ot
ell
to .,.- ,·,,oolleotion
..., t"t-er ' ia 4
.n
nn•
a
.
o,re t
oif'l
not.
iJlf rec llod,
J.lii t 18
at
•o
~
os .;o
•o 'I: hi.ID i.
a}.arfe.
Yea. air.
Objeation.
�'
•
•
•
•
•
�•
"
. • 1
ObjoctiCn.
"
or
;rt il"
'lil
.
, .,.,·,aw
~n
l
r'.
.
'
r,-
fT
beo
.. ,
I
l"
'
t J
•::'
'I
""
"d
•n ·o 1,
t'!eae
0
1
e!11,; t <>lJ •if
#
~
tor t
,
,rnr e
•
!tra t~(•ra
~
,-~-
t·'
•o
1V".'
r;
I
lil_'!l,.l"~
hcd.
-. .,..'"er :re
,~y-u· doo=.-.
...r.
0~
to4
O' ~Oct lo,, u ,:t
~,
1
:0·1t1
clii
'
1
T,
0:
"r
•
<
• if
~
·-
•-
=·
:-t
to
,
o~ver
•
'
1~
.
o~ t t' e
ti4
•~ • oo_
ctM!&fi l 'l". Lnc,-s
place
1d t"'e nu.r~~.
:r. ,;,111 1 r1 .nn.n
era
1
t
1
e,adi of the
d
r
•
•
Di
l
he
y u r~
0
("I;
Yen.
.,!t..er
1
·-
~--.
Yes,
i
at.
.,,, '
\
your ~o
'!.
'
t
roou. en: wht.t
C
C
r.ar:
I' ~jeot
"'r . Dill'lT •
to
,.. t.
OoJ o· ton ov r1-- lod •
.,
'!'hey ~hat'
cve4
e
r; ta1.re.
en
V.:JnTrere rno,;~d ur,rtairu·;
fJ
c,
1' 1.
-~rr~d?
.,..rvor., n!'lttl
;h .. I l' CJ. , h~o ,J in th•
·~. "
" •·e
T.
"Jil"ar
111
~c:
,,,,,,
.
�•'
\
•
•
•
•
�•
••
.,.
'
il<.•
..
,·ow th~ r ·· 00
Q
at
t"" c~ri hAd c
these
ibat'a
Cl
0
A
to •
t:. ort
t•"l
for your bein~ o:oved upataira
l!lll
tl:ere
h~ : ot
l"oo
l-..)". "" ·•a
Other
he
reaaon~
l'
DOMWfl8 o.1.1 r1 ht.
o .sceTta1n
these
to ;ci.r
'"""
I U:"898
i .. R
tlll
to r..nkt
0
c=
0
t•
OU"
en.
Ile. c1r.
You have be
lly i;..
(!
A
E'au:isr:
,·.e:1 'e~e J·ou at ·ne lour
1'hen
Ii Yes.
B l'
Bi!"'•
A I don' t ..::no,1."'r.
tri
Pa.'ll!llor, I thl.nlc it
n
,.,)so i .. wue 't since
A
I :zde
I a, ed lier.
1 er cot.
"
buoh l1ll inveat1~t1on'
tho other
•te investisntion.
I don't
:=t
ut I think
"!c,;. ;cl4
w o uefore
ttis.l.
'he 1
rmces:iber wether
~11
told
y l:no1'1! :uat
1 t ~""
the other
otore
..,.
ox:wtl
:o -
11110:1
I h• ~tbor
the 1 dr .:nows.
J.:r. Conrt:4 a1.n o •be otl:er
trllll.
.J1c1 70
aa
he
,, 1 nurno"'.
h& lJ. t tle
l&dy.
.,
�j
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
�•
11oxt ~a,?
o-r the
JI
in
1 tl,iru:
wi,e,
it
•h coru1r .
r.
l won't
DQl.'
. r.
"
I th1Th
ovcd 111 •1,~r&
'W.'18
ponitiv•.
hintlte
es t1'e au•
1
oa; •
I !en' t
~e
no
r nlly
noxt
~
,y
or ot.
ooks o-~ tbero wo~ld ehow.
•
peo le
)'011 IU.o,r it
lfow don••
oro,..:,4 in tbe "'o F 1
4
u . ctts
..
7
':
o.
t ·o 'lo o
~lU'
•tll
ou
rou
•
t~.e r,-owd
'l'il,;,
I '11:lllte t~ b
ec >lo
floor,
a.~ I clid.: ,.
tire.
n.,; J,
~cw
'1111Dl)C'" •
r
101
n!ll'vat:s am would aaroau
aix,
out
1 '-t'
ll•
14 not .
I
' • JaC >enc-.
,., l>
A
I wil
aro nd. r~ero all
• pl:.;
'1.'8l'O TC'r7
A.
1~
7e11 tor
not aal1n
l 51d not
\n arJ
1e
l! yo~ ~111 allow.,.,
I
yo--
ti,
T.1.ether It ~•
!Lero :c, roo
~
•
ot
.114
,~
""• any ""rp at •J,o baoA c:id o• tl.e ~OIIJli till
...-no.
eliver,1
A I do 't
W!I
ens '1 olt thoro•
DO'fi ~e "'-or ttero
wu.o c:-; dolJvcr~· Vi'tl.l'ouc
• •
conld n, t eeo out .
c •·a r•111,t11 lll'o•u,d bet1n,l
t'
Ye mac
~
l 'hoer.I oo:r~
llt
ll
t 1, en
tl:.e-re J ilcewiee"
I don't
?W
4' , H"mmor,
tb
J:oc it l'
nd ''he r.urae lt:nom:.
l:n Mn.rd
�•
•
•
•
•
�..••'
'•
Bi,
•
'
•
•
g. AD n Cl9ttPr o~ ~not.
you -were in n very 110-ryouo exo1ta1.,le
oond !tion'
'aol
A
I dcn't
var;
oafe.
~a
.no11l'r. 1 =· r.
,1•n
I\
y
""l-;J:.
t 'ho ttns
,ou au
a
~-n bao'
3C:- ltr• et.
e tc tbe
1--1 the
..., o l-osp1t&J.
'"!ber 1·1 1111r1inG. now.
A
"lo: 1
•o
O
jur:,
b
:1(1 •
tho left
•
eido
!U2t
e;.i
fro~
1
q
d
Oto 71•!
r.
ri t~l"
he.. roe-
~
oec.q,ied
on tl.o ?'if ht h.mlS :31iJo.
~he wst
on thP aaet
a!de
s1ile crf
or
aeon
1n
t-roo~ -
l-root.
l did know tl:.o nu:!Jber, but, c.m't.reo-1"·
htna
11,le or r1 ht hr.nd e110•
1 bt l-:"-nd oide as JOI!
' -.th
eaat ed.
!10\,
n ~o !'ho l-o
t!l
n Yo entnr the ~otoi•nl
1
nt
8 •
•
~
cc
Ter,
n. e
• Ir
• D:!-'J..arl, I •mdo!"atc>d
the 'll'"'T in
foel
~t
T ~•l 1 you.
r•~er t~1e 4e·oMnt
. .,• .
I 414
of Us
l:nl 1'
o oa<:l:.
it
�'
•
�•
"
\
67
t'rstatro
er cloc;r.'
:'lo1•,n, nn~ ll\ter
up.
roo::i on ..he seco
enn-nn.:• ltien 10
Lenee u tat~
roo
oooup1ei
c ::i
"t"voc1""rom
1n on
00::
0
..
,.
to
cl:
o,
"" :roon i!?
h1e'1
tr&et
:r.
co
......
Luo_c3 na ....
..ir.
L. ot o-r wo.rds.
r ..... nu • tro
door
fr
liS'
0,
Bir,
uch
r!)~r 00111d ne-t b
o.
•
aa
secno:
lr.
02
_,,,1_
7 • at t·
1■
:r
t:ror of t ht1
,,
" , lt'I
y ,. o ,atr~n
t. l
.:om= "-~ere'
•· at bnil~.i.Jli,'/'
A Yea, air, he~..,,.
r oa.n' t &GY ~. ti::.cc...s.,,. ne:rYi,us or exc1t11bl,.
o: oo-urso. t.:i. ,easiness~
Q
old.J'
Altd of a 111 l t h~ 1<oul•~ l"J
~~
tr.er
r-e felt
�••
•
•
�..•'
87
'
A
,...,.e
I don't
}OW about
that,~
trou ot tht! 1.;.oe i +-sl ae
~a.
to be -:-.a...,..ersorr1e4
...!tr elf
he oe r.. t1 4 0
I
A.
ot':i~r
l C lD 1 •
,a, ·'
2!1
s exc1to4 ·
► t..1i-
�"
'
•
�'
'
"
••
•
, ..,
111
~o .o~ - t
...;,.,,,.r-...._.<.L;i
./2C.._1---:I
~
r
I
0
e·
•
•
.,..
♦
•'
led
1
t lo
itlo:c
d
erlio•
e
J)l°
,.
,,
1
•o
t
•1.r,:-.
z.
u
•
io
:fir at
ill
oil.
d
ae
l' rt
~-
t oo .J'l ine~
d evi
nd
o!.
of
0
it
...c~r
COW'
tto~
1
-·
b
1
t 1
(U
••
e
•n
I
•.'"I
,.
r 1_
nd
e
l
0
def
i
# ...., 19
ved tt:""
ri!
lb
C
l.
&Sid
1 •
~-
t
t:
1
in en
C&
of • be jary.
0
I
co~t=
nrr-- ·ed. t
1
,.
'1
r4tc•
V
I;:
i
defe::d sn I • b
ti
on
1'
..
r
ot
r
r
C
llo
r
there-u on. tb
~1~
a
z.
•
I
'lnd
of o
ac··
I",
i
ro
- ... 0 .. t·
.,
1}
t
'
J-,,..«---A-.,
( .AG......1-:#,IJ,,"~ t,.q t ....~~.....J, ._1,_.~
.1
0
i
ev:!d .. ·
.I
C<ll'di
"3'" ro
,.
)
�•
�..'
,•.
n1
..,..u:c1:acm::x,oq .. or ,ocill!r...X ol'licY
!l:l I" RX"!l.!Bt::u:D tbat
inQ the ,,-c,dootion
n~o:i th~ trl'll
o!' the ;oa11mon1
or tbia
act forth
1s: ~111 of
da a i,art
to!'ne:,
tor t~e
~ocrr.orn,u~ltl propourn104 to ite
o·"tfenbaa:-:.er the
•1th
t'ollow1!1f'
in rofcronc,
hir
il:~
tb
,her-o telitill('
:'"luence
o=liquor
•aUillF
al,out
ntr.
r
tUl.:ler)'
..,~nt
--
i!lad"?'"ir:.ei •le.
of •ho
:o-,xt
t'hL.:h
C_. ':t~trtionB
._ psrt
]__
;-d
,
llO,
f
t~co.
day
o~ ~,
=•
c
of.
bccJ: of ~ r,-laco --
llCJ~g +t.ero
--
certo.1n
'Well.
r~ot1on th• rio~t
e11
aeverul
--
of ua at~od-
.1nt..1t.e iot
into
be:f'oco I \Klt!ld be t-,.:en
d
0
OTDrrnlad,
r.otlon
oxaoptod.
d in t• 1
1 ined
to whic,;h t~e wit:l:e:1t1
0
2. Jl10l" lCI 81
191:4,
q,&~ ti.mo tl'·e ce.r
'1t')1'ml:.1nt moved to stl" 1~
tor
dunt
lt-
441,th. "'
Lt ovoTniltr•
a i4 'lllO\is= tho de•
leto:"
and l th ul_'ht h• waa u.nder tt•
ind 110 n1d.
I wo·,11 uuffer
li•uor
•
I do :n1t kuow for
11quoT,
the
wltr.or-s ""-enjarti"
'lsot-e~"
a d I he ra1lro&1
liquor
·ihcrt?'l.q;:on eonncol
s3
u.a we1·•·1
hereo::.
.XCJopticns
"l>id you huv-e any c0nvi::ir.Ja;1on
-r.
o.nJ 1Dju1•11d
·•·,~es: several.
: 1.iVf) •;atl'IOer
lon;
to tco0lJS1-1ne al:.ortly
ran ,..,.~, the u'butr:ont
r~nlied.:
Q.UMSt
..r-~ d"1"-
""use
nd ref·l1llnl"
n!
!)r 7s tr..&t
out
to Pi
""~..;ans,rer
,i
~o etrt::o
tt1e.
'11
ai,:tio1_
ont
!il
d, oo~lod llDd e:,rolJ.L!d nd ~ale
It.JO ,
1 b 1e n~>ordi
l;: done t· i!I
�.
-
I
•
'l
•
•
' .
•
�'I
'
•t
'
I
•'
••
-
'
'
'
•
•
•
~-
-
�-•
�••
'
•
••
...
'
•
•
~m:""'"!:
33 I,
that
at the
:una ter::i,
Cou.rt of tloc.~1n ...J1i'.m Co~:1t_-, Y1rgi::ua.
tho body
or
sa1d coi;.n-cy, returne
one llenn1a Shtnet,,
in tne ,or;s
1923,
'th.e gr ...~d Juri,rs.
the
:'.:ollowing
or tho Cirou1t
1:l &nt .or
indiotcent
!lgn1nE t
and C:1guree !ollo111n_;:
"~he srcnd !ury in ~nd ~or tho body or aeid oount;
upon their
tho 19th
cert
onths
do present
dry o~ Llny, 19£3,
ir
k.rd
ll1ve:r,
e.t ~¥ton,
lune.s.
than
Md
V1:.glnia,
t•4 ~o wt'tb.dri.D
BLtd plea.
b. Coune:l,
ot tbo ::a::r.onwealtb,
S, Iuoaa
thereiin,
ar.16 c.'--:.rO!'f of
hill:,
ti.a
d1er.ble
aua "·
&m:! kill,
01 "11:rgtnla, •
and pl•~
on 1t.ot1on ot t..ia Counsel,
o.ceor!tn
"Jot
a .er=1t-
• d'o!le; une. tt. r i.,..on,
1.ndiotlr.en~
•le:.._ th•
on tl:e ;:ro
4
CLccu.ee:l die! -.n., a.ct •bl.ab
1D!""L-Yt:e .• ~. z-.;.ce..a, o:
b!.c.O ut.:taG..
41aabl.14,
de•eo1.:..-e ant l!l:ou:t be ,r,uieh~t.
:"here-,,;=1onthe Co-..l.rt snstcin'ld
rollooe,
11,
boon a:rra1i;ned
4t=urred :o ectd
1! 1:11!, e.nd 1a !&Wly
or:ornt1n,- a
oroae1.ug: tl1a st ne!ld oi:JJ
~1tl: lll"ent
•h!.eh
no: cb.a:-re. or a::1-,,;a,
a::tounto.4 to peruona.1
0.1
..'.fl rift
_,J<.t 41d ~rive
briabe
-~• eeouti&d havint
gu:11!.J," St',a.e.re" 1.n CJU.rt, {ad,
or kill
,,tile
~Ottnt.y,
tc c:a1a. d1s!1,,;.1re,
i.tera
on or about
tl;o pe ,e e ,md digni t.r of t • co..,.onr.oalth
':lloreuron
the.:t ..:.t !
in ~nid
s.nd of rJC_loe afo.rethov
an 1lbutxn nt a~ !"DSOhing the
the a.c,aae!,
Dannie Sbi!'lott
tou.ri~r.: ea..r, With 4•puty
telonionPl:,
asi,tnat
th~t
ot
b;r 1-ta !Ltt:o!'!lc:,
BB.id ae:i:ur:-&r.
ren..itted
e.n.4 OA notion
the &Lid 1:-.4.1~tl:2tnt
�'•
•
-
•
•
•
�'?'he g:-::.nd
'=
--
f. --
t:,
end f~.
t .o
Rooktn"'htz! ar.d no-:. e.- 1,:1"!n; aci~
ir o-t
o d:o . ree~nt
t ~--
ti
ie
t:, o!
or ,1:-1 · c~
·u.n t
Oourt &t tie
4
U:"on t.
•~
on or
.. l:.L1a'tt
1 , ...z.
.r=i:,
or t
~- Luota
feloru.otely
9..'>dof ce.11oe a.forotl:.ou;ht
of n bi;;J-, ab-Jt~'1t
nt n~-ton,
bro :king
,.
"'r•olUni; tho as11 <utoriobile
thoreb;;
tbo log and otherwieo
'111th 1ote:1t
d1efiguro,
~11 or ~hioh
b1m, t!:e
disable
e<,id o,sr o!:f
o~ c brid ·• oro sin;, t~e Shensndo&h ~ivtr,
71rc1n1a,
~- Lucas,
f1d drive
tbere1n,
6oing
bodtl;
Lucas.
.es.11' , • -·
agunet
&.nd .till,
o the s id
1n:ur;v
wae .;one b;; the eaid
;,ent!a
3hiflett
then and thare
tr,e
and
to u.D.1c,
!'•~•~
an<! ~1gn1t;v
or tho
Oo.. r ,on11ee.lth of ...
fir g1:o1a."
To 'l'l)ltoh action
Pont t
b
~
eaid objaotion,
aotlon
~ended tte
of tho cou~t
def~nd:.nt
and p_enaitted
in pett11t,1ng
objeote•,
~ut tb
part
or t_
.J 1oh
&r.d por::.1 ttine
ellitl
s&1d ''""'"'""
o-r ..xc111>tton ,:w.y bo ai~'Ded,
rooord
o• t is J-eo,
or c e! 4
seelod
s,d
pry
.nc, enrolled
ll'h_o,. 1, ac~ordic
t!e7 or 3-!_"t.a::b&r, 1"3::3. and within~
ord r
o~er-r,,lo6
,
ac,.end'aor.t, t1Je na~'".l ed. b:, '::otUlE:;l. o;i:ee. ted,
ill
Court
1nd1ot-
ea1d emon<llllor.t to be innce; to
o~ tl:e Co-.i~t 1n o,,-erruling
hie
tl:.e e~id
t et t.Ja
en·
ly done, t
e
a
.Ji.L'l!
C.i...:s~roo the d.Elta o.,. · ....e
co !"t • sr:.1 tt:i!lS all.!tl k'::.endl..:. t.
�•I
•
•
"
.,
•
'
-
-
•
•
•
....
•
•
�•
lB 'l'llll OlRClllIT COtl!!'l' OP !':Oill:IllGHAli C0l!ll7Y
COl:.'ll?llaUT!l
•
V3.
DllDl"lS Slil7i'L~'l'
a:: Ir a l!.::lO:.::-!::ll, that
wealth
to i:ialntail'I
lucan,
"110 beill;i
t1,e 1aall8
4ulJ, e110rn,
Dil-got
"}'On u,e trinl
1n aJ,id,
Ear=.
b:, la.
f.. Ltloae.
t',
Q
!!ow old are :,ou,
A
:?1.rty-one
Q
ffllere ilo Jou 11.,., !
A
,lkton.
You wre
!;:-. L"IIOB:J'?
:,elll'S olil,
n deputy ehor1!f
for I'loakin@balil Couuty durl.nf'
A Yoo, el:r.
il llow lona ,r.ere :,·ou de pnty ehar iff?
'
Sevon or eiO,t
l)o
years.
you Know the acouee
here,
.. 1.
Ten, eir,
Q
l!ow lonA hcrve 1ou knov.n h:lm.,
A l:no'f'ed of him about
t110
t>ennia Sl:i!flet
or three
~
:,ears.
2 Where does ho live?
A llo 414 lift
uoutl, of Elkton.
,
At the t~
\
South or Sllcton.
~
!!ow far!
.l
.l c.11• end uven
Q
In
of th1a ori!.la,
te11tto froa
lbth
t1i,
dB)' of DI:,, 19-r
tho bridg•.
oct I.!! rum Ccmlt7?
A rea.
Q
l':ro:t '111:lat'tri~•!
.l
!he River
Q
no
bridf"I,
Sheulllldoch llver?
•
A Yc.e_ sir,
Q
17,B,
MM~
A
A
co-n-
•• tollon:
teatitie4
OXll"1iml tion
II l'bat 1a :;•our
;part, lntrocmoe4
its
llJ'OD
of tt.1e cA118etl:e
Did
JOU,
...,.,
Luoaa.
lllT8llt
i.r.
Slli!!lot
011 9.
aharro
l9t3f
�•
•
�•
•
'•
'
•
•.
B. Lt/0,\S. a ~1\nosa
""in
C'o-::inoxrnaltb.
~
c!·•l. eworn.
'ire
n1reot
iutroduoea
·1,e
"01101111:
4eposes
c. l'r.
~xacilJA tion
on \Johnl:I' of
:ar,::an.
Wbat ia 10m: naine '>
1 • .....
tuou.
•ow old ar• you, r. Luoaet
~
'lfty-one
;,ears
old.
-1 W1arc to you l1ve
'-
0
Jlkton.
"ou ...,,-, 11 deput:,
ti • year
aherit!'
or •.ockln
b~"2 ~ount7 dDJ'lJ>t
191;3.
f.
Yen. air.
Q
llo·• lonf< ,i,re ;ott 6eput:, nhor~f•
A
ieven or ai<tht yearn.
Q
.to TOU lc:io the acousod hero.
t,.
Yee, oir.
Q
Bow lon11 have you k.no,n him~
.l
nio•d
Q
Whero dooo he 11-..~
~
re
Q
At t1:e til:!o of thin
A
South
or bi?I ab u
did live
eonth
•w
lle!!niff
Sl:ifflot·
or thl-oa :,care.
of ~llton.
crill'"'.
•ha
1eth
ia;; or
a:,. 19::3·
ot 1kton.
l"o• far?
A A .rile
e.nd aovan
It In ?.oakin~ham
tontha
Colltlt;,
t
Yoo.
~
" ·0111wl• t Bria...., Y
A The iv1r
from
the l>r 1df8.
0
1rid10.
Q Tl:D Shonnnd 11b River?
A Yea. sir.
l)1d rot1.
:r.
Luo a.
arraat
/.,
:r. Shifflet
on•
aharr•
�'
••
•
\
�I
••
•
I oould not mennuro ~'ODt exnotly
•
about
ton too1 trori
oar :r1ret
tt&
"" It
1,0,. tar,
tut
it 11$8
::2 or t:S 1'oet tro"'
tho bo.nlc, and about
where
}.e l'l"0Ul14.
1,1t
'WC.O obout
3:? or 33 feet
t:1:ieabut ant.
froo
Yaa, etr.
l)eaal" 11•• to !co lnr:,
lefi
11,e abntc.nt
tho cor JU111..,ont rirht
i:liau ha
over in t,.,e r1wr.
"'ho baa'lr o·
thc, bridpo
at b1lll ~itb
J:,;J
hill ant
ta.:en
mm tho first
ot b!o out,
buu;;
ud
out
ot be.
,;be
11
w.. o on.
i;y
"°'
., went ri
..nd
to ret
ar.4 held
hm
up
04J' 611d tr.
I oallo
na 'l:D ta:,,,,).old of
ho b~lEonce or tht1 onr~1na,
ana "tben :ber
Tho,· tn :en hil'I on to lrarrioonburs
ru1d tho:,
Jlono, And then I oame to tll• tno)litr.l.
J:llJ
~"'" the
oar in whon 11 finllll.7
:Wnded in
tl:o ""torT
~
over.
It no
on 1te r.heelc.
"nat
('Ile or tho 11 ;bta wus burmr.r,.
tton-e it •a.a at1ll
bl:rnin~.
ot it.
loft
It
111111 tho
Fo• doep
t
Q
•·
11 atarted
Lou4~~bei ·h
I taken
IIJl'•lt".
h<lm 11 ht.
aa
he
ater~
<!?hot."ltor wa.a about ---
iihore I wau a1atod :·
Yeo.
A It won eoout
~111,1 "'"'
A
I eeen that
R,c:,e au ootoro
l'!hon
•bout
,bout 3:30.
~bout S::',()?
A Yeo. air.
--
I •A'P80t four
·
•nd
nro,md
l tried
111;0.
10 ca.
it hit
lft(l waa faot
I ronchod
rnrFling
ro m.nntea.
1
n · it
orth 11.nl the !"ro11t
·ot bi.,, Ir:, tho collar
..,,.
I! m,,,t pooltion
•
aorta
haa!II Mf. I
out o• tho wutar :ror 2li or
!.0t2deroaoh
hr car
My hand ""'o fast.
l oonld hoar
■ 17
on tl,e
dot:n tt.a tO}l an
aud tho ourtait10
•ua broke.
at' knife.
co=
ovor.
tree and it cnohea rirht
I tho1truit it
the car
tl:!!t c:orni?lf.
Hi• oranlc aaao
the locust
rot
ha)lp0ned r.fter
A. Aa 11111111:1 l could reoall
rool:, =a
towards
)118t •hAt
or flv~
f••t
TJho.t tic:e in tho a:ornini;'·
deep.
ot
1>otice
�•'
•••
•
,
�5
111ro you eonso1ou•
all
t,.,,.,
the
Yon, eir,
•"" • all
that
haJl])ene4 •
A Y•n•
1 Dia yon ahout orAltol~• ·t•a, eir.
to
L:r.
that
1
rmminP.,
and
in lllY cr1Bt,
lot
stitoloea
30VOIJ
o
lh& t.
t in Jur7,
if eny.
yo-:,
1n o tho r1vor.
pltm·e
I ha-1
ltlco
Tho jur;,
ot a aal:l))oUllO fracture
I
aoi:,e.
wat nr be!"or• roacuo4"
samthin
&tat<> to
).llCll8,
:.r. Loud•rbaot,
o.rul
1011 'tfflro yo,~ L.,_ the
30 or 3~ ~1nuten
A
rooo1ved
1 hollc•d
• t b• l•r, •n4
1n n;y hc~d,
ut
1,lnro 1n ,r,y
eek -- out
throu
it
1L otill
a piece
a:!' iron
h 1111oo<>t.
·ero :yon tn:-en tc the hoap1 tel•
A
Yee. lllr.
llow long
on \here?
ere
A 2t or 3 ,..e'c11.
"
T bol1eve
I then wnt
1'.omo11n400:00 br.ol: "f-in,
to c;,,t uoQl!4
you ar" unable
10w
except b:;
u,e uso of o,-utol,en.
A
T oim wnlk •1th
one orutoh
o, tho floor.
bnt outside
I hAvo to u:i• two.
lb.-. tuoan.
form,
did you do bnytb.Lu
to cr.1110 'b1ttlet
ro.
eir.
or
t~e abut,..,tt~
-t
b1c ooll41tiou
1"1111will:.
~o
reference
dr;mlc or co er'
A
I tboueht
ovor
OILZ'off
llbt!'o
I 11&4no tille.
Do i,-ou 1:1,o•
bo1n
that
to dritt
1n llllY -,i.y.
I anol1
1r tie oo\lld
too mountain
'
south
of
tba.t
io?
be licuor,
drivo
but
over
-- ho oould
T eo11l~ 1).(lt toll
he 1110tu•ta1n fro,o
driY& 1Je
'i'hlo "ut 1B ho11oa at which
r ton.
whare it
i=ona
..na.
r.11p ,-
o 'ArtiooHuurg.
·ou nrreai:ed 11m ie located
Oon :,011 4eeor1ba a little
a,ore 4of1n1toly
wl'.ere
�•,,'
•
•
•
•
�•
•
••
'
••
A
o~ !loc .. lngro,n a Id ll<!w., tt 01,dtng so.ld Conr1. i.t
t .tlr 61.W!e do prldaent
19G.. , 111 01
4
:-r aboa.t t!:o lC.1 •l dn.;; ;;1 ·~.
t..;t. t.
19.,. .. , t
,,,.,erst.LLB - c-arto.a.» Yori!. t.ou=lne
;:.11r.
:>aJ
&ill
1 ts
1D
June
Sh ff'lott
lllll1 «.111, ~lrltit
~OClll.,(.wualt
of
...t.•11
7r.!> ,,;,,ice
wi1. b Do ~,
i,llll
61
w
8
rounl
th
ou
• ;
er f!
d.l af'
af' tne
'/11 glnllL
•1.aot:-2!t
t-Orc.,
..!oo.ut,,.., Whllu
Lo :GI
iileal)la,
•
'
t BL lea, 'I !
1.
1re •
�w.... A.,
-~
1 ~t~
--
,,t.,, -~
~ -:-' ......,..~
~ t._~
/,-J/.
t4
~ ~ li~
~...,_~
+-;~tt--.e.
LP-«/,. • ._.........,,rt,,~
4 ~ ....
,..e.,~--r
/....,. ' ~ -~
,-
7~.
'"-'-
"4..~
c;.r- ~ ~....;
,~
<A,
<!((,: lt.'a-4
~
<},,..,..,
....
,,__..._
•
"'
a,;
C•
I
:q
:_;;
'
'
..
...
.,
""
,-"'
•
I
ci>
>
...
•
'
•
•
•
c:;
u
''
<
"' •
.,,
"J
t1
•r
.
<
0
µ
0
•
0
t
,c-
r'
.
.'
'''-
",,
•
,..
~
�••
•
\
~~ tbl.8 heiq;
,h~ ~o
tlieu,
e.U t'.~• ortt.er::oe intro<l11oeJ o,i ba!:Jll:f
on 11111th~nd on b<•hal:." o! the ~,fe,1amt,
thr-
foz d,1terziin
.·,.tm-nea
cd'•c·
OIUIO,
into
t1on,
'ou:rt
lll'IJUO():lt
1t'
Md therl'U• on, tto
11111,10\J,,
JOU11!10l,
on,;\ :be !·tty lnT!ng
t't,e !'ollo1'1~
( "lire
to set
"·
1.naert
4D:t'endant,
tc
o, ?rMll.n,
3eale4
-
o-nott:,e
'b7 OOt!JU>fll, cow a the Jou.rt
Til~•di<lt GB o<>ntre:.-;• tc tl,e law LnG e,·idonoe,
nnid
t-1s,
•nil enrollod
do e thl11
att8r
to tbe
'l'erdlot:
,otion
notion
of Lhe Court
to set 111.11ide
or.tu \'Ordiot
1'11: !'1.r.:t
do. o~ • y, 192',
'b
111 or £,:oapticllln
&J:4 Dlt.8 a :put
rw contrsr ,·
:t,ldrtuJut 11• o.ocordano-,
<-1~ the 1'111'01ct o:r t?>.e t,::ry, tho d~end:wt,
tlu.t
m,1,Ql.tto~
ot
v.rdlot)
!>e lllw Wld ttV1411noocn4 ir. eutorin;:'
anll p-=
Cl"!' eitm:,-
rot:ll'e~,
'l:lab m·otio11 , " Court O'IOt-rJ.led, to ,.i,ioh
1n
w,ia
or
CCIUll&Cl,l!SCIIIte
ca;, lte a1,_,:a4,
ot t?:.lt:, 11!::t.. is l'iCoordlngl;;
cna 1!'1et1n nixt;r Oey11 frol!! tho
juv
�•
•
•
\
•
�t
.,
\
C 0Mli01."IIEAL
Ttl
v.
tharce
lf you .r1nd tile a.c:::uee-d, ;)ennis
will
:;niftlett,
then ycu
nO't guilty,
ao u.00 no more •
$&J
.}~
t ln6 him guilty
charged
ment
JW:1•
to the
in
of mallcio,,aly
th& indictment.
'by ;oafine.1.111,u
in
it>Jur Ing •
then you will
1.he 9enl tentio.ry
soy on
tHtcl
r or a period
w. i;.
fix
Lu:ao
bis
or not
punish-
les1J
than one ye1J.t nor more 1.hcm ten yea.rs.
If
yo~ do nol
gutlty
Luc,.n,but
lndl:::t.a.eot
I
conr1nement
ot unlawfully
then you will
not
Hunolred
Dollar••
If
s~id
ex:cedi:ig
punlohnieot
twel•e
say so and. asc.ertU.,tn
su::b
.fine
or,
111
your
&
fine
1n jail
not
ieapr isoru:s.:r:t.
injuring
hto
or
ny
\h~n one
Oy ;onfine(ri.ent
nol exceedi1g
Lhe felonies
you will
.for a period
exceedi"!'lg
lhe
punisT.lent
d.i1cretion,
then
a:.id
cha<sed in
or not less
of e1 ther
and battery,
't>y :onrtnei::ient
and
ior a period
h1rn guilty
or ueBault
mon.tc1s or by
him"*
t\loel..,e monlhts and a fine
you do no• find
b1.Jt guilty
of malictouoly
in,Jurin,;
in t~e pe~itentiary
in jail
both
hi.Jo guilty
no.r more t.han .nve years.
year
hie
find
!'1Ve
afore-
en.y so and !1.x
not e.xt:eeding
.Jive HunJred
:,ollars,
ot-
�•
•'
•
•
•
•
�•
•
•
'•
•
Co111mon,vcalthof Virginia, l T
Rockingha111County.J
..
o-,vit .
•~
<J
•
u>•
.-f..t__
£~ __::___
QA___§,1J4.__-1(~
- - 1.i~:J.- -·-·-·
~J
!}-_({
..fo_Lr __
{
,.----~~
--,.----,.-- ,-
iu l ,. "llW ot
' , .... /
. . ________ l)ull,m-
"
•
11
wmp(1n._•lc>C:wlu·d
1'n1m lit•• lo11wl-111rlhi"' !-..lfllil, lo lbt• 11;:;,,
c,f Lb+o<\111u,1o1111,,·
11th ,,t \·ir~iui.1 if lb,· .:..ni.
(),
·ubihli
~ ~v
_w.
I I · 1"1
llb.J,·rwritl« ,
,-,,,•,.~--niun,,· 1.-. :i--u.·hthat if •b.-. nho,
•
U:.r--1,
t-£,,
-:-_:-.,
-/ l f , .. •U
•l!t ,~,;q;m
,
"-'
~\
t......
l'nun-huu.:,,•
,11111llw11 auul Lht!h a!Us\\i'r
1,f th.- ~,id ___A2f_Lf_ _
th•
I ·u111111t,1n\t•itlll1•>f \' ir:tiuiu ,.,m,•, rui11!.!;
n t•,•it.1i11_{t~
r.J \ I
7
-
~
I'! /
c;
Y4•tc-G',
L-!~/-----Wlwn•-
•11111,ll'I
t'lm1•g••11,111111
...boll nn1
,
_.J..__
�•
•
•
•
-
-
�•
,.
\
•• •
\
•
t••'l\l1J,I\J
•
•
I
\1.111 CII• \IIH,l'I\.
lffk 1,.1,1,fl\\l
.......)
111l~J'I
•
h1 .rp,>c"Jr.mJ ,-..;\l'
i·\
ill cul''-"10 b, hulf ,,f tlw f'ommoO\\\'~lllh, un thl."c\ ,\nnn,11ion10,•~hin:!1h,· ...1iJ off\'m t·.
l<f
�•
••
•
•
�•
••
f/11111. ,111 //If'/•,,,..
1//J( /\/.\fl/I
I)/ l'//f'ST).
1;111'/'1'/\1,,,
•
It' be 1.,
f'I
'
111
th,, IVY
. \'l'Ol'
'
of
�•
••
I
•
•
111\1\l<•S\I f:.\l,Tll
'.
•
'
"
.....
ft~/(1,,lJu
..J..,.
~-
•
~?'
-
i;_
"'
{
~
~
•
�In the Name of rhc Commonwculth
of Virginia:
io tbl' Sheriff ~f Kut-kinRhant
,rrull/,,
/'/trl,if1JJ,
11f!,r11~I
©-&,.-,-..-·"I,._~
• -!:'-4-,~
. ,,,,,,,.,,, ,-.,,;-,
~--<j
.1, •• ,1 ~
,.,._, 11,,,., ,,.,.
rtl
n11t
mt-d r
,1,,.,~•flrt!J
.,( J;/OtJ
N n~
fV;,,,.,..., I, ,1- JJl-tCA'lllR,\~,
,, 1/f
C..tllll'll)', G1"ff1:na:
.......
~ ,_A-
fl.-rl.
,~,Jz.1,,,,,,
II/
/
,r
;frf
ti,
l,f
r ,,,Y"'•r,;/
('
,,,.., ....
fY,~f..--
,
lhl
,,,.
nu,,.,
Jlm,u,
(:'i,,,1111 ,,..,.,,,,,,;,
th,
�;/.i/3~
I "
,-_p~-<,..r.,,~r
�lo the N!1me of rhc Commonwoahh
•
"t.; /
/-.,,cit
, ~e
,<.
•tfn(
U,,~
lr';l,,r~,,,
of Virginia:
1,111 ,.,,,
,II..,,,.,
/.J,,f,,ut,u,1
.., #lu Jll'IM1u, 1,f l'IOO
.,,.,.
lt,UV' ll1tn.
l► 'r,I.
lltl•
,I
1•. /J/,.l(Jh-Ht
/f,,\·. l'ln•A /J/
, 111ul,,;
1111r
vHd
(',.ur/,
ol flt,
t'i,url
lliuo,,
/Ju
1/,,.llf
, ('frrk.
��-
In tbo Name of the Commonwcnlth
of Virgin in:
To 1he Sh~f
1, ,,pr
.tt'
fp,J',11 I/tr. ,/u.i/ff
r,f ,,..,. ('it,wd
l"ourl
u( J<o,c;ldu1Cl111m
C•1~n1y, Grcdin,:i
r,[ I',w,!,.i'i•th,1111
f'111111tfl.
111
'-"':.c..
I.-
.s- ,1it"
.,1
/(/2.
.,.;-
~~~~er,.,...
0
,,.,f
H,I
/N,
hll
r
,f
J
t.h , 1ul h1J •-' ( (pr n
- ,Ii«--
••
In
t ,n ,
1/.~rr tlr1• 11·r I
U-11,1 ~" ./. J,' TJL.U'A'll(•f,'
J
_,,J-.,
\
f'f,
' J/1,11.
fr 10Ar,
u, ·.,,,
,.,,,., tJ•r:,ir,u,IJ
,,-
,
,,f11tl ll"rl'
rif
~ 11/ r,11r• ,;d r, ,,,-t ,,;
JI,,, f
llu,i
11d //1 u "• t/,p
��In the Nun,c of the Commonwcul1h
fo rr1•p;-11r
/1f'{111'f'I flu-
u,,,,,,.
tl1n·,
,f, 11/
,l,ttt:Le of tJu
Ci,v,1;.0
ll,.e C,1url
T(J o'trlurk, ,,. n~.. 1m II,
ta lt'1rt,/11 m,it tl,r I rrlff., to "r.tl( t n. "o/'41I
,.,,u·I. r:~
1,. t Jla.l
L
wAo _,
f
Uwll
'A/!.
~ '
l!1/"";
Cr,mmo,,w"ultlt
,U ""'
,
wil4 ck.l'nfuuli~~•t fM'
w·~u,c.~"·
,I ,,._ lll,.,4.UKBl!Il.\;,,
,In!/ "'
of Virginia:
<"
rt
)d..¥~t'"
owr,
,,en~lt" ,,f .!'JtJO
mi~l,mr
/tlMtj/
m,t t•mlf ,nttl,rlf.,.
Vl,rk
.. l!J_,l ~ om/
of" o,o·
•
t.tel Otntrl, 11/ thr {o,o·i
.t. 1
11•;/~ 14
tfL if
,rtr,in.tl
tf th
ytttr
14·f/,t,
~«-u<?u ~
/JIJu•r, t}u
t'.11,111f(),ru•, nll.l,
,, . ctr,A.
��'
•
ConHnonweolth of Virginia. l T
,·t·
0
Rockingham County. I
·\\ 1 ·
81 1--rRnu
mt un tJw ..
11 tfttu
~'2
l'l"'l--!"A'~
,. twt>
1,,.for,
1111
l'
-~
;1_,r:::
•••
,,,_~-Z,{R.
,,.-;-11
•
l
L.J V :..l.:..L
11,,yuf___
1!1::!
~ ~ .!:_
"-~ ~,,p. Ur
ff:.'.~n. •~./:-•vod
..
'
___..f?.A((_(i.,
ill tl.11- '.>lUU of
@,i,g /:6-_t~~·~-.._,,,;f'
.; ....~,,-~
rollp,1n:o:.♦lt•l~lt1'41 frntu Ll.l•·ll\.>tu)-.,,t lhil" ~fllh·,
@__
~~,
J4
1(1
_~_z
lht· u~-
nr tL,·
, ., ffifll•Jf!\,1 iiJtb
,-r \·1tl.'IIU~ ir tl.e, ~.1
"-},:ill11111"•' ,Jt fonlt i.u th,· l"'rf11nn:111N•11{ thr
P(,ml1tions untJ, rwrhh•u.
m,,, tlu1 1l.1vun•I V••a.rth·~t :ii•••'"''1,·ri1tcu.
r.,_____----I~ --
";(,
lr,r#,,..._
�•
•
'
'
�.;,Co iaw rrvt~1:..,e,
tbu ao ...Ollset. to to
~ llt"il:st
to
&llai;
thu
cf
bli'dcu
tho
.repo"'1
c1Y11
he
r!ta1.e
&0<!0£ed
e4 ..:
7"ftlfw
hlrn un~.l
all
n1r
ot •vl!e;::L
... u
to
'c.-T"~-e
.,u•lt..
Jl
prov-,
reae r.Bb "' !; 1bt,
taJ.e .....t-. lt:-"i.tc:.t ...Al ~
~e. ,e
ttlS.6.
1& r•· ..-u! tr le
g,_11i,u ll'.{:I ::,c:.;.u"lllWlrltb
be:•om
... \.
1nn ..ce1 ..t
u&\
wl l s\t:fflo•,
lhCt B•.!Llt.
ta..
ba g!.l.:.lt.,,
r .. Lhe f:V14enco t.hat bc-1s ea.il~:'
but.
38 iv 11,e ~r
the
'boyou·l
!ur.i·
?.:.
cuttt
to be
~e
i;,,
11. enough t l'Bt l·.t .....:-iject~1rt.i
~, be su,.,_voaod. I,
t
i.~~h;..J6
:
l
£j1uc~lt.t
11
bo 84!.lsfJe-d
ree£.o.r..abl11 d,~ut~t.
91/ 75l
�•
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court: Criminal Cases
Description
An account of the resource
This series contains all criminal cases heard in Rockingham County from 1820 to 1971. The historical context contained within these records is rich, and one can expect to learn about various aspects concerning the social, cultural, and political climate of the day.
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
JMU Libraries
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1820-1971; currently digitized: 1820-1930.
Rights
Information about rights held in and over the resource
This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
PDF
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
Ccr001
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1924
Title
A name given to the resource
Commonwealth v. Dennis Shifflett
Description
An account of the resource
Defendant charged with felony assault.
Subject
The topic of the resource
Felony
Assault
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Rockingham County Criminal Court
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
JMU Libraries
Rights
Information about rights held in and over the resource
This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.<br /><a href="https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/</a>
Contributor
An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource
Jennifer Taylor
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
PDF
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
CCR001_008_263
Lucas
Shifflett